Woman’s Sister Sells Donated Clothes and Toys Can She Really Do That?

Imagine being in a tough financial situation and still finding it in your heart to help your well-off sister by giving her your son’s outgrown clothes and toys. Now, imagine discovering that she’s been selling those items for profit! One woman found herself in this exact predicament, and she’s wondering if she’s in the wrong for not wanting to give her sister any more of her son’s belongings. Let’s dive into this story and see what unfolds.

The Sister’s Request

A Generous Gesture

The Shocking Revelation

Confrontation Time

A Desperate Plea

Sister’s Response

A Compromise Suggestion

Sister’s Argument

Drawing the Line

Sister’s Accusation

The Financial Reality

The Dilemma

Update: Apology Received

A Change of Heart

The Sister’s True Nature

The Internet Weighs In on Sister’s Actions

So, what do people think about this situation? Is the sister in the wrong for selling the donated items, or is our protagonist being too controlling? Let’s see what the internet has to say about this family drama!

Don’t let entitled family members take advantage of you

Selling donated items? NTA says sell your son’s things too!

Sibling sells donated items, commenter suggests lying to avoid conflict.

Sister sells donated items without telling OP, sparks debate.

Sister sells donated clothes and toys, OP is NTA.

Generous mom’s donated clothes sold by ungrateful recipient

Sister sells donated items without permission. Not cool

Sister selling donated clothes and toys – bad etiquette or greed?

Sell what you don’t need, let her know politely

Donating to family doesn’t mean they can sell it

Betrayed by family Heartbreaking story of donated items sold.

Sister sells donated items, so commenter suggests charitable revenge.

Sibling rivalry over donated items sparks NTA response

Commenter defends selling donated items with sarcastic remark

Standing up for personal boundaries and choices

Sibling rivalry at its finest

Keeping donated clothes for future child, sister sells them instead.

NTA gifts have contexts, and depending on the context people might have reasonable expectations of how they’ll be used, and it can affect the relationships if those expectations are broken. Finding out they’ve been sold on Craigslist is a completely different matter, because it essentially means the person took communal property they didn’t pay into, took it out of the community, and made money off of it.

Keep sentimental toys for your son’s future, NTA comment suggests.

Donating doesn’t give ownership, but selling is questionable

Sister’s selling of donated items called out for greediness

Sister sells donated items, commenter shares relatable experience. ‍♀️

Next time, sell instead of gift to avoid sister’s reselling.

Stand up for yourself! Don’t let anyone profit from donations.

Redditor calls out sister’s behavior, verdict: Not the A-hole

Sister’s betrayal sparks sympathy for commenter

Commenter supports OP, calls sister ‘rude and entitled’

Sell donated items as your kid grows? NTA thinks so!

Sister sells donated clothes, refuses to return them. NTA upset.

Take back control! NTA has every right to sell.

Sister sells donated items for profit. NTA stands up.

Don’t let her get away with it! Stand your ground

Honesty is the best policy when it comes to donations

Sibling betrayal? Sister sells donated items meant for nephew

Sister sells donated items Commenter calls her out

Sister’s actions called absurd in clothing donation scandal

Commenter calls out entitled behavior.

Choosing between legality and morality

Sibling rivalry and entitlement issues

Marking hand-me-downs to return is common courtesy

Commenter calls out entitled parent for selling donated items

Sister sells donated items OP is NTA

Don’t let her take advantage of your generosity.

Don’t profit from donated items! NTA did the right thing

Commenter criticizes the rich for exploiting the poor’s donations

Sister sells donated clothes, gets upset when asked to donate. NTA

NTA. Sister selling donated goods for profit is selfish

Ignore her and move on. NTA has got this!

Family drama: Sister sells donated items without permission or profit share ‍♀️

Supportive comment with an apology for previous post

OP’s sister sells donated items Commenters sympathize.

Donated items sold by sister, commenter suggests profit-sharing. #NTA

Don’t be fooled by fake gratitude

Donating to family can be tricky NTA learns the hard way

Generosity should not be taken for granted. NTA for cutting ties

Your donated items, her right to sell. Your right to refuse.

Commenter is outraged at sister’s actions.

Sister sells donated items, commenter calls her greedy beyotch

Unexpected comment takes a wild turn

Supportive comment, hope for sister’s realization

Donation drama ends with a surprised Pikachu face.

Commenter finds humor in lack of juicy drama.