Imagine joking with your fiancée about a ‘hall pass’ before your wedding, only to have it backfire in the most spectacular way. That’s precisely what happened to this 27-year-old man when he made the colossal mistake of revealing his theoretical ‘hall pass’ choice would be his fiancée’s sister! Talk about a recipe for pre-wedding drama! Let’s dive into the story and see how this bombshell unfolded.
The ‘Hall Pass’ Joke

The Curiosity Begins

The Pressure to Reveal

The Awkward Rationalization

The Reluctant Confession

The Joke Turns Sour

The Unthinkable Happens

The Fallout Begins

The Double Standard?

Couch Surfing ️

A Pre-Wedding Disaster
So there you have it, folks! A seemingly harmless joke turned into a pre-wedding nightmare for this couple. The man’s choice of his fiancée’s sister as a ‘hall pass’ has left their relationship on rocky ground, with friends divided on whether he’s an a**hole or just plain stupid. As the dust settles, let’s see what the internet thinks of this explosive situation…
Man’s ‘hall pass’ choice backfires, labeled YTA and ‘stupid’

Choosing the fiancée’s younger sister as a ‘hall pass’? YTA ♂️

Naming a real-life person as a ‘hall pass’ is a bad idea . Commenters warn of potential implications on future children.

Commenter calls out OP’s creepy and sexist ‘hall pass’ request.

Fiancée called out for being insensitive and hurtful

Title says it all YTA for wanting fiancée’s sister.

YTA choice for ‘hall pass’ angers fiancée and commenters

Commenter calls out man for inappropriate comment about fiancée’s sister

Commenter calls out OP for choosing fiancee’s sister as hall pass

Fiancée devastated after ‘Hall Pass’ choice, commenters agree YTA

Engaged man jokes about wanting fiancée’s sister, both perpetuate it. ESH.

“Your sister” is not a valid hall pass choice

Commenter gets called out for inappropriate ‘hall pass’ choice
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/d7c090f2-7c04-4eda-834e-94be951a4592.png)
Commenter calls out OP as the a**hole. Ouch

Commenter calls out OP for ‘f*cked up’ behavior. Yikes

Commenter calls out ‘dude’ and deems him the a**hole ♀️

Ex hits on sister, commenter advises against it. YTA confirmed.

Red flags raised as commenter calls out OP’s ‘disgusting’ behavior

Commenter calls out ‘idiot’ with YTA verdict

Man’s ‘hall pass’ choice causes irreparable damage to relationship

Commenter ends engagement over ‘yikes’ hall pass choice

Man’s ‘Hall Pass’ choice backfires, sister rivalry ensues

Commenter thinks OP is in the wrong

YTA’s ‘Hall Pass’ choice leaves fiancée questioning relationship

Fiancée’s response to ‘Hall Pass’ choice is fiery

Comparing your partner to a younger version is a big no

Redditor calls out YTA for choosing fiancée’s sister in ‘hall pass’ game

Choosing a real person as a hall pass? YTA, dude. ♂️

Fiancée warns against ‘hall pass’, receives backhanded compliment in reply

Commenter calls out OP for being an ‘asshole’

Don’t tell your partner you’d rather bang their sister

Fiancée’s sister as hall pass? YTA and in deep trouble

Fiancée’s reaction to ‘Hall Pass’ joke is not forgiving

‘Hall Pass’ jokes are emotional chicken, someone always gets hurt. ♂️

Commenter calls out OP’s stupidity in hilarious way

Don’t need to read it, title says YTA. Keep it private.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3ccc57b6-109b-4a14-a9d4-aea5d2c429c1.png)
Commenter condemns marriage and calls out YTA with anger

Betraying trust and damaging relationships with YTA move.

ESH. Awkward family gatherings await both of you
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/c872936f-9247-4b3a-a88c-a3ffce0dfa93.png)
Choosing fiancée’s sister as hall pass? YTA, big time

User suggests a tool to make digging easier, defends OP’s actions.

Commenter calls out OP for choosing sister as ‘hall pass’
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/98b26a0f-d826-4144-b453-c5dd58c86cf5.png)
Man’s hall pass choice of fiancée’s sister deemed inappropriate

YTA for dehumanizing your gf and diminishing her sister.

Naming someone close as hall pass = incredibly stupid move

Commenter calls out OP for being the a**hole

Choosing a person you know for a hall pass? YTA ♂️

Commenter jokingly suggests post belongs in different subreddit.

YTA gets called out for suggesting a mutual acquaintance for ‘hall pass’
