Man proposes to girlfriend with family heirloom causing family drama

A man is facing backlash from some family members after choosing to propose to his girlfriend with a family heirloom instead of giving it to his daughter. The man’s mother gave him her engagement ring before she passed away, and he had been planning to use it to propose to his girlfriend of five years. However, his daughter assumed the ring would be hers, and was upset when he explained that it was not. Despite having other sentimental family heirlooms, the daughter and some family members are upset with the man’s decision. The controversy has caused a divide in the family, with some taking sides and others remaining neutral. Read on to find out more about this family dilemma.

Heirloom proposal causes family drama and daughter’s heartache ❤️

Proposal plans cause family drama, ex’s daughter involved

Family drama over heirloom ring proposal. Daughter upset.

Sentimental proposal causes family drama and heartache ❤️

Proposal with family heirloom sparks family drama. AITA?

Updates on the family drama unfold

A family heirloom proposal causing unnecessary drama

What’s the latest update on the family drama?

Family drama ensues after proposal, father intervenes in the situation.

Marine veteran father causes drama during proposal

Family drama surrounds proposal with heirloom ring.

Family drama ensues after heirloom proposal, entitlement causes tension ⚡

The dramatic end to a family heirloom proposal

Family feud over heirloom ring proposal, bride-to-be’s decision pending

Securing an heirloom: Couple includes ring in prenup for peace ☮️

Family drama ensues over heirloom ring proposal

Family drama resolved as Jane apologizes for her behavior

Family drama unfolds after heirloom proposal, stay tuned for updates

Possible baby on the way causing tension in the family

What’s the latest update on this family heirloom proposal drama?

Family heirloom ring causes drama over gender expectations for inheritance.

An heirloom ring with a hidden clause sparks family drama.

Family heirloom causes drama in marriage proposal

A man proposes to his girlfriend with his late mother’s engagement ring, causing his daughter to feel entitled to the ring. Despite having other heirlooms to give, the daughter is upset and talks to her uncle about it, causing family drama. After receiving backlash from some family members, the man seeks advice from his father, who supports his decision to give the ring to his girlfriend. The issue is eventually resolved by adding the ring to their will with a condition that it will be given back to the family if they divorce. In the meantime, the daughter apologizes for her behavior and Laura, the girlfriend, might be pregnant. The drama surrounding the engagement ring causes tension among family members but ultimately results in a solution that satisfies everyone involved.

Debate over who should inherit family heirloom ring, NTA wins.

Family drama over heirloom ring, suggestions for a duplicate ring exchange.

Daughter accuses father of being the a**hole for proposing with grandma’s ring instead of buying a new one, causing family drama. Replies defend father’s right to the ring and question daughter’s entitlement.

NTA. Family drama over heirloom engagement ring proposal.

Heirloom ring causes family drama; daughter disapproves of proposal. ‍♂️

Daughter upset over heirloom ring given to stepmom. YTA.

Using a family heirloom for proposal causes drama. YTA.

Navigating family drama over heirloom ring in proposal

Solving family drama with a simple ring-passing agreement

NTA for proposing with family heirloom causing drama

Choosing a family heirloom over your daughter’s happiness? YTA.

User points out OP’s lack of concern for daughter’s feelings

Man disregards daughter’s feelings in proposal, causing family tension

Family heirloom ring causes tension and YTA for not considering daughter.

Commenter accuses proposer of prioritizing self over child.

Debate over family heirlooms in engagement rings sparks controversy ⚔️

Ignoring his daughter’s feelings, OP proposes with family heirloom causing drama ‍♂️

“YTA” comment receives harsh but honest criticism from readers

16-year-old daughter upset over family heirloom engagement ring.

The fate of a family heirloom after divorce and family drama

Commenter calls out proposer as the a**hole, drama ensues

Commenter accuses parent of being the a**hole towards their child

Commenter calls out OP for being TA in proposal drama

The ring’s drama: Unveiling potential family conflicts

Navigating family drama over a family heirloom.

Future ring drama with fiancee and daughter, INFO requested

Navigating cultural differences in prenuptial agreements

User calls out OP for not considering daughter’s inheritance.

Stepmoms unite: both agree OP is YTA for proposing with heirloom

Proposing with a family heirloom causes family drama. Is it worth it?

Controversy over family heirloom ring in proposal. YTA or NAH?

Commenter changes judgement to YTA and predicts relationship issues.

Woman defends giving heirloom ring to ex’s son, sparks debate

Inheriting a family heirloom causes drama. NTA for keeping it.

Commenter warns about future family drama with heirloom ring

Family heirloom proposal drama: commenter defends rightful ring ownership.

Defending family heirloom, commenter says NTA with shocked emoji.

Commenter calls out OP’s behavior, sparking backlash

Family heirloom causes conflict in proposal

Curious about the family drama surrounding heirloom transfer.

Family drama ensues over heirloom engagement ring

OP receives soft YTA for not protecting family heirloom properly

Commenter calls out proposal for selfishness, receives agreement from reply.

Commenter empathizes with Jane’s situation.

Family drama ensues over heirloom ring’s future.

Inheritance drama: Daughter not entitled to family heirloom

Engagement ring debate: Who gets to keep the family heirloom?

Be transparent with Laura and solve the problem together.

Commenter calls out father for lack of care towards daughter.

Daughter calls out father for not asking her opinion on heirloom.

Commenter calls out OP for being a cowardly a**hole.

Daughter upset after father gave fiance heirloom ring. YTA.

Navigating family drama over an heirloom engagement ring

Defending the proposal and questioning double standards.

Engaged OP dismisses daughter’s feelings over family heirloom, ESH.

A family heirloom causes drama, but was it intended for proposal?