♂️ Buckle up, folks! We’ve got a tail-wagging tale of family drama, tradition, and a man’s love for his feline friend! Our protagonist finds himself in the doghouse with his in-laws for not wanting to continue a long-standing family tradition of adopting a golden retriever. Instead, he’s taken in a sweet, abandoned cat who’s stolen his heart. But his MIL is having none of it! Get ready for a wild ride as we dive into this paw-some story!
Not a Dog Person… But a Cat Guy?

A Purrfect Past Experience

In-Laws Insist on Family Tradition!

♂️ No Dogs Allowed! MIL Shocked!

Enter: Lil Mama, the Abandoned Cat

Feline Friend Finds Forever Home

Nextdoor Neighbors Reveal Sad Past

Purrfect Relationship: Cat Naps & Knitting

MIL’s Dramatic Reaction to Lil Mama!

MIL Questions Manhood Over Cat Preference!

MIL’s Bizarre Facebook Posts

Friends Suggest Unwanted ‘Gift’

Firm Stance: No Dogs Allowed! ♂️

♂️ Even Friends Think It’s Weird!

AITA for Ending Family Dog Tradition?

Cat-astrophe: Man Breaks Family Dog Tradition, Faces MIL’s Wrath!
Our cat-loving hero finds himself in a furry fiasco when he refuses to continue his in-laws’ 5-generation tradition of adopting a golden retriever. Instead, he’s taken in a sweet, abandoned cat named Lil Mama. But his MIL is having a hissy fit, questioning his manhood and even suggesting friends gift them a dog against their wishes! ♂️ The internet is divided, with some calling him a cruel a**hole for not loving dogs. Others think it’s weird he won’t just give in and get a pup. ♂️ Let’s see what the internet has to say about this cat-vs-dog debacle! Will our protagonist stand his ground and keep his beloved feline friend, or will he be hounded into submission by his MIL and the dog-loving masses? The suspense is killing us!
When in doubt, microchip the cat and claim ownership.

NTA. MIL is batshit insane for threatening to get rid of your cat

In-laws upset over cat vs. dog tradition – NTA prevails

Choosing a pet caused family feud despite being NTA

Protective cat owners unite against outraged in-laws! ♀️

NTA comment shuts down in-laws’ ridiculous dog tradition.

In-laws outraged over dog tradition, but commenter calls NTA

Pet lover defends husband’s choice of cat over family dog tradition

In-laws outraged over dog tradition, but NTA for choosing cat

Confused commenter questions relevance of post, sparks no replies.

In-laws demand dog ownership, commenter suggests cutting contact.

Breaking tradition with a cat? NTA, not a big deal! �skin-tone-3

Secure in masculinity: Man defends cat over dog tradition. NTA.

Choosing pets is a personal decision, but we need cat tax
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/72e43445-1170-4c89-b9f2-ceccee7638e1.png)
NTA, your home, your harmless preference, and none of anyone else’s business

Should the breeder be held responsible for family drama?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/2539b433-b15e-47fd-8617-6cd188100ad5.png)
Sarcastic reply to in-laws’ outrage over cat vs dog tradition.

NTA. Traditions should be positive. Let your wife handle it.

Embrace the cat love! No need to compromise. NTA

In-laws mad over dog? NTA says respect or duck off.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/4a0a0d50-f862-4ca9-a516-48892bb79ccb.png)
NTA for choosing cat over family dog tradition!

Cat-loving men are hot . It’s okay to not like dogs. NTA.

NTA for choosing not to get a dog. Tradition shouldn’t dictate pets
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/6e863772-b95b-4687-b668-77777bf01a3f.png)
Supportive comment defends OP from overbearing in-laws with humor

Cat vs. dog debate sparks controversy. NTA defends feline companions.

Choose pets wisely, not blindly for traditions. NTA here
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/1b957b90-ad18-4f78-9872-d5669012dfd3.png)
Shots fired! This commenter calls out the in-laws’ behavior.

NTA. MIL is insane. Family tradition is not more important.

Family pressures OP to choose dog tradition over spouse’s preference. NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/b2a8dfbb-0f1b-4129-8288-05713ba98039.png)
Family tradition ruined by a feline? NTA, says commenter.

In-laws outraged over cat vs dog. Commenter says NTA.

Choosing a cat over a dog? NTA! Stand your ground.

When NTA turns into ‘restraining order’…

Cat vs dog debate sparks intense reaction. NTA’s frustration resonates.

Defending the cat and calling out a crazy MIL

Choosing a cat over a dog? NTA, dogs are a huge responsibility ♂️
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/fa890a36-2185-458c-a3e8-dcf1ffa08333.png)
NTA for choosing cat over dog. Dog culture has gone overboard

Passionate defense of cats over dogs sparks controversy

NTA. Pets shouldn’t be forced on people. Same goes for kids.

NTA stands firm against in-law’s dog tradition

Challenging traditional family values sparks controversy ⚡

Choosing cats over dogs – fair or unfair? NTA thinks so.

Choose the pet you want, not what your in-laws want

Defending not getting a dog? NTA! In-laws, chill
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/94b781fd-b32f-4b4d-bcea-b04a66057689.png)
Choosing a cat over a dog tradition: NTA and catifying FTW!

Breaking tradition or peer pressure? A refreshing insight.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/2198f539-2792-4cb4-b4bd-c3e3a1ce5f79.png)
NTA defends husband’s decision and highlights MIL’s poor attitude towards animals.

In-laws slammed for implying manhood linked to dog preference

Choosing a cat over a dog: NTA, but outdoor cats?

Dog lover defends husband’s choice of cat over family tradition

Cat lover defends actions and suspects in-laws of foul play.

Knitting skills praised as commenter sides with poster against MIL.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/8ee89aea-87e1-4e7c-8472-cb238bc27f5c.png)
Dog lover defends husband’s choice over in-laws’ pressure

In-laws outraged as husband chooses cat over family dog

Keep the cat and forget the tradition!

Dog lover defends husband’s choice and calls out family’s ignorance.

NTA defends choosing cat over dog tradition, calls in-laws weird.

Formally adopt the cat and tell them to sod off!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/427f2052-5b0d-404a-956d-324a1aca1403.png)
Being a responsible pet owner matters more than family tradition.

Breaking gender roles > living by in-law’s dictates!

Choose the cat , MIL is a huge AH ♀️

NTA! Cat > dog. MIL’s crazy.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/6057ad91-0c34-4752-9833-164f024615b9.png)
NTA stands his ground against sexist in-laws over family pet ♂️

In-laws go crazy over cat vs dog; commenter advises caution.

Choosing cats over dogs: furry roommates or man’s best friend?

NTA! Owning a pet is a huge responsibility

Pet ownership is a personal choice, don’t let others dictate

Suggests calling breeder to prevent in-laws’ dumbfuckery.

Dogs are more work than cats, SO understands. In-laws overreacting.

Owning a dog is hard work and not for everyone

NTA, cats over dogs is a personal preference. MIL is crazy

Last Updated on March 21, 2024 by Diply Social Team