Buckle up, folks! We’ve got a heart-wrenching tale of love, loss, and baby names that’ll have you on the edge of your seat. Meet our grieving mama, who tragically lost her husband to COVID-19 while pregnant. Her MIL had the brilliant idea to name the baby after the late hubby, and in an emotional haze, our protagonist agreed. But wait, there’s a twist! When baby boy arrived, mama had a change of heart. Will she stick to the promise or forge a new path for her little one? Get ready for a rollercoaster ride of family drama, broken promises, and a Facebook announcement that’ll leave you shook!
Tragedy Strikes: Losing My Husband to COVID-19

MIL’s Emotional Request: Naming Baby After Late Husband

Baby Arrives: A Change of Heart on the Name

Surprise Announcement: Introducing Baby “Lucas” on Facebook

MIL’s Confrontation: “Why Did You Break Your Promise?”

Painful Memories: Calling Husband’s Name Hurts Too Much

MIL’s Accusation: “Disrespectful to Your Husband’s Memory” ♀️

️ Standing My Ground: “I Don’t Owe Anyone Anything”

MIL’s Ultimatum: “I Don’t Even Want to See My Grandson Now”

AITA for Breaking My Promise? Seeking Honest Opinions

⏰ Clarification: I Didn’t Wait Months to Change My Mind! ⌛

Hurtful Comments: “You Deserved to Lose Your Husband”? How Dare You!

️ Asking for Bluntness Doesn’t Mean Being R**e!

Broken Promises & Baby Name Drama: Will This Grieving Mama Honor Her Late Husband?
Well, well, well… the internet has spoken, and boy, do they have some thoughts! Our protagonist finds herself in a sticky situation after breaking her promise to name her baby after her late husband. MIL is furious, accusing her of disrespecting hubby’s memory. But Mama stands her ground, claiming she doesn’t owe anyone anything. Some folks are throwing shade, saying she deserved to lose her husband (ouch!), while others are more understanding. Let’s see what juicy responses the internet has cooked up for this baby name debacle! Grab your popcorn, ’cause this is gonna be a wild ride!
ESH but a little kindness could have spared stress and pain

No a****e here. MIL was wrong to influence name choice.

Mom-in-law is called out for being an A**hole

Using Facebook to announce this was a bad move, YTA.

Woman calls out MIL for lack of empathy after name change.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/5d6e1385-fa53-4fdf-acac-7918818c8ce6.png)
Naming baby caused rift between DIL and MIL. ESH.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/00f14290-a48b-4dd0-ae23-529b71b84493.png)
Is the MIL justified in feeling disrespected about the name change?

YTA called out for poor communication and lack of consideration

Naming baby after late husband, but not telling MIL first. YTA.

Both sides grieving, hopefully they’ll come to a resolution ❤

Inquiring about the late husband’s full name and legacy.

Widow chooses not to name son after late husband. NTA.

Naming your son is okay, but try to handle the situation better

MIL had good intentions, but OP could have handled better
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/c068686f-06c9-4d1a-9b79-aa065999978a.png)
NAH. Both parties are grieving and coping in their own way. ♡

Changing the baby name without reaching out was disrespectful. YTA

NTA. Empowerment to the new mom for making her own choice.

Promising to name after husband then saying ‘just MIL’ YTA

MIL accuses DIL of disrespecting baby name change on Facebook

Prioritizing grief over a grandchild’s name? NTA according to commenter.

NAH, but revealing the change on FB was not cool

Changing the baby’s name without telling her was cruel. NAH.

MIL’s grief and love for her child should not be dismissed.

Communication is key! ESH for Facebook reveal and lack of communication.

Name change causes family drama, commenters weigh in

Widow chooses not to name son after late husband

MIL prioritizes grief over DIL’s baby name change, NTA wins

Choosing a different name protects the child from projecting grief. NTA.

User calls out OP for not telling MIL about name change

YTA. She’s the grandmother of your child. Imagine how your husband would feel to hear you be dismissive of his mother. She’s grieving and might not be reasonable, but you treating her like this is truly awful.

Naming a child after a deceased relative can lead to self-esteem issues. NTA.

NTA but explain your reasoning earlier to avoid conflict with MIL ❤️

MIL shocked by Facebook baby name change, NTA

NTA. Commenter sympathizes with OP’s grieving and changing views, criticizes MIL’s behavior.

Naming a child is your choice, but changing it after loss

Grief is complex. Both MIL and DIL deserve grace

Naming baby caused a MIL vs DIL feud. YTA or not?

NTA stands up for their baby’s name against critical MIL.

Communication is key. NTA but could have handled better.

NAH commenter suggests gentler approach to name change situation.

Parenting advice: apologize to MIL for renaming baby, lead by example

NAH verdict reached, with emphasis on empathy and boundaries.

Changing the baby’s name on FB without telling MIL first? YTA

Navigating grief is difficult, but it does change over time ✨

MIL’s reaction to baby name change sparks YTA judgement.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3876c757-66a5-45a6-afdc-a25f0860f6b6.png)
Facebook oversharing causes family feud over baby name change.

Changing a baby’s name through Facebook? YTA for the disrespectful approach.

Compassionate response acknowledges MIL’s feelings but calls out overreaction. ❤
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/45964e02-95eb-491f-99a1-92a484fcea72.png)
YTA called out for disrespecting daughter-in-law’s baby name change

Choosing a baby name is personal. NTA for changing it.

Changing the baby’s name without telling her was insensitive

Choosing a baby name to honor a deceased loved one?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/20412c59-5e8c-4245-925f-f9f142ae86ea.png)
Naming baby without informing DIL: NTA, but add husband’s name?

Changing your baby’s name doesn’t make you the a**hole. ♀️

YTA for not telling DIL in person about name change.

NTA. MIL should not have strong armed you into anything.

NTA. You don’t owe anyone anything when it comes to naming.

Grandma’s petty response to baby name change. NTA OP

A comment advocating for communication and empathy between families.

NTA for not naming baby after dead parent. Middle name option.

Supportive comment: NTA. Grieve and raise your son your way.

Mother’s right to name son after husband, despite MIL’s reaction ✌️

Stand your ground! Your child, your choice.

Compassionate reply urges empathy and private communication for grieving family.

NTA for changing baby name but ESH for not informing beforehand. MIL’s reaction is way over the top

Compassionate NTA comment suggests patience and grace for grieving MIL.

Grieving in-law suggests courteous communication after baby name change

MIL’s pain and grandmotherhood undermine YTA’s Facebook reveal.

Golden rule reminder: Treat others as you wish to be treated.
ESH.

Finding closure after losing a partner is complicated, NTA.

NTA, You gave him the chance to be his own person

A heartfelt NTA comment on naming a baby after a deceased loved one.

Supporting NTA, commenter suggests seeking professional help for better insights.

Grieving widow stands up to manipulative MIL over baby’s name
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/340430d2-89c9-4670-858b-67bf18a39e2f.png)
Supportive comment with advice on communication and consideration.

YTA breaks promise to MIL and dishonors son’s father. AH move

Suggests a memory box project for healing after naming dispute. ❤️

NTA, but could have handled it better

NTA. MIL needs therapy. Raise your child to honor his father.

NAH. MiL deserved to be informed in a better way

Healthy relationship and boundaries key in MIL-DIL conflict

Processing grief and communication could have helped avoid conflict

NAH. Miscommunication leads to difficult time for both families

NAH on name change, but MIL deserved better announcement method.

OP is called out for being an a**hole. Yikes.

Last Updated on May 16, 2024 by Diply Social Team