Buckle up, folks! We’ve got a juicy story about a man, his ex, his current girlfriend, and a adorable pup named Shadow. This tale is full of twists, turns, and a whole lot of drama! Our protagonist finds himself caught between his past and present, trying to navigate the choppy waters of love, loyalty, and puppy custody. Will he be able to keep everyone happy, or will this doggy dilemma tear his relationships apart? Let’s dive in and find out! ♂️
A Puppy Named Shadow
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/145a487c-7537-4c66-8995-e07676ac90a4.png)
♂️ Trying My Best, But Feeling Aloof
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/77ae4a6f-a11c-4cd8-a9b5-30319d92488e.png)
Financial Struggles & Apartment Woes
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/dccc04f0-521a-4e42-b8d7-3e81de317ec4.png)
⏰ Years Later, Shadow Visits
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/1074e601-20aa-4bda-b5b8-a46a703e87cc.png)
Mental Health & Income Instability
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/67440558-0df7-4cac-a05a-19284b54315f.png)
New Girlfriend, New Questions
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/facd9f63-d5f0-49f9-b4e5-a3438119bc0a.png)
Shadow’s Happiness Comes First
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/9f45d10f-6f3e-4612-ba63-97b96af55282.png)
Annoyed at the Bargaining Chip
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/dd809b1b-4b72-4655-943a-19e2a23d717e.png)
♀️ Girlfriend’s Silent Treatment
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/fdfd35fb-f09f-4c11-a7be-8cbb1c313116.png)
Puppy Drama: Man Caught Between Ex and Current GF!
Well, well, well… looks like our protagonist is in quite the pickle! He’s stuck between his ex, who’s got custody of their beloved pup Shadow, and his current girlfriend, who’s green with envy over the whole situation. It’s a classic case of ‘he said, she said,’ with accusations of lingering love and taking sides flying left and right. Our poor guy just wants what’s best for Shadow, but his girlfriend seems more interested in marking her territory. Can you blame her, though? It’s a rough situation! Let’s see what the internet has to say about this paw-some predicament!
Dog custody battle: NTA for choosing pup over ex-girlfriend

Mental health struggles and relationship red flags

NTA. Don’t date someone who treats dogs like trophies.

Mature co-parenting wins, girlfriend’s insecurities lose ♂️

Avoid getting a dog with a manipulative girlfriend. NTA.

New girlfriend wants ex’s dog, internet agrees: get new girlfriend

Don’t date jealous, controlling girls like this. NTA

NTA made responsible decision for dog and mental health, girlfriend unsupportive

Stand your ground and prioritize your dog’s happiness!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/879c0e3c-7db7-4e4b-b593-f91fe43d8b3b.png)
Keeping the dog with ex was the right choice. Girlfriend’s jealousy.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3bdbf1f1-81ca-4a18-b2d6-1223af9f8a64.png)
Girlfriend’s possessiveness not good for the dog or relationship.

Navigating emotions in relationships – understanding vs defensiveness

Girlfriend wants ex’s dog? NTA says she’s unreasonable

Girlfriend demands dog theft, commenter calls out absurdity. NTA.

Ex left the dog for a reason. NTA for prioritizing dog’s welfare

Current GF insecure about ex’s dog visits. NTA for caring.

NTA. Keeping the dog would only cause you to lose out.

Think twice before getting a dog or kids with her

Mature decision to let ex keep dog, GF immature for rehoming
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/a4cf2bfc-69ef-4f7b-8ff2-e71d3ba6fcc9.png)
Red flags in a new relationship? Watch out!

Supportive comment encourages reevaluating unhealthy relationship.

New girlfriend wants dog back from ex? Not cool.

Current girlfriend not a good fit for a dog owner

NTA wants to see Shadow, not the ex. Dog tax!

Let the dog stay with the ex for its own good

Commitment issues? NTA for not keeping promise to gf.

Jealous girlfriend wants ex gone, not the dog. NTA.

Dump the crazy girlfriend and keep Shadow!

Girlfriend wants dog back for wrong reasons. Not the A-hole.

Silent treatment is abusive Find someone mature to date
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/c977d449-c469-4311-b5b9-d580d3893371.png)
Choosing between ex and current girlfriend over dog. NTA.

Supportive comment advises to prioritize mental health over girlfriend’s demands.

Girlfriend’s jealousy could lead to a disastrous future.

Current girlfriend is being petty and childish.

Ditch the gf ❤️ . Keep the doggy visits ❤️

NTA. Mature decision, girlfriend needs to grow up and accept it.

Current girlfriend’s insecurity causes drama over ex’s dog

Girlfriend’s jealousy puts dog’s well-being at risk. NTA.

NTA bro, it’s a lady Jedi mind trick

Dodged a bullet NTA, let her go silent

When joint custody of a dog seems like still being in love with your ex

Prioritizing your happiness and the dog’s well-being is important.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/0150499a-4f13-43b9-8873-4132ef3a7020.png)
GF demands dog back from ex, comment calls her entitled

Dog custody drama sparks debate among commenters.

User questions OP’s ability to care for dog, deems them YTA

Ex’s dog causes ex drama, but NTA for keeping pup

Jealousy and red flags: NTA should be wary

Ex-girlfriend causing drama over dog custody. NTA.

Girlfriend’s insecurity leads to invented reason for argument. NTA.

Being mature and responsible or keeping the flame burning? NTA

Ex’s dog, NTA. GF’s demands = red flag.

Don’t get a dog with someone who puts their wants first

Dump her! NTA deserves better. Don’t tolerate possessiveness

Exes visiting pets can be sweet

Keeping the peace: NTA’s ex arrangement works for everyone

Girlfriend demands dog back from ex, NTA but run away!

Responsible pet parenting: NTA for doing what’s best

Insecurity at its finest. NTA, you’ve done nothing wrong.

Making the best decision for your furry friend

NTA. Commenter suggests reconsidering insecure girlfriend with red flags

User advises OP to reconsider relationship with unstable girlfriend.

Girlfriend wants dog back, but commenter advises staying firm.
