Christmas is supposed to be the season of giving and love, but one woman’s dilemma is stirring up quite the drama. She and her husband buy gifts for all the kids in their family, but this year, they’re at odds over how much to spend on their nephew, L, whose family is struggling financially. While the woman wants to spend less on L’s gift because his parents can’t reciprocate, her husband argues that L deserves a nice Christmas too.
The Annual Gift-Giving Tradition
The Kids and Their Gifts
The Sibling Group
The Only Child U(6)
The Struggling Family
The Cheap Gift Dilemma
Husband’s Argument for a Better Gift
The Emotional Impact
The Compromise
Update and More Context
Financial Help for L’s Family
The Gift Exchange Tradition
The Plan for L and His Family
Frustration Over L’s Mother
The Elitist Attitude?
The Great Christmas Gift Debate: Who’s in the Wrong?
This woman’s Christmas gift dilemma has everyone talking. She and her husband can’t agree on how much to spend on their nephew, L, who comes from a struggling immigrant family. While she initially opts for a cheaper gift, her husband insists that L deserves a nice Christmas too. In the end, she compromises and spends more on L’s gift, but the emotional impact of their disagreement lingers. As the debate continues, we’ve gathered the top responses from the internet to weigh in on this festive family feud.
RELATED STORIES
Outrage over unequal Christmas gifts. Commenters agree, YTA.
YTA for calculating gifts based on what you receive. Shameful behavior.
OP is called out for being a selfish and cruel Scrooge
Treating someone lesser because they’re poor is textbook evil
YTA gets called out for unequal Christmas gifts
Equal budget for all kids outside the home. YTA.
Commenter calls out OP for classism and is not holding back
Commenter calls out selfish gift-giving, gets Grinch comparison.
Don’t be a Grinch! YTA for giving unequal Christmas gifts
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/138c3112-d93d-40ae-90f0-1fe5137cdbf6.png)
Commenter accuses woman of being TA and harboring resentment.
Atheists aren’t heartless, it’s about being a decent human being ❤️
Being stingy for no reason and singling out kids? YTA.
A comment about the true meaning of Christmas sparks debate.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/f6741917-b306-4f7a-8a82-c48a643526eb.png)
Commenter calls out entitlement, husband’s upbringing mentioned in replies
Commenter calls out gift-giving injustice with fiery language
Commenter and replies express disgust towards OP’s unequal gift giving.
Commenter calls out OP for being TA in unequal gift-giving
The true meaning of Christmas is giving without expecting anything back ❤️
Commenter shuts down troll with fiery response
Commenter called out for selfish gift-giving mindset
Commenter calls out selfish gift-giving, sparks political discussion
OP is called out for being a Scrooge this Christmas
Commenter receives overwhelming judgement with YTA verdict.
Commenter calls out terrible behavior with shock and disgust
Insensitive gift-giver shamed for lack of empathy and compassion
Commenter calls out OP for being judgmental and calculating
Commenter calls out gift-giving cruelty during Christmas. YTA verdict.
Woman receives backlash for selfish Christmas gift giving. YTA.
Commenter accused of being clueless in gift giving etiquette.
Commenter calls out selfish gift-giving with a YTA verdict.
Don’t be a Grinch: Commenter calls out unequal gift-giving attitude
Don’t be a Grinch! YTA for punishing a kid for his family’s financial situation.
User refuses to buy Christmas gifts for financially struggling child. YTA.
Christian love? More like Christian hate. YTA comment.
User calls out YTA for lack of empathy towards struggling family
Don’t be a Grinch! Gift giving is about generosity
Don’t punish a child for their mother’s actions. YTA.
Don’t punish a child for their parents’ inability to gift back. YTA
Don’t be a Grinch this Christmas! Spread love and joy equally.
Insensitive gift-giving sparks outrage, YTA called out
Entitled woman shames poor child for not giving her gifts YTA
Redditors call for harsher judgement on YTA comment
Don’t be a Grinch! Spread the joy of gift giving without thinking about money. YTA.
Generosity over reciprocity. YTA insinuated poor kid undeserving of gifts.
Commenter calls out OP for bad behavior.
Don’t be a Grinch this holiday season
Commenter calls out gift-giver for missing the point of Christmas
Commenter finds article difficult to read and deems person in the story as YTA.
Don’t be a Grinch! Consider the joy of giving.
Commenter calls out AH for unequal Christmas gifts
Commenter calls out OP for bad attitude towards gift giving.
Gift giving shouldn’t be transactional
Commenter calls out absurdity of unequal Christmas gifts, deems OP YTA
Commenter calls out OP for bad attitude, compares to ex-wife.
Commenter calls out selfish gift-giving parent with a YTA verdict
YTA for unequal Christmas gifts. Get all nieces/nephews equal presents.
Don’t punish a child for his parents’ financial situation.
Generosity is key Don’t be a Scrooge this Christmas
Commenter calls out gift-greed with fiery insult
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/7e81af7b-95ad-4718-abd2-98843e481810.png)
Don’t be a Grinch this Christmas! Spread kindness instead
