Picture this: you’re living in a small one-bedroom apartment with your historian fiance who specializes in Germany from 1930-1960. Naturally, you’ve got some controversial books on your shelves, but they’re all for academic purposes. One day, your brother and his girlfriend come over for a visit and end up staying the night. The next morning, the girlfriend is in a terrible mood and leaves abruptly. Later, your brother confronts you about the books, demanding an apology and calling them inappropriate. What do you do? Well, let’s dive into this wild story and find out!
Tiny Apartment Life
The Bookshelves
Historian Fiance
Specializing in Germany
The Controversial Books
No Souvenirs
Family Visit ️
Morning Drama ☕
The Confrontation
Family Knowledge
Ironic Situation
Reading Skills
Childish Outrage
Father’s Reaction
Additional Info
Book Drama in a Historian’s Home
Our protagonist lives with their historian fiance, who has a collection of controversial books for academic purposes. When the protagonist’s brother and his girlfriend spend the night, they discover the books and are not happy. The girlfriend storms out the next morning, and the brother later confronts our protagonist, demanding an apology and calling the books inappropriate. Our protagonist, puzzled by the situation, points out that the girlfriend should have read the covers, which clearly state they are critical views on the manuscripts. They call the outrage childish and tell their brother to call them when both of them grow up. Since then, the protagonist’s mother has been hounding them, while their father finds the whole situation hilarious. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this bookish drama…
RELATED STORIES
Historian’s bookshelf causes family drama , but ignoring history’s errors is worse. Brother and GF missed the obvious, NTA.
Engaging with opposing views is important. NTA.
Teaching history to not repeat it
NTA, but brother and gf’s reaction shows why social issues persist
NTA. Brother and gf are ignorant. Historian fiance has right books.
Academic vs. racist texts: Ignorance demands no apology
Curiosity about brother’s GF’s religion sparks discussion on bookshelf uproar
Understanding bad ideas is crucial for supporting good ideas
Career-related books in one’s own home, NTA according to commenter.
Defending historian’s bookshelf sparks insightful discussion. NTA.
Don’t let book-haters win! Stand your ground. #NTA
As a historian, displaying Mein Kampf is important. NTA
Defending husband’s bookshelf against family’s cultural ignorance
Don’t judge a book by its cover, take time to understand
Not the a**hole! Hilarious and educational, haters gonna hate
500+ books on Nazi Germany, maintenance workers judge. NTA.
Defending the right to choose own bookshelf
German historian defends importance of studying history, criticizes book censorship
Research books called ‘nazis’? NTA deserves a huge apology!
Don’t remain ignorant of the past, NTA sparks interesting convo
Defending father’s humor and OP’s emotional response
SIL fails to grasp context, commenter says NTA.
Well-handled response to needless family drama
The evil and boring book that caused uproar
Sassy sibling and supportive dad defend historian. NTA
Defending personal space and education with books
Open-mindedness over comfort zones. Education over delusion. NTA
History professor defends interest in Nazis
NTA. The irony of calling for book removal in historical context
No symbols, no problem: NTA comment shuts down drama
NTA defends freedom of speech and triggers a sensitive reader
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/5ead4a4e-e8e9-4602-962b-c7fa38998790.png)
A couple’s sketchy book collection causes uproar, NTA for having them
Brother’s GF criticized historian’s bookshelf, comment defends.
Uninviting narcissistic morons over a bookshelf win
Defending historical significance of personal book collection
Family keepsakes don’t equal condoning history
Don’t judge a book by its cover: NTA wins!
Sibling defends historian against virtue signalling accusation. No AH here.
Historian’s fiancé throws tantrum over bookshelf, commenter says NTA
Historian’s bookshelf causes family drama, but commenter supports OP
Uncomfortable books are needed for a full scope of history
Defending historian’s bookshelf from unnecessary offense
Owning a controversial book doesn’t make you a bad person
Unresolved family tension over brother’s insult to fiancé ♀️
Understanding academic work can be difficult, NTA here
Knowing history can prevent repetition. Brother, gf, and mom are AH.
Assertive comment defends homeowner’s rights with a touch of sass
Guests overstep boundaries by judging host’s bookshelf
Don’t let her stir drama and drive a wedge
NTA. Being a proper historian involves confronting uncomfortable truths.
Preserving history vs. personal comfort: A house divided ♂️
Dad’s bookshelf causes uproar – commenter stands with him
Celebrate freedom of expression!
NTA defends historian’s bookshelf; girlfriend overreacts to history.
NTA historian defends bookshelf, educates brother’s girlfriend on historical research.
Understanding the context of the historian’s bookshelf
Unreasonable demand for apology over historian’s bookshelf. NTA
Historian’s GF acts like a child over book choice. NTA.
Having multiple religious texts on a historian’s bookshelf causes uproar . Commenter relates and says NTA, have a laugh and move on ♀️.
Reader finds humor in family drama, defends historian’s bookshelf.
Standing up to cancel culture with a supportive dad
Jewish historian defends fiancé against baseless N**i accusations
Reading from others’ perspectives is important to understand history. NTA
Critical analysis of harmful rhetoric is essential in countering bigotry.
Respect boundaries, mind your own business.
Passionate historian defends book collection with personal connection. NTA
Preserving history is crucial. NTA for keeping the bookshelf
NTA – Historian’s bookshelf causes family drama
Sibling feud over historian’s bookshelf, commenter defends spouse’s career.
