Imagine being born on Halloween and having a tradition of throwing Halloween-themed birthday parties every year. Sounds like a blast, right? Well, not everyone is thrilled about it. Meet our birthday girl (14F) and the new girl at school, ‘Hannah’ (15F). When the birthday girl announces her plans for a Halloween party this year, Hannah accuses her of copying her own party idea from May. The drama unfolds as friends take sides and the birthday girl faces a tough decision.
Halloween Birthday Tradition
New Girl ‘Hannah’ ♀️
Party Planning Talk
Hannah’s Accusation
Birthday Girl’s Defense ️
Hannah’s Confusion
Friend’s Input ️
More Confusion
Copycat Accusations
Friends Take Sides
Birthday Girl’s Dilemma
Edit: Decision Time ⏳
Copycat Clash: The Halloween Party Showdown
Our birthday girl is torn between sticking to her Halloween party tradition and giving in to the new girl’s demands. With friends taking sides and the clock ticking, she’s leaning towards keeping her spooky celebration. Will the copycat accusations haunt her forever, or will the two Halloween enthusiasts find a way to coexist? Let’s see what the internet thinks of this sticky situation…
RELATED STORIES
Celebrate Halloween twice? Complete win! NTA, have fun
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/1b7f1da8-a4b4-481e-a84d-90c42cdb6e41.png)
NTA for correcting friend’s wrong Halloween date and party month.
Copycat drama at a Halloween birthday party. NTA.
Birthday girl shuts down newbie’s Halloween party, gets support
Throw the party and enjoy! NTA
Themed parties for parents’ birthdays, cool family tradition
Having two parties is a great idea
Celebrate your birthday without entitled people!
No dibs on themes, even if it’s your birthday ♀️
Orthodox Christmas Eve birthday girl defends Halloween party, receives birthday wishes
Get creative with your birthday party themes
Halloween birthdays deserve double the fun
Newbie accused of copying party, but NTA. Explanation given.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/e11746b2-a93a-45f9-ad07-4b589e3e96d7.png)
NTA, honey. Your birthday is Halloween, which is cool. Her birthday is May, and she has a Halloween birthday, which is cool. No one gets to dictate how another person celebrates their birthday.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/9f331abd-b28d-416b-9d8f-fa0c09cdb34b.png)
Celebrate your Halloween Bday and ignore the petty newbie
Gatekeeping Halloween? Not cool. NTA for choosing your own theme
Commenter points out grade school level knowledge, gets corrected.
NTA suggests googling Halloween for birthday party, gets agreement.
Birthday girl’s claim to Halloween party superiority is mocked
Commenter recalls Halloween mistake, calls out girl’s ignorance
Not the a**hole, but what sparked the clash?
Teen drama immortalized online, NTA says it’s trivial.
Birthday girl defends Halloween party date with Salem enthusiast
NTA comment receives no replies
Celebrate your birthday your way Ignore the drama!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/5c171cba-e6d4-4b11-a714-819e953a4286.png)
Birthday girl celebrates with Halloween party, jealous friend objects. NTA.
Don’t let the newbie bring you down. Happy Halloween Birthday!
Not the a**hole, but what happened at the party?
Birthday girl gets support for blowout party. Let’s celebrate
Hannah needs to chill, NTA has it under control
An American chimes in to support the OP’s Halloween party plans
46 and still a Halloween queen! Shut that brat up
Stand your ground! You have every right to party.
Double the Halloween fun, no a**holes in sight!
Birthday girl shuts down Halloween party critic, NTA
NTA and a Halloween costume dilemma
Don’t let her ruin your spooky birthday!
Don’t let a birthday ruin Halloween! NTA wins
Celebrate your birthday and Halloween, NTA has got your back!
NTA stands up for Halloween-themed birthday party
Avoid Hannah, she’s willfully ignorant and entitled. NTA.
Halloween babies unite! NTA, celebrate your birthday however you want!
Birthday girl gets Halloween party revenge, no regrets
Hannah gets shut down with a not-so-subtle NTA
Don’t let her dim your party spirit!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/f5969dd0-2a73-424a-8600-235b91fff9f0.png)
Teen drama over Halloween party planning. NTA wins.
Commenter calls out birthday girl’s intelligence, NTA verdict.
Halloween spirit prevails in NTA’s comment.
NTA! Have your party, it’s your birthday!
Birthday girl shuts down newbie’s Halloween party. Not the a**hole.
Blonde joke backfires – commenter called out for being insensitive.
No drama, just Halloween party wishes
Double the Halloween parties, double the fun! NTA wins.
This comment brought the laughs!
Celebrate Halloween and Birthdays with spooky themed cakes
Commenter encourages doing what you want for Halloween party
Birthday girl’s entitlement causes conflict over Halloween plans
Cultural confusion over Halloween and All Saints Day?
Celebrate your birthday your way! Don’t let ‘Hanna’ bring you down. NTA.
Celebrate your birthday with a spooky bash!
