She Wants to Call Me Dad…But I Said NO

Buckle up, folks! We’ve got a juicy story straight from the trenches of modern family drama! Meet our main man, a stand-up guy caught in the middle of a sticky situation with his ex, their kids, and a surprise addition to the family. ‍ ‍ ‍ He’s been doing his best to keep things friendly, but when an innocent request from his ex’s daughter throws him for a loop, he’s left wondering if he’s the a-hole for setting boundaries. Get ready for a wild ride filled with custody chaos, awkward moments, and a whole lot of heart!

Custody Chaos: The Ex, The Kids, and The One Night Stand Baby!

‍♂️ Deadbeat Dad Ditches Daughter: No Child Support, No Shows!

Friendly Exes: Cookouts, Favors, and School Pickups!

School Shuttle Service: Picking Up All Three, But Not Playing Daddy! ‍

Dinner Dilemma: A Nice Meal Turns Into an Awkward Moment!

Goodbye Hugs and a Shocking Request: Eva Wants to Call Me Dad!

Mixup or Meaningful Ask? Eva’s Surprising Question! ❓

‍♂️ Uncomfortable and Unwilling: I Don’t Want That Responsibility!

Sad Eva and Angry Ex: Josie Calls Me a Jerk!

Flattery or Future Expectations? Josie’s Perspective on the Situation!

Uncomfortable and Afraid: Worrying About Future Expectations!

‍♂️ AITA for Setting Boundaries? Questioning My Decision! ❓

Unspoken Concerns: Keeping My True Feelings to Myself!

Sticking to My Name: No Uncle or Nicknames, Please! ‍♂️

‍ ‍ Tio Time: Enjoying Being an Uncle to My Siblings’ Kids!

Family Drama Explosion: Am I a Jerk for Refusing to Be Called Dad?

Well, well, well! Looks like our main man is in quite the pickle! He’s been doing his best to be a stand-up guy, helping out his ex and her kids whenever he can. But when little Eva drops the D-bomb and asks to call him dad, he’s left feeling more uncomfortable than a cat in a room full of rocking chairs! He politely declines, but now his ex is calling him a jerk for not embracing the role. The internet is about to weigh in on this family drama, and you won’t believe what they have to say! Grab your popcorn, because this is going to be a wild ride! Let’s dive into the juiciest responses and see if our guy is really the a-hole in this situation!

Setting boundaries with a child is tough, but necessary. NTA

Setting boundaries is important, but it’s not your responsibility ❤️

Setting boundaries with kindness. NTA for not being dad.

Being honest with Eva was necessary, but a longer talk needed.

Being a father figure can come with legal obligations. NTA.

Suggests alternative pet name for child, empathizes with situation.

Setting boundaries early can prevent future financial burdens

Setting boundaries with empathy and care. NTA

Being a father figure is admirable, but it’s okay to decline ‍♂️

You are not her dad, it’s time to set boundaries ‍♂️

Choosing not to be called dad to avoid confusion. NTA.

Setting boundaries with a child who’s not your responsibility. NTA

Setting boundaries while still showing care. NTA

Heartbreaking situation. NTA but Eva’s future looks challenging

Setting boundaries with ex’s child, NTA but tough situation

Choosing not to be called ‘Dad’ – NTA comment

Setting boundaries with stepchild, NTA but be gentle

Being a father figure is enough, NTA for setting boundaries

Setting boundaries with kindness and respect. NAH and understanding child’s perspective

A thoughtful suggestion for compromising without hurting Eva’s feelings

Respectful boundaries, but consider a loving nickname for Eva

Setting boundaries with stepchild, discussing future plans with ex-spouse. NTA

Innocent mistake, but important to explain the situation kindly

NTA. You’re not responsible for the child, she is.

Polite NTA declines daughter’s request to call him dad.

Advice on navigating the complexities of parental titles.

Being a parent is tough but NTA for setting boundaries.

NTA, but sensitive situation. Josie needs to talk it out ‍♂️

Setting boundaries with stepchildren and financial responsibilities discussed.

Be careful, NTA could still be liable for child support

Boundaries respected. Calling you dad could complicate legal matters. NTA.

Finding a new title to connect with stepdaughter.

Consideration for the child’s confusion. NTA, prioritize comfort.

Setting boundaries with stepchild, ex needs to clarify the situation

Respectful NTA sets healthy boundaries with potential stepchild.

Don’t let your ex put you on the hook financially. NTA

Setting boundaries with ex’s daughter: NTA, not obligated ‍♂️

Politely document boundaries to avoid future financial obligations. #NTA

Boundaries are important to avoid legal responsibilities. NTA

OP’s sensitive handling of situation; setting boundaries. NTA

Choosing to spend time with her is more important

Setting boundaries with ex who frames you as dad

Setting boundaries: Saying no to being called dad.

Boundaries set, NTA. Josie needs to respect your decision

Supporting a child’s future while being NTA

Being kind but setting boundaries. NTA

You handled it well, but watch out for your ex’s intentions

Uncle’s story shows treating non-biological child like family is complicated. NTA

Setting boundaries with stepchild’s absent father, NTA, protect Eva’s future

Refusing to be called dad to avoid future complications.

Ex wants daughter to call me dad, but NTA. It’s strange.

Avoiding potential legal trouble. Smart move.

Ex’s daughter wants to call him dad, he said no. NTA.

Heartbreaking story of a dad’s rejection. NTA, but proceed with caution

Being called uncle would be worse, ask Joan Crawford’s daughter

Being called Dad is a privilege, not an obligation. NTA

Mother may favor last child due to perceived favoritism, NTA.

Setting boundaries with stepdaughter’s desire for father figure

Setting boundaries with your ex when it comes to fatherhood ‍

Setting boundaries with stepchild, mother should explain to her gently

Not the a**hole for not wanting to be called dad

A child of similar experience advises against calling stepfather ‘dad’.

Setting boundaries with kindness and empathy. NTA

A heartwarming story of a girl seeking a father figure ❤️

Being a male role model without fatherly responsibility

Setting boundaries with a child is tough, but NTA.

The slippery slope of saying no to being a dad

Setting boundaries with your ex’s child is understandable.

Establishing boundaries with Eva can be done kindly and respectfully

Being a friend and father figure, NTA for saying no.

Ex’s audacity to ask after your great support. NTA

Setting boundaries with empathy is key in this situation

Suggests a harmless nickname for the girl to use instead of Dad.

Setting boundaries with ex, avoiding false expectations. NTA

Being inclusive but setting boundaries = NTA

Respectful NTA declines unwanted fatherhood, sets boundaries for himself ‍

Setting boundaries with stepdaughter’s guilt: NTA, but supportive

NTA. Advice on how to communicate with Eva about boundaries

A child wants to call him Dad, but he said no. NTA.