In a family steeped in tradition, a name carries the weight of generations. For the Doe family, the firstborn son has always been bestowed with the honorable name of John Jacob Doe, a legacy dating back to their Civil War ancestor. But what happens when the latest bearer of this name embarks on a journey of self-discovery? ️⚧️ Join us as we unravel the complex tale of siblings, identity, and the battle for birthright in this perplexing family conundrum.
A Family Tradition Rooted in History

Meet the Doe Family: A Tale of Three Siblings

️⚧️ A Sibling’s Journey: Coming Out as Transgender

A New Chapter: Changing Names and Traditions ✍️

The Bullying Burden: A Painful Past

Honoring Dad: A Son’s Heartfelt Wish ❤️

Remembering Dad: Keeping His Memory Alive ️

Dreams of Fatherhood: Passing Down the Legacy

Mom and Sis Approve: A Family United

Relatives Revolt: The Birthright Battle Begins

The Firstborn Feud: Who Deserves the Crown?

Denial and Disrespect: Relatives Refuse to Acknowledge

AITA? A Complex Family Conundrum

Confusion Reigns: A Perplexing Predicament

️⚧️ Sister Supports: A Sibling’s Blessing

️ The Name Game: A Sibling Showdown
In a shocking twist, the OP’s sister, the former JJ Doe VI, has given her blessing for her brother to take on the family name! But not everyone is on board with this unconventional name swap. Relatives are revolting, accusing the OP of stealing his sister’s birthright and refusing to acknowledge her transition. It’s a complex family drama that has everyone scratching their heads. Let’s see what the internet has to say about this perplexing predicament! Get ready for some juicy responses that’ll have you on the edge of your seat!
Transgender sister’s blessing makes him eldest son. NTA

Honoring family tradition while respecting sister’s identity. ❤

Defying sister’s decision: family uses name as excuse. Nice gesture.

Sibling takes transgender sister’s name with her blessing

Sibling support trumps extended family’s intolerance. Don’t back down
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e385a2af-b0f3-4c8f-8936-8446dd6d2e3f.png)
Supportive comment suggests therapy for transphobic relatives

Keeping family tradition alive, NTA for taking sister’s name

Naming traditions could be a deal breaker in relationships

Calling someone by their deadname is never okay. NTA.

Sibling support wins in name change discussion

Transgender sister’s name causes family feud, NTA asserts identity

Taking a name isn’t a crime, NTA prevails

Supportive comment shuts down family’s unwanted opinions

Sister’s support makes it clear: NTA, haters gonna hate

Embrace tradition and identity without hurting anyone – NTA.

Supportive comment applauds sibling’s name decision despite family drama.

Changing your name: fun times with unsupportive family

Sassy suggestion to confuse unsupportive family members

Don’t worry about what others think. NTA.

Trans person supports man taking transgender sister’s name ❤️

Taking your sister’s name? NTA, but legal issues exist.

Standing up for your identity: NTA for keeping family tradition

NTA! Family should support, not dictate your life choices

Respect your sibling’s identity, ignore the haters.

Sibling support Taking sister’s name with blessing

Taking your transgender sister’s name? Consider the legal hassle

Breaking tradition for trans sibling, NTA. Family must accept change

Taking sister’s name, NTA. Family not accepting, f**k them ️

Sister gave up name willingly, NTA. Relatives denying her womanhood
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/7846cc72-4cd5-44b9-a146-b89529b2f797.png)
Respect sister’s support when taking her deadname.

Taking sister’s name with blessing but family disagrees ♀️

Transgender sister’s name creates family feud. NTA prevails.

Skip generations with names! NTA for using sister’s name.

Sibling support wins over family bigotry. NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/d0c923e4-d69d-4914-bb3f-ebf7b503c9a0.png)
Be yourself and forget the haters!

Naming children after fathers can be a sensitive topic.

Changing name with sister and mom’s support – NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/4915f832-53e3-4194-8ce4-6ee7be45eba0.png)
Supportive comment towards person taking transgender sister’s name

Sibling support triumphs over family drama ✌

Creative solution to family dispute over name dilemma

Choosing preferred name is a win-win. NTA

Sibling support! NTA, older sis and family approval > all

Family supports name change, but potential mix-ups may arise

Sibling support : Brother takes transgender sister’s name with her blessing

First-born son takes transgender sister’s name. NTA, relatives complain.

Supportive comment defends man taking transgender sister’s name.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e7455de2-1539-4680-888a-d94db3ace7f6.png)
Trans sister’s name given to man: NTA controversy resolved

Navigating family traditions and trans acceptance

Supportive comment encourages standing up for transgender sister

Supportive siblings and mom stand up to unsupportive extended family

Supportive comment with a catchy tune reference

Proud father planning to name his son after his transgender sister ♥️

NTA and relatives are assholes, gender ambiguous names discussed ♂️

Sibling name change causes family drama ♂️

Supporting transgender sister by taking her name

Sibling support and name jokes, NTA wins this round!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e5dc1b81-6630-4af7-a358-4c1e9f7d1f56.png)
Stand your ground and repeat ‘change is hard’ ✊
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/0d75f7be-c002-4440-bb3a-e637f3502602.png)
Continuing family tradition, NTA. Extended family are massive AHs.

Support for a man taking his transgender sister’s name

New name approved by sister, NTA. Congrats
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/d897a91c-cc19-4f5b-80d3-ad37db21114b.png)
Sister’s support matters most. Others can sit and shut up. NTA

Sibling support and family tradition, NTA wins this round
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/32b2975d-6813-4324-ac76-2e869c39c8d5.png)
Transgender sister’s name: rightful heir or family feud? NTA wins.

Sibling takes transgender sister’s name, family feud. NTA wins.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/2d36cd35-cf3c-449e-b052-25d3a14a34a7.png)
Transgender sister’s name sparks family feud. NTA for name bearer.

Supportive comment defends man taking sister’s name amid family backlash

Support for transgender sister against unsupportive relatives

Supportive comment on name change raises legal concerns.

Transphobic family giving him a hard time over sister’s name change. NTA

Misreading the title leads to humorous judgment, but ultimately NTA.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3f8680ce-ffac-4883-8b70-52dc6e9b1310.png)
Supportive comment encourages transgender sibling to take chosen name ️ ✊

Transgender sister’s name change sparks family argument. NTA defends decision.

Supportive comment defends man taking sister’s name with NTA sentiment
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/68cd4c26-cf35-4631-bc35-09b16a3f62c1.png)
Family tradition can be important, but sister’s approval is key

Sensible suggestion for avoiding name mix-ups with records

Breaking tradition for LGBTQ+ family members ❤️

Respectful name change with sister’s permission ✌
