Picture this: you’re finally meeting your brother’s new girlfriend for the first time after months of quarantine, and you’re not exactly thrilled about it. He’s had a sketchy history with girlfriends, so you’re not expecting much. But when she arrives, she’s even worse than you could have imagined! She can’t even get your name right, calls your parents ‘mum’ and ‘dad,’ and talks non-stop through dinner. What would you do? Well, let me tell you how one woman handled this situation…
Brother’s New Girlfriend

Living at Home

Name Game ♀️

Mum and Dad?!

Awkward Dinner ️

Interrupting Queen

Picky Eater ♀️

Drunk and Fed Up

Silent Treatment

Brotherly Love

Parents’ Opinion

Worst Advice: Be Yourself? ♀️
So, our protagonist had to endure an excruciatingly awkward dinner with her brother’s new girlfriend, who just couldn’t stop talking or making bizarre requests. Our heroine, a bit tipsy from day-drinking, finally snapped and told the girlfriend that anyone who told her to be herself couldn’t have given her worse advice. The room went silent, the girlfriend left, and now the brother is furious with our protagonist. Even her parents think she went too far. But did she really? ♀️ Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…
A judgmental comment leads to backlash about drinking habits

Judging GF while drunk: YTA or NAH?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/98a1d26c-f8fc-41e9-b658-9db7a28510da.png)
YTA called out for bad table manners and inappropriate behavior

Having an uncommon name doesn’t make anyone less angry, YTA.

Bro’s GF is weird and rude, but sister’s comment was harsh. ESH ♀️

A comment suggests better ways to handle the situation

Drinking all day and bullying your brother’s GF? YTA

YTA! Learn to have patience and consider others’ perspective

User calls out echo chamber, gives gentle YTA judgment.

YTA commenter slams OP’s personality, predicts relationship issues.

Judgmental behavior backfires ♀️

Both sides at fault: commenter suggests rude GF provoked confrontation

Bro’s GF & drunk sister both rude, but brother needed to intervene.

User calls out commenter for being rude to nervous girlfriend

YTA gets called out for being a ‘Drunk Asshole’

Both parties acted like a**holes but sister’s behavior was disrespectful

Don’t commit murder by words! YTA should have been polite

Empathize with talkative individuals. Don’t be rude. ♀️

ESH, but could have handled it better ♀️

Rude sister and immature response at family dinner

OP thinks GF is obnoxious and ESH, comment agrees.

Obnoxious GF refuses to eat favorite meal, comment hilarious but rude – ESH

Etiquette question: Is it ever okay to refuse host’s food?

Brother needs better taste, parents need a spine, GF clueless

First impressions matter, but was calling her out in public too far?

Excuses made for GF’s behavior, ESH for overreaction and rudeness

YTA. Drunk sister made an awkward first impression, but commenter’s judgemental attitude also inappropriate.

Nervousness doesn’t excuse bad behavior. YTA gets called out.

Sister stands up to obnoxious GF: NTA for calling out rudeness

A commenter plays devil’s advocate and questions OP’s credibility.

Rude sister gets called out, and commenter approves

Anxiety sufferer calls out YTA’s lack of empathy

Liquid courage leads to justified call-out of rude behavior

Calling parents mom and dad is weird. GF and OP are ESH.

Day drinking leads to AH move, GF rude at dinner

OP called out obnoxious GF, avoiding future family drama. NAH.

OP criticized GF for minor things, got drunk, and acted horribly.

OP may be more at fault for not giving GF a chance
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/774d9252-3a27-45c3-a800-e9bbe8a4df61.png)
Drunkenly shutting down obnoxious GF makes for awkward family dinner

Redditors weigh in on YTA’s shady line and advice

YTA. Be less judgmental and more understanding of people’s nerves.

A commenter calls out the original poster for being rude to his brother’s girlfriend and suggests he apologize.

Agreeing with the commenter’s NTA judgement and self-awareness

Defending an Insecure GF: YTA or NAH?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/fc6ff45a-549c-42d9-ae45-c7f8aa0c42c1.png)
Don’t blame it on the alcohol, YTA for being rude

Being drunk is not an excuse for being an a**hole

Interrupting and being clingy may be a sign of ADHD. YTA.

Being annoying doesn’t justify being cruel

YTA called out for escalating situation with new girlfriend.

Insulting your brother’s girlfriend publicly? YTA. Apologize now

YTA called out for not accepting responsibility.

Hilarious YTA comment makes for a memorable family dinner

Redditors call out commenter for being TA, YTA denial.

User calls out drunken sibling for poor behavior at dinner

Drinking + hostility = YTA. Empathize with anxious sister.

Advice to apologize and clear things up for drunk comment.

NTA. Harsh but necessary. GF crossed all social norms.

Insult may be weak, but YTA for slamming girlfriend’s behavior.

NTA commenter finds humor in sister’s antics and plans to replicate.

First meeting faux pas and awkwardness: ESH agrees

Redditor predicts YTA verdict based on early bragging.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/bf764ccf-578c-4d55-982b-4e803e10bb79.png)
Amid the chaos, a humorous take on the drunk sister’s behavior

Teaching basic manners: NTA shuts down self-absorbed GF
