Girlfriend Gives Away BF’s New Puppy Behind His Back!

Buckle up, folks! We’ve got a real doggy drama on our hands! When a cat lover and a dog devotee move in together, things are bound to get a little…ruff! Our protagonist never wanted a dog in the first place, but their partner just couldn’t resist a cute pup from Craigslist. As the puppy problems pile up, tensions rise, and a beloved childhood toy becomes collateral damage. Did our hero have the right to rehome the rowdy pup, or was it a total a-hole move? Let’s dive into this tail of love, loss, and a whole lot of puppy drama!

Puppy Problems: A Tail of Two Lovers

Moving In Together…With a Twist!

Goodbye, Old Friend…Hello, New Puppy?!

Craigslist Surprise: A German Shepard Pug Mix?!

Cat vs. Dog: The Ultimate Showdown!

Puppy Problems: Loud, Untrained, and Messy!

‍ Training Troubles: A Ruff Situation! ‍♀️

The Last Straw: Puppy vs. Care Bear!

Furious and Fed Up: Time for Action!

Rehoming the Pup: A Tough Decision

Guilt Sets In: Did I Do the Right Thing?

My House, My Rules: The Lease Argument

‍♂️ Partner Storms Out: Retrieving the Pup?

⚖️ Weighing the Options: Justified or Jerk Move?

‍♀️ AITA? The Ultimate Question! ‍♀️

Puppy Problems: Who’s the Real A-Hole Here?

Well, well, well…this story sure has gotten the internet talking! ️ Our protagonist just wanted a peaceful home with their beloved cat, but their partner had other plans. Bringing home a surprise puppy is bound to cause some tension, especially when it’s a German Shepard Pug mix from Craigslist! As the pup wreaks havoc on the house (and a cherished childhood toy ), our hero takes matters into their own hands and rehomes the dog without their partner’s consent. Talk about a bold move! But was it justified, or did they cross the line? The internet has some thoughts, and they’re not holding back! Let’s see what the masses have to say about this puppy predicament!

Unilateral actions lead to poor animal parenting. ESH.

A bad “roommates with benefits” situation. E-V-E-R-Y-O-N-E S-U-C-K-S H-E-R-E!

ESH but communication is key in a relationship

Breaking up might have been a better solution ESH

Dog drama – surprises and secrets don’t belong in relationships.

BF’s girlfriend gave away his puppy, internet judges her YTA

Partner surprises with a puppy, OP gives it away. ESH.

Training a puppy takes more than 2 weeks. ESH for negligence.

Both partners made poor decisions, lack of communication caused conflict ️

Dog drama leads to ESH situation, living arrangement in question

Breaking up might be the best thing for both parties

ESH relationship needs communication. No right to give away pet.

Puppy drama leads to ESH name-calling.

A disastrous relationship with mutual disrespect and no communication

Poor puppy caught in the crossfire of immature relationship

Dog drama: OP and partner both at fault for puppy problem.

BF gets new puppy against GF’s wishes, both suck

Partner got a dog without permission, but can’t give it away

Giving away his new puppy – did she cross a line? ESH

YTA stole their dog! Break up or move out instead!

YTA for giving away your partner’s puppy without permission

Both acted immature by going behind each other’s backs

Break up already! ESH, you’re both disrespectful and unkind

Partner gets new dog without discussion and both parties immature

BF and GF both at fault for new puppy fiasco

Breaking a deal and getting rid of a pet? ESH

Both parties at fault for not communicating before getting puppy

Harsh criticism for EHS commenter with no emotional control

Keeping to the agreement. NTA wins this one!

NTA for rehoming surprise puppy, but relationship issues need attention

Partner buys puppy from puppy farm, OP is NTA for giving it away

Tit for tat – fill your house with cats

Agreement broken, tough lesson learned. Selfishness has consequences. NTA.

YTA for giving away someone else’s puppy without permission

Giving away BF’s puppy makes YTA and childish

OP is YTA for giving away puppy without telling partner.

Stealing a puppy and giving it away? ESH, but more you.

Both got dog without permission, both got rid without asking. ESH.

Stealing a puppy is never justified. YTA, no doubt

Giving away someone’s puppy is never okay. YTA.

Agreement broken, surprise puppy given away. NTA saves day

Partner brings home a puppy after agreeing not to. ESH.

Buying a pet without consulting your partner is disrespectful. Giving it away is worse.

Relationship advice: respect and communication are key ❤️

Giving away a pet without consultation makes YTA.

Communication is key! Both parties were in the wrong

Taking away a puppy may seem harsh, but NTA in this situation.

Dog drama! Commenter and OP both at fault. ☠️

Firing back at AHs? ESH with gratitude

Pet drama leads to ESH verdict and relationship advice.

Communication is key! ️ ESH needs to grow up.

Relationship and puppy problems. Immature ESH situation.

Respectful comment defending OP’s actions in removing the puppy. NTA

Both at fault for not communicating, but don’t reconcile.

Respect matters! Choosing pets should be a mutual decision.

No sympathy for BF who broke agreement & can’t train dog

A puppy dilemma: no clear a**hole, but everyone sucks here.

NTA for rehoming dog, but better communication needed with GF

BF called a dirt bag for giving away puppy behind back

Relationship gone wrong. ESH. ‍♂️

Agreeing to no more pets doesn’t justify giving one away

Taking someone’s pet without consent is a**hole behavior.

Giving away a dog after it’s been established in a home is bad for the dog. ESH.

Pet adoption gone wrong. ESH and dog deserves better

Mismatched couple re-homes puppy behind each other’s backs. ESH.

A puppy, manipulation, and two people being total dicks

Ultimatum between love and puppy leads to shared custody. ESH.

Relationship troubles and damaged property over new puppy. ESH.

No agreement for an untrained dog, NTA for finding home

No respect for each other’s property, innocent dog suffers

Partner angry after girlfriend rehomes destructive puppy. NTA.

Red flag! Commenter called out for being inconsiderate and thoughtless.

Both wrong for going behind each other’s backs

Puppy and cat are the only innocent ones in this mess

Agreement broken. Dog gone. Fair game. NTA wins.