In a tale of friendship, love, and makeup, a woman finds herself in hot water after giving away her girlfriend’s limited edition eyeshadow palette to her best friend’s girlfriend. As the situation unfolds, the couple’s relationship is put to the test, with emotions running high and the question of whether the makeup mishap was a simple mistake or a betrayal.
The Perfect Girlfriend?

New Friends and Makeup Obsession

A Get-Together Gone Wrong

Katy’s Bathroom Discovery

The Fateful Decision

Confrontation and Conflict

Limited Edition Woes

The Silent Treatment

Harsh Comments and Realizations

Gender Clarification

Taking Action

Update: Resolution?

A Makeup Mishap with Lasting Consequences
In a whirlwind of emotions, a woman gives away her girlfriend’s limited edition eyeshadow palette to her best friend’s girlfriend, sparking conflict and tension. As the couple navigates through the fallout, they face harsh comments and confront the question of whether it was a simple mistake or a betrayal. Will they be able to resolve the issue and move forward? Share your thoughts and reactions.
Giving away girlfriend’s limited edition makeup was a major betrayal

Giving away her makeup? YTA. It’s not yours to give.

OP’s girlfriend’s makeup was given away without permission. YTA.

Makeup is off-limits, YTA!

OP is in trouble for giving away girlfriend’s makeup.

Sharing makeup is a fast pass to an infection! YTA.

Giving away girlfriend’s makeup without permission? YTA for sure

Don’t mess with your girlfriend’s makeup collection! YTA.

Don’t mess with someone else’s makeup collection!

OP is called out for giving away someone else’s property.

You messed up big time. Go get her makeup back!

Don’t give away someone else’s stuff! YTA’s motive questioned

Curious about the palette name? Join the discussion!

BF gives away GF’s makeup without permission, risking relationship

GF gave away prized possession without consent, YTA receives backlash

YTA gave away girlfriend’s pricey makeup, apologize now!

OP is in trouble for letting someone steal his girlfriend’s makeup

Don’t mess with your girlfriend’s makeup! YTA for stealing.

Boyfriend gives away girlfriend’s pricey makeup: YTA and cowardly.

Giving away girlfriend’s makeup without permission is a betrayal. YTA.

Don’t mess with someone else’s makeup collection!

Giving away makeup you don’t own? YTA and so is Katy

Giving away limited edition makeup? YTA according to commenters

BF gave away GF’s makeup, called it a mistake. YTA.

Giving away her makeup without permission? YTA

Sharing makeup is a hygiene risk. YTA, replace the palette.

The verdict is in: YTA for giving away girlfriend’s makeup

Lesbian commenter finds humor in gender assumption, gets support.

Returning stolen makeup: YTA learns a valuable lesson.

Giving away GF’s pricey makeup without consent: YTA and fix it

Respect personal property: YTA for giving away girlfriend’s makeup

Return the makeup ASAP! YTA for giving it away.

Don’t mess with your girlfriend’s expensive makeup collection! YTA

Giving away girlfriend’s makeup without consent, gaslighting, and refusing to rectify mistake. YTA

Giving away girlfriend’s makeup: YTA and relationship in jeopardy

Giving away girlfriend’s makeup without asking? Definitely a betrayal

Don’t mess with a girl’s makeup! YTA for giving it away.

Boyfriend gives away girlfriend’s makeup palette without permission

Stealing from girlfriend’s bathroom? YTA and spineless. Dump-worthy.

Apologize and ask for the palette back. YTA in trouble

Caught red-handed? YTA accused of stealing girlfriend’s makeup

Sharing makeup? YTA for giving away girlfriend’s stuff.

Supportive comment wishes karma on boyfriend’s lost makeup palette.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/7dece09b-d27f-43c1-9ab1-f50721053c95.png)
Don’t mess with her makeup! YTA should apologize

Don’t mess with your girlfriend’s belongings. YTA

Don’t mess with her makeup! YTA learned it the hard way

Giving away girlfriend’s makeup? YTA and in the doghouse

Don’t mess with your girlfriend’s makeup! YTA

Don’t mess with your girlfriend’s makeup! YTA

Giving away expensive makeup? YTA according to commenters

Don’t mess with someone else’s makeup YTA

Commenter calls out OP as a YTA and a dumbass

Girlfriend’s makeup given away: YTA and in denial

Don’t steal from your girlfriend for brownie points

Don’t mess with other people’s stuff!

Stealing and giving away girlfriend’s makeup? YTA and in trouble

Respect is key in any relationship

Partner gave away girlfriend’s makeup, called out for disrespect.

Don’t mess with a girl’s makeup! YTA learned the hard way.

Don’t mess with a girl’s makeup! YTA, show some respect
