Picture this: You’ve spent hours planning your daughter’s birthday party, decorating the house, and inviting all her friends. But when it comes to the cake, you’re faced with a dilemma: Do you get her the strawberry cake she wants, or do you go with the chocolate cake that everyone else will enjoy? In this story, our cake-conflicted mom decides to go with the majority and gets a chocolate cake, but adds some strawberries on top as a compromise. Little did she know, this choice would lead to tears, tantrums, and an early end to the party.
Birthday Gone Wrong
The Cake Dilemma
Strawberry vs. Chocolate
Majority Rules?
Compromise?
Surprise! Or Not…
Tears and Tantrums
Embarrassment Ensues
Party Over
Husband vs. Wife
Regrets and Realizations
EDIT:
Cake Catastrophe: A Birthday Party Disaster
So, our well-intentioned mom thought she had found the perfect solution by getting a chocolate cake with strawberries on top. But when her daughter saw the cake, she was devastated, leading to a full-blown meltdown in front of all the guests. The party ended early, and mom found herself in a heated argument with her husband over the cake choice. Now she’s wondering if she made the wrong decision and if she’s in the wrong for not getting her daughter the cake she wanted. Let’s see what the internet has to say about this birthday party blunder…
RELATED STORIES
Mom chooses cake for daughter’s birthday, internet says YTA
Mom buys cake daughter hates on her birthday. YTA.
Mom prioritizes guests over daughter’s birthday wish: YTA
Mom’s selfishness ruins daughter’s birthday cake choice. YTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/04707c97-966b-4bc2-baf0-ba8245a5de0b.png)
Mom’s cake choice was selfish and daughter deserves an apology
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/a0240f48-5013-4962-92e3-fb96c4c7c682.png)
User shares successful cake solution for picky eaters
Mom prioritizes others’ opinions over daughter’s birthday happiness
User calls out double standard in cake choice.
Reddit user calls out OP’s behavior as narcissistic
Mom’s cake choice sparks YTA backlash. Daughter’s birthday ruined.
Strawberry cake controversy: Mom ruins daughter’s birthday. YTA.
User calls out OP for not behaving like a normal human ♂️
Mom ignores daughter’s birthday wish, labeled YTA by commenter.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/61dae060-a9e1-496d-8e00-cb4add7bdeff.png)
Mom chooses her own cake over daughter’s birthday wishes
YTA comment: Focus on daughter’s happiness, not others’ opinions.
Mom’s cake choice sparks YTA verdict from commenters
User calls out OP for not communicating with daughter before. YTA.
Daughter’s birthday ruined by mom’s cake choice
Mom chooses her favorite cake over daughter’s birthday wish. YTA!
Buy the cake they want, not the one you like. YTA
Mom’s cake choice for daughter’s birthday is a major YTA
Mom gets called out for ruining daughter’s birthday
Mom chooses her favorite cake for daughter’s birthday
Let her eat strawberry cake! YTA ruined her birthday
Sibling shares solution to cake dilemma with similar experience.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/8bfe42b7-af8a-4986-b696-9b25ceb108e4.png)
A birthday cake disaster, a bad flavor choice, and disappointment
Let the birthday girl choose her cake! Your concern for others is appreciated, but get some cupcakes instead.
Mom gets called out for being selfish on daughter’s birthday
Parenting judgment and a 10-year-old’s tantrum. ♀️
Disliking chocolate and nuts, YTA suggests buying a second cake.
Mom’s cake choice angers daughter on her birthday, YTA
Buying a cake for yourself on someone else’s birthday? YTA
YTA for getting a cake your daughter doesn’t like , alternative desserts could have been offered. Also, strange tantrum behavior from daughter ♀️.
Mom’s selfish cake choice ruins daughter’s birthday. No excuses. ♀️
Mom’s cake choice ruins daughter’s birthday, and she’s the a**hole.
Mom’s selfishness ruins daughter’s birthday cake choice. YTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/595fd4f0-d303-4bc7-93e4-a1bc1877c06a.png)
User questions authenticity of post and calls out OP’s behavior
Mom ignores daughter’s birthday cake request, gets what she wants. YTA
Strawberry vs Chocolate Cake: YTA for choosing selfishly
Narcissistic mom ruins daughter’s birthday with her selfish behavior. YTA
Daughter deserves to feel special on her birthday! YTA
Let her have her cake and eat it too!
Mom faces criticism for ruining daughter’s birthday cake choice
Mom ruins daughter’s birthday with cake choice. YTA confirmed.
Mom adds walnuts to daughter’s birthday cake, ignored her preference. YTA
YTA is slammed for ruining daughter’s birthday cake
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/f05f0e2b-fcb0-4e9b-a042-cb6c6a35396d.png)
Mom ignores daughter’s birthday cake request, gets embarrassed when daughter gets upset. YTA
Mom’s cake choice ruins daughter’s birthday: Commenter calls YTA with a bonus cake preference
Cake seller defends girl’s right to birthday cake choice
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/c30ae6d6-63c9-42a6-86e8-9fb71b5612f8.png)
User requests end to cursing in forum with humorous tone
A commenter calls out OP’s behavior as selfish
User calls out OP for being selfish and not considering daughter’s wishes.
Choosing cake for yourself makes YTA. Apologize with strawberry
User gets called out for being selfish parent.
Walnuts in cake? No thanks. Empathy for the daughter.
YTA’s edit backfires, commenters not impressed with narcissistic behavior.
YTA for not letting the birthday kid choose the cake flavor Also, chocolate cake with walnut bits inside?
YTA. Cake matters to a 10-year-old on her birthday
Letting a 10-year-old choose her cake isn’t too much to ask
Mom ruins daughter’s birthday cake, puts guests above daughter
Choosing your own cake over your 10-year-old daughter’s is selfish
YTA: Ignoring your daughter’s birthday request is not cool
YTA’s decision ruins daughter’s party and self-worth
Harsh criticism for mom’s birthday cake decision
Mom ruins daughter’s birthday with selfish cake choice: YTA
Don’t be a dick. Let people like things. YTA.
User calls out OP for selfish cake choice on daughter’s birthday.
Mom chooses cake for herself on daughter’s birthday: YTA
Daughter wanted strawberry cake for birthday but OP chose otherwise. YTA.
Putting your child’s happiness first
YTA vs NTA: Commenter sides with the majority opinion
Mom prioritizes guests over daughter’s birthday. YTA
Selfish mom ruins daughter’s birthday cake choice. YTA
Nuts on a kid’s cake? Not cool! Agree or disagree?
Mom chooses chocolate cake over daughter’s request, internet calls YTA
Being a good host means accommodating guests’ allergies and preferences. YTA.
Daughter’s birthday ruined by mom’s cake choice: YTA
Confused commenter questions parent’s thought process in cake choice
Put your child first on their birthday ❤️
Mom prioritizes own image over daughter’s birthday wishes. YTA.
Chocolate cake isn’t for everyone but YTA for being selfish
User calls out the negligence of mom’s cake choice. YTA.
