Meet our heroine, a 28-year-old woman who’s been in a loving relationship for over two years. She’s always been clear about one thing – she doesn’t want kids. Her boyfriend, despite wanting children, decided he could live without them for her sake. But what happens when a hidden chapter from her past surfaces? A chapter involving a baby bump, a sister in need, and a decision that would change everything. Let’s dive into this emotionally charged saga.
A Picture Worth a Thousand Words

The Unexpected Revelation

The Result of a Loving Gesture

The Past Unveiled, A Relationship Shaken ️

A Clash of Perspectives

The Aftermath: Apologies and Accusations

The Fallout: A Love Story on the Rocks

The Surrogacy Saga: A Deeper Dive ️

The Trust Factor: A Sister’s Fear ️

A Love Story Tested by a Surrogate Secret: Where Do They Go From Here?
In a twist of fate, our heroine’s past as a surrogate for her sister comes to light, shaking the foundations of her relationship. Her boyfriend, initially accepting of her decision not to have children, is now upset and feels deceived. He’s questioning their future, as he struggles with the fact that she was willing to carry a child for her sister, but not for him. Our heroine stands her ground, emphasizing the difference between carrying a child and raising one. She’s apologetic for not revealing her past sooner but insists it wasn’t his business. As the dust settles, the question remains – will their love survive this storm? Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…
“Giving birth and raising a child are two different things”

NTA. BF wants kids, but you’re incompatible. Time to break up.

NTA, but is he kidding himself about changing OP’s mind?

Confusion and skepticism surround the requirements for surrogacy agreements.

ESH for not discussing previous surrogacy and potential resentment.

“NTA, but his resentment towards the surrogate child is understandable. “

YTA for not telling your SO about being a surrogate

NTA – Your partner’s confusion about your past as a gestational surrogate

Secret surrogate past leads to relationship trust issues
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/9cc29956-5db4-468d-af05-ca225d11db35.png)
NTA vs ESH: Relationship shaken by hidden surrogate past. Trust broken.

ESH. He’s overreacting, but you should’ve been upfront about your past.

YTA for hiding a significant secret from your partner for years

NTA – He lied about wanting kids, not your responsibility.

Secret past creates confusion and trust issues in relationship
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/4dd52379-7f2e-447e-bd91-308b516ccbf5.png)
NTA. BF surprised by secret past. Emotions got the best.

NTA: Your body, your choice. His reaction is manipulative bs
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/857aaa6a-7662-4866-affd-d8a05bb63904.png)
Interesting perspective on ‘living without kids’ as a red flag.

♀️ ESH: Relationship shaken by secret past and incompatible interests.

“YTA. Should’ve disclosed surrogacy info. Mistrust will fester. “

NTA: His lies about wanting kids put your relationship at risk

NTA. Past is past. Your secret, your story.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/92016cbb-49ba-4966-a776-f8df86dfc539.png)
Stick to your guns! You’re NTA for knowing what you want!

End it. Resentment over not having kids will only worsen

Engaging response to being a surrogate and not wanting children

Engaging in communication issues: YTA for hiding surrogate past.

Empowering choice , unsupportive partner . NTA, stand your ground!

NTA. Revealing a secret surrogate past tests relationship’s true colors.

“NTA or ESH? Boyfriend’s pregnancy misunderstanding reveals deeper issues. “

Partner’s secret past causes relationship turmoil. YTA or NAH?

NTA. Reconsider the relationship. Discuss deal breakers early on.

Secret surrogate past raises trust issues in relationship.

YTA accusation sparks skepticism and disbelief among commenters.

NTA. It’s not his business. He still wants kids.

ESH. Communication is key in relationships.

Surrogacy vs. Parenthood: A Delicate Balance of Love and Responsibility

YTA for hiding your surrogate past from your partner.

ESH for not telling him, confusion on NTA judgment. ♀️

NTA: A rocky relationship built on secrets and unfulfilled expectations.

Surprising N.T.A. votes for male sperm donors, accountability needed!

Surrogate requirements vary by country, but exceptions can be made.

♂️ ESH. Irreconcilable differences lead to resentment and a doomed relationship.

YTA for hiding surrogacy secret, NTA for not wanting kids

Misunderstanding about surrogacy sparks debate. Who’s right?

Reconsider relationship if he wants kids and you don’t

ESH: Communication is key! Secrets can shake up relationships

YTA for hiding a major secret from your partner for years.

NTA, he’s guilt-tripping you instead of being honest about kids.

“The dangerous lie of pretending to be okay without kids.”

Miscommunication about pregnancy intentions leads to judgement.

Not the a**hole. Let’s hear the juicy details!

Surrogate secret shakes relationship. NTA, but will it change minds?

BF not on board with no child plan. Time to talk!

Huge secret revealed! Is their relationship doomed?

Stand up for your rights! Break up with him!

Unveiling a secret surrogate past: the consequences and aftermath

Surrogate past shocks partner, confusion over commitment, give him time ⏰

NTA: Exit plans needed, relationship may not be genuine

NTA: A selfless act of surrogate motherhood, a hidden gift ❤️

Surrogate past revealed after 2.5 years: NTA, time to move on?

ESH. Secrets, trust, and the desire for kids collide.

ESH: Love, trust, and a surprise pregnancy announcement. Drama unfolds!

You’re NTA for being a surrogate, but is your relationship doomed?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/a9c3bb7a-6a08-44e1-a934-b54377adedb1.png)
Surrogate past revealed late, causing uncertainty in relationship dynamics.

Time to part ways?
