Life is full of unexpected twists and turns, but when the past comes knocking at your door, what do you do? This is a tale of a woman who took on the responsibility of raising her sister’s children after a tragic loss. After years of absence, their biological father resurfaces, bringing with him a whirlwind of emotions and a request that leaves our heroine in a moral quandary.
A Young Marriage, A Tragic Loss

Stepping Up to the Plate ⚾

A Blast from the Past

The Court Steps In ⚖️

An Unexpected Visitor

Standing Her Ground ️

A Reminder of Reality

The Moral Quandary

A Doorstep Dilemma: When Family Ties Become Knotted
In a heart-wrenching tale of family, responsibility, and moral ambiguity, a woman finds herself in a predicament when her ex-brother-in-law, who abandoned his children years ago, suddenly reappears, asking for help. Despite his pleas, she stands her ground, reminding him of the family she’s built in his absence. But as the dust settles, she can’t help but question her decision. Let’s delve into the internet’s take on this complex situation…
“NTA at all. You’re doing so much for him! “

Report to CPS to ensure child’s safety.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/12b36b86-d59d-4631-bc17-7306226c5e6c.png)
Father returns, expects older kids to babysit. NTA calls him out.

NTA: Absentee father needs to take responsibility for his actions

NTA. Firmly shut down communication and prioritize your own well-being.

“Allow him to abandon another child” – the burden of responsibility

NTA, keeping toxic people out of your life.

NTA. He insults you after showing up unannounced. You owe him nothing.

Bio dad’s behavior is unacceptable. Document every encounter. NTA.

NTA: Absentee father tries to reconnect, but kids want nothing to do with him. He only sees them as free babysitters.

NTA. Call CPS to ensure the kid’s safety.

“Abandoned child? Call CPS! NTA.”

NTA. Protecting family from a deadbeat dad

Family meeting needed to discuss ex-BIL’s surprise kids

Document everything and record conversations to protect yourself. NTA!

Absentee father returns to exploit teenage kids as free babysitters

NTA. Abandoned kids, court shut him down. Alarming doorstep visit.

Should they consider getting a restraining order?

Heartwarming NTA comment about being an amazing aunt
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/808077e3-a271-4fa3-a7f2-e4183020adf9.png)
NTA – A refreshing perspective on absent fathers.

Taking care of his kids? Not your problem. NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/085b4450-89ac-4688-849e-972500015f5d.png)
NTA, absent father keeps making kids despite losing custody

NTA. Father’s unannounced visit raises suspicions and inconvenience.

NTA. Cut off contact and protect your family from him

NTA. The nerve of this guy! Dumping his kid on you? Stay away!

NTA. Deadbeat dad should lose custody until he shapes up.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/f4f5979a-2986-4ed3-9522-91e84db37609.png)
Curious about the drama, but it doesn’t matter. NTA.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/1422f2c5-c76a-49ae-a64e-ba374507d3da.png)
NTA. You’re a good man. CPS might have been necessary.

NTA: Absentee father tries to abandon another kid, has issues

NTA: Expose the father’s bs to court and child services
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/14d27080-c671-470f-8fa2-f992c4f8fbbb.png)
NTA: A dude with a questionable parenting track record ♂️

No obligation to a child who isn’t related

Not the a**hole. Tell us more about this unexpected visitor!

NTA. Former BIL is a hot mess. Abandoning kids & expecting you to take another

NTA. Father or sperm donor? The truth hurts.

BIL gets roasted for needing a vasectomy

NTA. Father abandons kids, takes them to court. Kids refuse contact.

Deadbeat dad? Not the a**hole for calling him out!

Savage response! NTA shuts down absent father with vasectomy suggestion

“Wow, this guy has some stones on him.” NTA

NTA. Absentee father returns, BIL is manipulative and untrustworthy.

NTA: Absentee father’s motives questioned, potential burden on OP.

No obligation to an absentee father. Focus on your own family.

Supportive comment about fostering ex brother-in-law’s offspring.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/a9dcd091-28cc-43cb-87bc-7583b216da7e.png)
NTA- Ex bio needs to stop having kids… history of ditching them

Not the a**hole for what? Tell us more!

Setting boundaries with an irresponsible father. NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/d1f9cd2f-3b6e-4b26-8763-5998e360fd4e.png)
NTA. Deadbeat dad wants more? F**k him. Heartbreaking for child.

“NTA: Father returns, claims child isn’t his. Drama ensues. “

Cutting off contact with toxic people. Good move!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e051b8a4-6111-4f4b-acec-1d8d7db4a35e.png)
Setting boundaries with an absent father for everyone’s safety. NTA.

NTA. Exposing the truth and protecting innocent children from abduction.

NTA – Block him! Protect your kids and yourself from him

NTA. Drama queen dad?

NTA – Taking responsibility for your own choices and actions.

Protect your property! Get a restraining order. NTA

NTA. Absentee father dumps kid on you without explanation

NTA: Absentee father’s lies unravel, causing chaos in his marriage.

NTA. Your BIL is an entitled with surprising depths of . You did more than you needed to do . He needs to organize his own childcare and maybe stop reproducing .

NTA: Kids made right call, dad wanted to dump them again.

A surprise visit with a potential secret child?

Protecting kids from absentee father, suspicious of his intentions. NTA.

Standing up for the kids against an audacious absentee father!

NTA. You’re already raising his kids. What more does he want?

NTA: Absentee father’s return sparks skepticism and resentment.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/ad7fee67-b383-4f47-9e0d-a1118fe3b53e.png)
NTA for raising his babies while he’s incompetent. Get help!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e84531bb-22d8-4cd3-998d-75e6c9fe39d8.png)
HARD NTA: Standing up for oneself against an absentee father

NTA: He’s just a sperm donor, you owe him nothing

Adoptee’s opinion: Blood doesn’t define family, but boundaries do.

NTA. Manipulative father using emotional blackmail to force his way in. Protect yourself and your kids.

Restraining order and change your number, he’s unstable.

Absentee father struggles with parenting. NTA for being frustrated.

NTA. Don’t let him drop his problems on your doorstep
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/6c60e502-c9bc-46be-b880-dad98f709d4d.png)
Setting boundaries with an absentee father. NTA, stand your ground!

Father’s return: Free babysitting and hidden motives?

Fighting for the kids, the judge ruled in their favor!

Doubts about the emergency and concerns for the children’s safety

NTA: Absentee father expects older kids to babysit. Unfair!

NTA. Abandoned kids, now wants happy families with new wife?

Shocking entitlement: Absentee father wants you to support more kids? NTA

Father’s return sparks controversy over having replacement children.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/25d2e0b7-2c6b-47eb-9441-fe40e25e5dad.png)
NTA: Another child dumped on you? That’s just unfair

NTA. Keep referring him to your attorney for safety

No obligation to care for his child. He’s an idiot.

NTA. You’re a saint and more of a man than he will ever be

NTA: A strong mom keeping her teens safe from an absent father

NTA, but call CPS to protect the child

Avoided an abandoned child? Your brother needs to learn!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/080eda86-c204-4a0e-b189-3010848b1c8b.png)