In the midst of a typical family setting, a chilling statement echoes, causing ripples of shock and hurt. A 16-year-old girl, caught in the crossfire of family responsibility and personal freedom, drops an ultimatum that leaves her family reeling. ‘I’d rather die than care for my autistic brother,’ she declares, a statement that not only reveals her inner turmoil but also exposes the cracks in this family’s foundation. Let’s delve into this emotionally charged saga.
The Unbearable Burden

The Father’s Dilemma

The Unwanted Responsibility

The Unspoken Question

The Dreaded Proposal

The Explosive Response

The Aftermath

The Final Stand

A Family Torn Apart by One Unthinkable Ultimatum
In a tale that tugs at the heartstrings, a 16-year-old girl finds herself at the center of a family crisis. Faced with the prospect of caring for her severely autistic brother, she drops a shocking ultimatum, ‘I’d rather die than care for my brother.’ The fallout is immediate and devastating, with her father left reeling and her older brother accusing her of being heartless. The girl stands firm, insisting that her father needed a clear ‘no.’ As the dust settles, we’re left to ponder the implications of this emotional bombshell. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…
“NTA. That is NOT SOMETHING you ask a 16 year old about. W*f. No way. You could have said it a bit nicer. The dying part was probably too much. But come on, your 16… 16 year olds dies every day. And lives to talk about it. At least where I am from.”

Teen girl refuses lifelong responsibility, family dynamics and hypocrisy.

NTA for declining responsibility. Enmeshment is not healthy.

“NTA – The burden shouldn’t fall on you, sis! “

NTA for not wanting to be caretaker, but language matters

“YTA. Clearly your older brother was capable of giving your dad a firm no without telling him he’d rather die.”

YTA – No obligation, but show some empathy. Manners matter.

YTA. You have the right to say no, but your attitude is entitled

Taking care of a special needs child is an enormous task
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/33de7c33-4b60-454b-8f3e-dec1c535a193.png)
YTA for lack of empathy. Be kinder to your brother

“Barely talk like a normal person” – a concerning red flag

Teen faces backlash for insensitivity towards autistic brother.

“YTA… Your words show a lack of empathy for your brother.”

R**e response to brother’s refusal: YTA ♂️

NTA, but stand your ground and refuse. Don’t let guilt-tripping happen.

Choosing a care home for an autistic sibling: NTA, it’s a huge commitment emotionally, physically, and financially.

“Caring for a mean, severely handicapped sibling is taking years off my mom’s life. NTA.”

NTA for standing up to your father, but show empathy

YTA. Your dad cares, but you deserve happiness too.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/ffdb5488-5cfa-4acb-899a-0c3078ae2cfd.png)
Caring for disabled sibling is tough. Dad needs to plan ahead.

Engaging comment section: Opinions clash on sibling responsibilities with ND person involved

Unpopular opinion, but YTA. Your attitude lacks empathy and understanding.

Harsh response to autistic brother sparks shock and family tension

Polite refusal would’ve sufficed. Drama and rudeness were unnecessary.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/48a41fb9-39a5-4391-a065-8a78e810e23d.png)
“NTA for not wanting to care for your brother”, but YTA for your heartless attitude.

Cruel response to father’s request, brother’s advice is spot-on

Last Updated on February 7, 2024 by Diply Social Team