Family therapy can be a helpful tool for families in conflict, but what happens when speaking your mind only leads to punishment? One 16-year-old girl found herself in this exact predicament. Her family, which includes her half-brother, little sister, and parents, is no stranger to heated arguments. When her parents decided that family therapy was necessary, she was initially on board. But after facing punishment for their honesty during the first session, she and her half-brother decided to take a stand by staying completely silent during the next session.
Dysfunctional Family Life ️
Family Therapy: A New Hope
Punishment for Honesty
Silent Protest Begins
Not a Single Word
Ignoring the Therapist
Parents’ Anger and Therapist’s Struggle
No Punishment This Time
Feeling Guilty
Not Deliberately Rude ♀️
Dad’s Accusation
The Dilemma
Wanting Things to Get Better
The Silent Idea
Silent Treatment: A Necessary Evil?
This 16-year-old girl and her half-brother chose to stay silent during family therapy to avoid punishment for their honest thoughts. Their parents, who were initially angry, didn’t punish them this time. While the girl feels guilty for ignoring the therapist, she wonders if staying silent is the only way to avoid further conflict. She genuinely wants her family to heal, but fears the consequences of speaking up. Is her silent protest justified or should she risk punishment for the sake of progress? Let’s see what the internet thinks…
RELATED STORIES
NTA calls for communication with therapist to address family issues
Encouraging support for a teen’s difficult family situation
Silent therapy? NTA suggests emailing therapist for help
Speaking up in therapy shouldn’t be punished
Therapist should see kids alone for safe communication
NTA for not speaking during family therapy. Commenters empathize
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/488cafb4-ecb9-4129-8403-98319a17f755.png)
Don’t blame the teen, blame the parents. NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/eebc5b80-2c11-4579-bbf5-02720875b894.png)
Commenter defends teen, criticizes parents in therapy session
NTA comment and reply share negative experience with family therapy
Silent teen in therapy with abusive parents: NTA, therapist advice.
Therapist sees through silent act. Client’s motive questioned
Family therapist explains common issue with teens in therapy
Speaking up in therapy may lead to abuse at home
When family therapy goes wrong
Breaking the silence in therapy: tips for teens
Silence is golden: NTA for refusing to speak during therapy
Therapy for two? NTA teen seeks private talk with therapist
Honesty in therapy should be encouraged, not punished. #NTA
Speak up or stay silent? NTA seeks advice in therapy.
Therapy should never feel like punishment. NTA
Teen punished for not speaking in therapy, NTA, parents narcissistic
NTA suggests a solution to speaking freely in therapy
Therapist can help address issues without throwing anyone under the bus
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/1ba2e378-f120-475c-9ab9-48066a1bab75.png)
Therapy for compliance not participation?
Encouraging and supportive reply to a struggling teen.
NTA, but don’t be silent. Speak the truth
Get individual therapy for uninterrupted support.
Family therapist should respect individual privacy. NTA
Honesty is the best policy, even if it means punishment.
NTA stays silent during therapy, parents don’t understand
NTA for speaking the truth and calling out dysfunctionality.
Teen’s silence in family therapy justified, parents sabotaging progress.
Commenter supports teen in therapy, calls parents ridiculous
Teen refuses to speak during therapy, suggests emailing therapist privately
Silent but not guilty: Teen refuses to speak in therapy
OP’s family may have narcissistic tendencies, according to commenter
Struggling to communicate in therapy? Seek help from trusted adults
Advice for teen in family therapy: ask for private sessions.
Teen refuses to speak in therapy due to punishment. NTA.
Teen in lose-lose position, advised to tell therapist about punishment.
Struggling with therapy? You’re not alone. NTA
Speak up to your therapist they’re there to help
Therapist suggests terminating sessions with children, focusing on parents
Encouraging NTA comment to speak up during family therapy
Supportive comment to a teen in family therapy.
Silent but wise: NTA comment approves of therapy silence
Advice on talking to therapist about confidentiality and getting own therapist
Encouraging support for a struggling teenager.
Silence is golden: Teen refuses to speak during family therapy
Speak up or stay silent? Commenter suggests a middle ground.
Encouraging support for a teen in family therapy
Silent protest in therapy: NTA, let the therapist advocate for you
Silent teen receives support for not speaking up in therapy.
Safe space violated, teen refuses to speak during therapy. NTA
Encouraging honesty in therapy is crucial for progress
Silent teen gets support from commenters after family therapy dispute
Commenter advises to leave dysfunctional household for better mental health
Confiding in the therapist may help gain trust.
Engaging in therapy without speaking up: coping strategies
Opening up in therapy can be hard, therapist can help
Supportive comment suggests solution for family conflict
Speaking up or staying silent: a lose-lose situation?
Silent teen receives support after family therapy
Therapist can help you, call them and keep it secret
Teen fears punishment for speaking up in family therapy
Teen refuses to speak in therapy due to punishment. NTA.
