Sister’s Allergies Turned Against Her: Genius or Cruel?

The holiday season brings families together, but it can also bring out the worst in some family members. Our protagonist found herself in a frustrating situation when her sister, Lily, kept smoking around her despite her objections. She tried talking to Lily and even suggested using the designated smoking area at their parents’ house, but nothing seemed to work. Finally, she hatched a plan to use Lily’s dog allergies against her to keep her at bay. But was this a clever solution or just plain cruel?

Holiday Family Time

Horses and Sister Troubles

Sister’s Annoying Habit

Lily Ignores Requests

Tried Talking to Lily ️

Designated Smoking Area Ignored

Enough is Enough!

Lily’s Dog Allergy

Introducing Venus, the Golden Retriever

Venus Joins the Horses

Lily’s Reaction

A Clever Solution?

Pointing to the Smoking Area

Family Sides Chosen ⚖️

Parents’ Verdict

Allergy-Driven Strategy: Justified or Unfair?

In a desperate attempt to keep Lily from smoking around her, our protagonist brought her parents’ dog, Venus, along to the horses, knowing full well that Lily is allergic. Lily was furious, but our protagonist stood her ground, pointing out the designated smoking area. While their siblings sided with Lily, their parents supported our protagonist’s actions. But what do you think? Was this a justified move, or did our protagonist cross the line? Let’s see what the internet has to say…

NTA – Polite request ignored, so low-end confrontation ensued

NTA: Sister ignored request, OP pushed back, she became whiney a**hole

NTA – Genius way to address smoking near horses

“NTA. If you choose to smoke, fine. But you don’t get to choose to smoke around others without their consent.”

Stand up for your health and bring the dog!

Cute doggo helps counter sister’s intentional smoke exposure. NTA!

Fire hazard in stables? Cobwebs are the real danger!

Polite smokers shame inconsiderate ones, sister being inconsiderate. NTA

Passive-aggressive genius: using dog to train sister to smoke elsewhere.

NTA: Smoke vs. Dog – Allergies ignite a heated debate!

Smoking sister gets a taste of her own medicine.

NTA for bringing another animal to protect against secondhand smoke

Smoking area exists for a reason, NTA. Is she malicious?

NTA. Lily needs to use the smoking area

Fire extinguisher revenge: NTA takes allergy warfare to new heights!

NTA for avoiding sister’s smoking near horses

Smoking in a barn? Parents would go ballistic!

Dog’s happiness proves NTA’s genius solution!

Smoke vs. Allergies: Battle of the Breathing Troubles

NTA: Smoking near stables = haywire hazard!

NTA, Lily can f**k right off. Siblings agree.

Smoking in a barn: NTA or a risky move?

NTA and Venus probably appreciate it. New routine, genius or cruel?

Smoking sister becomes the a**hole: NTA comment wins the debate!

Smoking in a horse barn? NTA but major fire hazard!

Polite request denied, so reasonable alternative used. Fairness questioned.

Smokers: Almost Always the A**hole

Smoker shows empathy, sister lacks respect. Family dynamics at play.

Smoking dilemma: Quit or smoke alone? NTA.

“NTA. Personal space matters. Enforcing it with a dog? Genius! “

Smoking in a barn: fire hazard or NTA?

Smoker respects boundaries, sister doesn’t. Genius revenge!