Sister Demands He Takes Care of Her Child, But He’s Got His Hands Full ‍ ‍ ‍

Family can be a source of love and support, but sometimes, expectations can lead to conflict. A man shared his story, where his sister, a single mom, asked him and his wife to take care of her child if anything happened to her. However, the couple’s daughter has a host of medical conditions and requires constant care. They feel they can’t commit to caring for their nephew, leading to a heated argument. Let’s dive into this family drama. ‍ ‍ ‍

Sister’s Request

Daughter’s Condition

The Tough Decision

Sister’s Reaction

No Close Friends to Help

The Controversial Statement

Wife’s Opinion

Financial Struggles

Temporary Solution?

Emotional Toll

Willing to Help, But…

Daughter’s Future Arrangements

Foster System as Last Resort

Family Expectations vs. Reality

In a heart-wrenching tale of family expectations and reality, a man and his wife are faced with a tough decision when his sister asks them to care for her child if anything happens to her. Their own daughter’s medical conditions and the emotional and financial toll it takes on the family make it impossible for them to commit to raising their nephew. Despite offering financial support, the couple stands firm on their decision, leading to a rift between siblings. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…

NTA for refusing to take care of sister’s child. Valid reasons.

Putting your own child and mental health first is important.

Sister’s choice, sister’s responsibility. NTA for setting boundaries.

User suggests possible solutions and tactful approach.

NTA. OP’s sister may have lied during evaluation for IVF.

Sibling puts OP in impossible situation, NTA for reacting.

Productive conversation needed. Finances not the only issue.

NTA for prioritizing your child’s needs over your sister’s demands . Neglecting a child with special needs is a serious issue . Your decision shows great parenting ‍ ‍ ‍ .

Clear-cut NTA verdict with no room for debate

Concerns raised about sister’s health, but also pandemic-related anxiety.

Caring for a child with severe medical needs is already overwhelming

Parenting responsibilities clash with sister’s demands ‍ ‍ ‍

Sister demands childcare, but NTA has valid reasons to refuse

Parent with autistic child explains why he can’t take on more.

Choosing not to burden a child with disabled sibling. NTA

Reasonable request, reasonable response. NTA for prioritizing your daughter.

Putting his daughter first, NTA comment receives support

Sibling disagreement over child guardianship, but both have valid points ‍ ‍ ‍

Being a parent means planning for ‘what ifs’, NTA for declining.

Sibling of disabled person supports OP’s decision, NTA

Commenter clarifies reason for family estrangement due to prejudice.

Sibling conflict over child custody and mental health. ‍ ‍ ‍

Being honest about limitations is important. NTA

NTA commenter suggests taking the kid in themselves.

Sometimes strangers are the best options. ‍♂️

Not obligated to take in sister’s child. NTA

Sibling demands childcare, but NTA stands firm.

Straightforward NTA comment shuts down entitled sister.

Short and sweet. The commenter is not the a**hole.

Sister wants OP to take care of her child, but NAH.

Commenter criticized for lack of tact in NTA judgement

Support worker confirms OP is NTA for refusing sister’s demands

Sister demands he take care of her child, but he’s NTA.

Commenter suggests medical issue for sister’s behavior.

Cousin’s experience shows it’s okay to prioritize own limitations. NTA

Responsibility doesn’t equal a**hole. Sister needs to plan better

Politely declining sister’s request due to prior commitments. NTA

Taking responsibility for one’s actions. Not the a**hole

Sibling demands childcare, but overwhelmed couple says NTA.

Helpful suggestion for a tough situation

Commenter is not the a**hole in this situation.

Respectful NTA declines sister’s request to take care of her child

Commenter judged NTA, but where are the replies?

NTA, sister is a soft a**hole. Offer support for nephew’s future.

When your support system is lacking, taking care of kids is tough

NTA. Sister demanding childcare, but commenters agree he’s not responsible.

Commenter is not the a**hole in this situation.

SIL suggests insurance policy to secure child’s financial future

Compassionate response to a tense situation. Apologize and communicate better.

Commenter confused about obvious reasons for no relationship with parents.

Single mother demands help, but commenter says NTA.

Agreement on not being the a**hole

Honesty is the best policy. NTA for setting boundaries

Parenting a child with a disability is emotionally draining. NTA

Setting boundaries with family members ‍ ‍ ‍ ‍ can be tough. ‍♀️

Commenter is not the a**hole in this situation

Valid concerns. Nephew grieving, sister chose single parenthood. NTA

Setting boundaries is important. Good for you!

Heartfelt support for NTA comment, lots of love sent ❤️

Single mom via sperm donor doesn’t indebt others to help.

Commenter is not the a**hole for refusing sister’s request

Compassionate response to unprepared sister in a stressful situation

Guardianship is a tough decision, especially for non-parents

Setting boundaries to prioritize daughter’s needs is responsible parenting. NTA

No obligation to take in sister’s child. Truth hurts. #NTA

Caring for special needs child is no joke. NTA for saying no.

Commenter questions sister’s sudden fixation on child’s guardianship.

NTA calls out single parents, receives support from commenters

Sibling wants him to take care of her child, but…

Last Updated on June 19, 2023 by Diply Social Team