Picture this: you’re a professor at a large public university, and you’re faced with a dilemma. One of your students has shown incredible integrity by pointing out a mistake in her test marking that would have given her a higher grade. Now, you have to decide whether to reward her honesty or stick to the rules. What would you do? ♀️ This professor chose to bump her grade up based on her character, sparking a heated debate on fairness and ethics in education. Let’s dive into the story…
The Test Marking Dilemma

A Student’s Honesty Shines Through ✨

The Impact on Her Grade

Her Performance in the Course

The Professor’s Controversial Plan

The Reasoning Behind the Decision

A Reward for Integrity

Nobody Else Affected

The TA’s Argument for Fairness ⚖️

A Rare Occurrence

The Professor’s Perspective

A Thought-Provoking Question ❓

The Final Decision

Keeping It Quiet

The Alternative Approach

A Professor’s Unusual Reward for Honesty
So, here’s the situation: a professor at a large public university faced a unique dilemma when a student came forward to correct a mistake in her test marking, which would lower her grade. The professor decided to not only return the 2.5% she would have lost but also reward her with an additional 2.5% for her honesty. This controversial decision sparked a debate on fairness and ethics in education, with the TA arguing that it’s unfair to other students. The professor, however, believes that this rare act of integrity deserves recognition. What do you think about this professor’s choice? Let’s see what the internet has to say…
Professor’s decision to bump grade based on character praised

NTA comment supports professor’s decision to bump student’s grade based on character

Grateful student receives grade bump based on character

Rewarding integrity over grades

Debate over bumping student’s grade based on character.

Grading based on character? Commenters disagree with professor’s decision.

Controversy over professor’s decision to bump student’s grade based on character

Unfair advantage? Commenter says YTA for bumping grade based on character

Professor’s grading decision defended against TA’s mistake.

Student’s grade bumped based on character, fair or not?

Is it fair to bump up a student’s grade based on character?

Debate on grading based on character in academic classes

Grade bump for good character? Controversial decision sparks debate.

NTA. Adjusting grades for soft skills is fair and justifiable.

Giving grades based on character? YTA according to commenters
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/0364c910-8afe-489a-86b0-3a8944fe2942.png)
Grading based on character: controversial or refreshing?

Grades based on character? Commenters say YTA.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/8f5c95a8-4bf7-4b72-8fa0-715c5b8ec9c7.png)
Student’s honesty rewarded with grade bump, but slight YTA for favoritism.

Commenter calls out professor’s unfair grading system, YTA.

Professor’s character-based grading: Mild YTA, but potential consequences.

Professor’s character-based grading deemed unfair by commenter. YTA.

Integrity over grades – A refreshing take on education

Controversial grading decision sparks debate on fairness and favoritism

Objectivity vs. Integrity: A Slippery Slope

Bumping up grades based on character: NTA or YTA?

Debate over professor’s decision to grade based on character

Commenter accuses professor of favoritism. YTA verdict given.

Student calls out professor’s grading system with Harry Potter reference ⚡

Student calls out professor’s controversial grading decision.

Devaluing hard work? Is bumping grades based on character wrong?

Med school dreams vs. fairness? Commenter says YTA ♂️

Honesty doesn’t pay off? Commenter thinks professor is TA

Teacher’s decision to bump grade based on character criticized
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/974d5fd7-7e29-4e95-9114-cd14781467d0.png)
Professor’s decision to bump a student’s grade based on character is controversial

Grade bump for character: unfair competition or deserved recognition?

Grade bump for good character: fair or unfair? YTA thinks unfair

Controversial grading based on character: YTA or NAH?

Fellow professor calls out cringe-worthy email from colleague
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e2e443c3-18e4-4f88-b025-54d620303c29.png)
Pre-med student’s ethical dilemma sparks grade debate

Clearing up the confusion: TA stands for Teachers Assistant

Student’s integrity rewarded with grade bump

Fairness in grading debated, with surprising TA defense

Universities should value soft skills alongside grades. NTA.

A commenter suggests a new grading system for the professor.

Grading based on character? YTA according to this commenter.

Bumping grades based on character? YTA or NAH?

Commenter deems professor as the a**hole.

Questionable approach to grading, sketchy to raise grade at end

Professor’s grade bump decision sparks debate among commenters.

Commenter disagrees with professor’s decision to bump grade based on character

Student accuses professor of unfair grading practices

Student accuses professor of favoritism, calls them out for breaking the system

Fairness concerns raised over professor’s grading based on character

Offering a letter of recommendation for a lower grade?

Is character relevant to biology? Debating grade bumps based on honesty.

Student’s grade bumped based on character: Fair or arbitrary?

Integrity pays off: Professor bumps grade based on character

Boosting a capable student’s grade for honesty

Australian grading system differs from others, sparking cultural confusion

Lecturer calls out unprofessional behavior of grade bump based on character

Concerns raised over potential legal issues with bumping grade based on character

Grades based on character? NTA or YTA? Engage in debate

Commenter disagrees with grading based on character, calls American system stupid

Commenter compares professor to Dumbledore and Neville Longbottom

Professor faces backlash for bumping student’s grade based on character
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/b27b523f-a75a-4980-8172-ca1c8ac453f6.png)
Grading based on character? Ethically concerning. Discrimination a factor.

Grades based on character? YTA. Ability should be the focus
