Imagine being asked a simple question: ‘How many kids do you have?’ For most, the answer is straightforward. But for one mother, it’s a heart-wrenching dilemma. Her oldest son, Josh, was tragically killed in a boating accident when he was just 6 years old. Now, when asked about her children, she finds herself torn between acknowledging her deceased son and avoiding the discomfort it often brings to others. This dilemma has led to a family feud that’s left everyone questioning: was she wrong?
A Family Torn Apart by Tragedy

The Uncomfortable Question

A Painful Revelation

A Husband’s Accusation

The Mother’s Defense

The Husband’s Retort

The Fallout

The Final Question

A Mother’s Struggle: Caught Between Grief and Social Grace
Caught in the crossfire of grief and social grace, this mother’s struggle is as heartbreaking as it is relatable. Her oldest son’s tragic death has left a void that’s hard to navigate in casual conversations. Her husband’s accusation that she’s trying to erase their son’s memory has only added fuel to the fire. The family feud that ensued has left everyone questioning: was she wrong to omit her deceased son, or is she simply trying to spare others the discomfort? Let’s delve into the internet’s thoughts on this emotionally charged situation.
NTA. It’s okay to protect yourself from painful conversations.

NTA – Protecting yourself by not always bringing up your deceased child

“Coping with grief differently: a delicate balance. ✨”

Engaging with foster siblings and navigating grief – NAH.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/64983109-e934-47be-bc07-9d4c30329921.png)
Understanding the struggle of discussing deceased loved ones.

NTA: Grieving mother’s choice to keep son’s memory private

Dealing with grief differently: privacy vs open discussion
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/b7a33a84-5143-4c61-9c36-20709a594368.png)
Understanding the delicate balance of grief and communication.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/c3f859c0-558e-4f2d-965d-19dcd6a6c923.png)
NTA. Your children, living or gone, are no one’s business

Heartbreaking dilemma of mentioning deceased son and dealing with insensitive comments

Navigating the delicate balance of mentioning a deceased loved one.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/c92d6403-9832-46a8-ad41-45fd8594d552.png)
Engaging dilemma: To mention or not to mention deceased loved ones?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/930fae87-8cc2-46d3-acc2-1ccc58e00d6c.png)
NAH: Couple struggles with how to honor deceased son together ❤️

NTA. Grief is personal. Don’t subject yourself to unnecessary pain.

“No photos, no mention. My sister never gets mentioned.”

Coping with loss: Different ways to handle the pain ❤️

NTA: Dealing with grief differently can strain relationships. Seek counseling.

Avoiding the awkwardness of talking about a deceased child.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/15e033b6-5232-40ff-88d6-b386b169eac4.png)
NTA. Grieving mother shares her struggle to mention her deceased son.

Lying about a deceased loved one to strangers for self-preservation.

Sharing my story of loss and navigating conversations about it

Heartbreaking dilemma: Should she mention her deceased son?

Respecting personal boundaries when discussing a deceased child.

Heartbreaking dilemma: Mother’s choice to mention her deceased son
