We’ve all had those sentimental items that hold a special place in our hearts. But what happens when a well-intentioned mom accidentally gives away her son’s cherished dog collar? It’s a story of miscommunication, frustration, and a whole lot of drama. Let’s dive into this emotional rollercoaster and find out what went down.
The Beloved Family Dog

Moving Out and Leaving Memories Behind

Time for a Basement Cleanup

A Collar Finds a New Home

Thanksgiving Meltdown

The Harsh Truth Revealed

Furious Son Demands Answers

Mom’s Honest Mistake ♀️

No Turning Back ⏳

Heated Argument Ensues

Mom Stands Her Ground

Son’s Unreasonable Demand ♂️

A Mother’s Dilemma

A Sentimental Item Gone Forever?
So, here’s the situation: a loving mom accidentally gives away her son’s sentimental dog collar during a basement cleanup, and all hell breaks loose when he finds out. The son is furious, demanding his mom retrieves the collar, but she stands her ground since she had warned him about unmarked boxes. As emotions run high, we can’t help but wonder if there’s any hope for reconciliation or if this cherished item is lost forever. Let’s see what the internet has to say about this heart-wrenching dilemma.
Mom throws away son’s sentimental item, YTA comment section.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/2cd9fc0c-3c24-411b-8275-3eb2e0a570ff.png)
Throwing away son’s things while he’s at school? YTA big time

Parenting gone wrong Son’s sentimental dog collar given away

YTA gets called out for not using phone to share photos.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/561a7fea-913b-4c1c-9d4e-576aef752ea8.png)
Lesson learned: Always ask before throwing away sentimental items. YTA.

Mom throws away son’s sentimental dog collar, YTA according to comment

YTA for giving away sentimental dog collar without checking with son

Misunderstanding leads to sentimental item being thrown away
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/8fef3ac5-de6e-4550-9b20-9035f4072c6d.png)
Mom’s mistake with sentimental collar – YTA verdict

Moving mishap leads to sentimental item being thrown out. YTA.

Mom mistakenly donates son’s sentimental dog collar YTA for not verifying.

Mom threw away sentimental dog collar, YTA according to commenter.

Mom faces backlash for giving away son’s sentimental dog collar

Heartfelt comment about a lost pet’s sentimental collar

Throwing away son’s sentimental items makes YTA

YTA for giving away sentimental item without checking its value
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/f189a429-4037-4390-ae39-0c0fa66422da.png)
User calls out OP for lack of consideration and empathy

Labeling boxes is key! NTA, but communication is important

Sibling’s past experience leads to YTA judgement with empathy

Mom’s actions deemed wrong, lacked empathy. YTA confirmed by comments.

User defends mom who gave away sentimental dog collar. NTA

Don’t be a mom who throws away sentimental possessions

Mom’s actions questioned, trust with son at stake. YTA ♀️

Sentimental dog collar thrown away without asking. YTA

Don’t throw away sentimental items without checking first. YTA.

Sentimental items mistakenly given away, YTA. Offer to make amends

Mom throws away sentimental item, called out for being TA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/07053d9b-fbd7-42dc-89af-02fa775a0c57.png)
Mom gave away sentimental item, OP is the a**hole.

YTA for giving away your son’s sentimental items without asking.

Throwing out his sentimental item was wrong. YTA.

Mom throws away son’s sentimental item, called out for it.

Mom throws away son’s sentimental item without consent

College student’s sentimental item given away by mom, NTA response.

Don’t mess with a dead pet’s collar, YTA

Parent’s attempt at teaching lesson backfires, labeled YTA by commenter.

User calls out OP for not communicating before giving away item.

User calls out OP for giving away sentimental item.

Mom throws away son’s sentimental dog collar, called out for being TA.

User calls out OP for lack of remorse over lost collar

Devastating experience of losing sentimental items. YTA for sure

Keeping sentimental items can bring joy for years to come

Parental empathy questioned in lost dog collar debacle

User calls out commenter for being materialistic. YTA.

Mom gets called out for giving away son’s sentimental item.

Mom faces backlash for giving away son’s sentimental dog collar

Mom could have communicated better with her son. YTA.

Unmarked boxes or not, YTA for giving away sentimental item.

Parental sentimentality vs. clutter: YTA or NAH?

Mom gives away son’s sentimental dog collar as punishment. YTA

User calls out OP for teaching an unnecessary lesson.

Giving away sentimental item = YTA, a major one

Insensitive mom throws away son’s sentimental item. YTA.

Mom gives away son’s sentimental dog collar Commenter calls her out

User calls out OP for being the a**hole.

Mom gives away son’s dog collar, called a**hole in comments

Labeling system or not, YTA should have warned him beforehand

Mom’s mistake with sentimental collar sparks YTA backlash

Mom faces backlash for giving away son’s sentimental dog collar

YTA for throwing away sentimental dog collar. Be there for your son

Lost sentimental items, OP is YTA for not verifying first

Parenting gone wrong YTA throws away sentimental item
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/bc37b044-b626-4141-8d27-4d131b566dc0.png)
Mom mistakenly gave away son’s sentimental dog collar. YTA.

Mom gave away son’s sentimental dog collar, YTA according to commenter

Mom faces backlash for giving away son’s cherished dog collar

Mom threw away son’s sentimental dog collar without asking. YTA.

Sentimental dog collar thrown away. YTA says commenter.

Mom throws away son’s sentimental item. Commenter calls her out.

User calls out OP for carelessly giving away sentimental item

Heartbroken commenter calls out ‘YTA’ for giving away sentimental collar

Suggestion for a simple solution, but YTA according to commenter.

Mom throws away son’s sentimental dog collar, YTA according to comment

Did she knowingly give away his sentimental item? YTA or NAH?

User questions OP’s motives, deems them the a**hole.

Mom gives away son’s sentimental dog collar without permission. YTA.

Mom throws away sentimental item, called out for being YTA

Son’s mom threw away his belongings when he left for military

A petty move or an honest mistake? Mixed opinions here
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/f7e67e85-68ae-4dc0-b1e5-aa52e3fde190.png)
Opinion divided over son’s reaction to lost dog collar
