Man Refuses to Split Finances with GF After She Denied Him Years Ago: Fair or Foul?

Picture this: A couple moves in together and the girlfriend earns more than the boyfriend. He suggests pooling their finances, but she declines, wanting to keep their money separate. Fast forward two years, and the tables have turned. The boyfriend is now earning significantly more than his girlfriend. Suddenly, she’s all for sharing their income. What would you do in this situation?

The Initial Financial Situation

Pooling Finances? Not So Fast!

Separate Finances It Is!

A Change in Earnings

More Promotions on the Horizon

Suddenly, She Wants to Share

Family and Friends Weigh In

Is He in the Wrong?

A Financial Feud: Is He Being Unfair?

This tale of love and money has our protagonist questioning his actions. After his girlfriend refused to pool their finances when they first moved in together, he’s now refusing to do so after a series of promotions left him earning more than her. With family and friends chiming in, he’s left wondering if he’s being unfair or simply standing his ground. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this sticky situation…

Keep finances separate if not married. Legal protection with license.

Don’t keep score, focus on ‘we’ not ‘me’

Keep finances separate until marriage. NTA for doing so.

ESH conflict over money and grudges in a relationship

Fair game: Man refuses to split finances with ex-girlfriend.

Don’t combine finances unless married. Girlfriend lacks ‘us’ mentality. NTA.

Partner wanting to pool finances only when favorable is NTA. Scorekeeping breeds resentment.

Negotiating finances in relationships, not automatic. Refusal as payback unfair.

Different ways to split finances: 50/50, proportional to income, combined.

Combining finances: trust, risk, or revenge?

NTA. Communication is key. Keep it civil and honest.

Combining finances after a raise? Both suck

Discussing finances is important for serious relationships

Sharing finances in a long-term relationship: joint or separate accounts?

Separate finances are fair, a joint account for mutual expenses.

Money talks, and so does fairness. NTA for standing firm.

Suggestion for fair and equitable split of joint finances.

Separate finances are a good idea regardless of what you make

Treating others the way you want to be treated ✌️

NTA, but unequal income can create an unhealthy power dynamic

Fair or foul? NTA comment discusses financial hypocrisy in relationship.

Open communication is key to healthy finances and relationships.

User questions OP’s assumptions about GF’s motives for not combining finances.

ESH, communication is key to avoid resentment in relationships

Married commenter advises offering to take on larger bills together ❤️

NAH. Keeping scores isn’t healthy in a long term relationship.

Sorting out finances in a relationship: NTA’s advice for less stress

Both parties being a**holes, need to communicate and compromise ‍♂️

Fair or foul? Commenter says NTA, suggests income-based expenses splitting.

Man refuses to split finances with GF after past denial: NTA

Keep finances separate until marriage, says commenter. NTA.

Sharing finances is not necessary before marriage. Tit-for-tat is childish.

NAH for sticking to initial decision, but need to discuss future.

User questions the wisdom of pooling finances with a girlfriend.

NTA, but grow up and learn to let go of grudges.

Honest conversation about finances is crucial for a healthy relationship.

The grandmother’s advice on separate accounts is a great idea

Karma is a b***h! Man refuses to split finances with ex-girlfriend.

Financial support in a relationship can come in many forms

Combining finances is not necessary in a relationship. NTA.

Sharing finances is important in a healthy relationship. NTA.

Discussing finances with a professional may save your relationship

Culture plays a role in finances, but promotions can be rapid.

Money troubles in a relationship. NAH, but red flag?

A detailed breakdown of how to split finances in relationships

Splitting finances after rejection: NTA but two wrongs don’t make right

Discussing finances before marriage is important. Good advice!

Sharing finances is not necessary for a successful relationship

User agrees with the dad and advises to sign a pre-nup.

NTA commenter advises man not to marry his girlfriend and take an exit now to avoid paying alimony later.

NTA, don’t share finances. Polite rejection, no good reason to change.

NTA but resentment and power dynamics can kill relationships.

NTA. Splitting finances can lead to trouble. Your girlfriend’s motives?

Fair or foul? Commenter questions division of household labor as currency.

OP advises against combining finances before marriage, with a touch of humor

Keep finances separate until marriage, pool 75% into joint account. NTA.

Fair compromise or petty revenge? NTA refuses to split finances.

Set up joint account with proportional split based on income. Don’t be petty.

NTA suggests compromise for finances, recommends couples counseling for relationship.

Should they split finances equally? ESH for being petty.

Keep your finances separate to avoid relationship conflicts.

Sharing finances can work with compromise and communication.

Living with someone who tilts things in their favor? NTA

Never combine finances, but if you’re keeping score, it’s over.

Financial independence in relationships. NTA’s perspective.

Seeking advice for a healthy relationship and finances

NAH couple debates merging finances after 5 years together.

Red flag alert! Commenter warns of GF’s narcissistic behavior.

Consider a joint account for shared costs to avoid resentment

NTA but keeping score isn’t good in relationships. Good communication is

NAH – Open communication is key for a happy financial setup

Pooling finances now makes more sense given Covid circumstances. NAH.