Man Refuses to Give Parents Monthly Allowance: Heartless or Prudent?

In a world where familial relationships often intertwine with financial obligations, one 31-year-old man finds himself at the heart of a heated debate. After landing his first job following a career change, he was asked by his parents to provide them with a monthly allowance. However, he declined, citing his need to save for his future. This decision, while practical, has left him feeling conflicted and questioning his actions. Let’s delve into this intriguing story of familial bonds, financial responsibilities, and the quest for a secure future.

Career Change and New Responsibilities

The Filial Request

Financial Background

Previous Contributions and Debts

Wife’s Support and Sacrifice

Investing in the Future

The Dilemma of Repayment

Balancing Act: Parents vs Future

The Immigrant’s Sacrifice

A Man’s Struggle: Family Obligations vs Financial Stability

Caught in a whirlwind of familial responsibility and financial planning, our protagonist is desperately trying to find a balance. Having just started his career after a change, he’s faced with the request of providing a monthly allowance to his nearing-retirement parents. However, his financial goals and responsibilities towards his supportive wife make him hesitant. With only 15k in savings and a monthly saving of 800 after expenses, he’s torn between his aging parents’ needs and his own future plans. The story intensifies as we learn about his immigrant parents’ sacrifices, adding another layer to this emotional dilemma. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…

Giving parents allowance: cultural differences and personal responsibility. NTA.

Putting your future first and setting boundaries with family

NTA – Don’t let your parents’ financial choices burden your child!

NTA. Prudent decision to prioritize own financial stability and family.

Commenter owes parents for raising him, clarifies in reply.

NAH, discuss with wife and parents about financial boundaries

NTA. Communicate with your parents and make a game plan

NTA for not giving parents allowance. Wife’s sacrifices undervalued.

Curious about the wife’s perspective and shared goals.

Supporting parents vs. starting a family: a tough choice

Did the parents financially support their child’s education?

Cultural differences make this a tricky situation.

Are your parents elderly? Do they need financial support?

NTA: You don’t owe them anything, but some parents manipulate.

How much allowance should he give his parents?

NTA. Parents’ sacrifice for better opportunities, but it’s your choice.

NTA. Struggling to support parents without sacrificing your own family.

Cultural issue: Monthly allowance for parents, prepare for heated discussion.

Cultural differences impact whether to support parents financially. Considerate advice.

Parents should not expect a monthly allowance from their children. NTA.

“Retirement isn’t an age.” Should you financially support your parents?

NTA: Balancing financial stability and parental expectations can be challenging

NTA: Parents’ responsibility to care for you, not your indebtedness.

“Prudent son explains why he’s not giving parents allowance yet. “

Parents aren’t entitled to your wealth. NTA for setting boundaries.

No allowance for parents who didn’t pay for your schooling?

Immigrant child breaks free from tradition, sparks debate on obligations

NTA. Prioritizing financial security for your family.

Fair compromise: Hard work should be rewarded, but within limits.

Deciding whether to support parents financially. Balancing responsibilities.

Engaging comment defending responsibility to support parents, despite financial constraints.

Can they downsize? Planning for retirement and finances.

Cultural expectations vs personal financial goals: finding a middle ground

NTA. Parents charged rent & didn’t pay for school. Treat them.

Prudent Redditor advises on discussing finances and future plans

NTA: Setting up a matching funds system can ease cultural expectations

Asian culture values monthly allowance, but contribution is important too.

Balancing cultural expectations and personal responsibilities.

Putting your spouse first is important for a healthy relationship ❤️

NTA. Take care of your own family first. No guilt.

Mixed opinions on giving parents allowance. What’s your take?

NTA. Financial priorities lie with your spouse and future.

Parents asking for allowance, but NTA. Need more info.

Be kind to your parents, but find a compromise

Invest in yourself first, then share the wealth!

Outsider perspective on cultural expectations of giving parents monthly allowance.

Planning for your family needs over your parents’ wants.

NTA: Parents asking for money, jeopardizing your future and family.

Navigating filial responsibility: saving up for the future while helping

NTA. Prioritizing your financial stability before supporting retired parents.

Having kids as a retirement plan? NTA, but controversial!

Focus on family first! NTA for setting boundaries.

Saving for kids? $800 isn’t a lot, NTA!

NTA – You’ve already paid your dues, prioritize your wife ❤️

Putting your wife first: NTA for prioritizing your family ❤️

NTA: Prioritizing your wife and potential family is reasonable and fair.

NTA – Prioritizing parents over grandchildren? Risky move for marriage.

Refusing monthly allowance for parents: Prudent or heartless?

Parents sacrifice for kids without expecting repayment. NTA for refusing.

NTA: Symbolic allowance shows respect, prioritize future family.

NTA. Prioritizing savings is important for financial stability.

NTA, but prioritize paying off debt and building funds for kids

No responsibility to parents: financial or otherwise. ‍♂️

Op refuses parents’ monthly allowance to secure their own future. NTA

Parent refuses allowance, commenters agree it’s heartless in this situation ❤️

Generational clash: NAH, cultural differences cause conflict and misunderstanding.

Cultural clash: Filial piety vs. personal boundaries. Reddit’s take?

Generous or Selfish? The Dilemma of Supporting Aging Parents

Cultural clash: Balancing expectations and financial feasibility

Should you financially support your parents? Reddit is divided.

Cultural respect: Even $50/month shows gratitude and stability.

Heartless or prudent? This person chooses to not give anything