Imagine planning the perfect proposal for your girlfriend, only to have your brother steal your thunder – and your ring! That’s exactly what happened to a 26-year-old man who had been preparing to propose to his 24-year-old girlfriend on their 4th anniversary. But after his older brother swooped in and used the same ring to propose to his own girlfriend, the younger sibling was left with no choice but to demand a new ring.
A Perfect Proposal Plan
Brother’s Sneaky Intentions
“Can I Borrow Your Ring?”
The Placeholder Ring Excuse
A Firm No
The Stolen Ring
Caught Red-Handed
Confrontation and Confession
The Ring’s Tainted Reputation
Demanding a New Ring
Brother Caves In
The New Ring
Brother’s Accusations
A Broken Relationship
Mom’s Divided Opinion
A Tale of Two Rings and a Broken Bond
In a whirlwind of drama, a man’s proposal plans were shattered when his brother stole his engagement ring and used it for his own proposal. The younger brother demanded a new ring, leading to a bitter fight and a damaged relationship. With the older brother now accusing him of being inconsiderate and childish, and their mother torn between supporting both sides, it’s clear that this family’s bond has been severely tested. Will they ever be able to reconcile? ♀️ Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…
RELATED STORIES
NTA. Brother steals engagement ring. Is he the worst brother?
NTA wants new ring after brother steals his
NTA. Brother’s fault. Sit down and explain. Rip the band-aid.
NTA. Brother stole ring, threatening relationship. Trust broken, consequences deserved.
OP’s brother steals engagement ring . OP plans to come clean after proposing
Brother steals engagement ring, ruins proposal, and lies to fiance
Brother steals engagement ring, ruins surprise. NTA for demanding replacement.
“NTA – He never intended to return the ring. Good for you!”
INFO: Fiancé deserves to know she’s engaged to a thief
NTA: Brother’s betrayal, lies, and accusations. Turdly actions for proposal.
“NTA, he straight up stole the ring. Massive a**hole!”
NTA. Stolen ring, petty accusations? You’re considerate and mature!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/38f70576-f45f-4e16-ac6f-92be81dd28a0.png)
Brother steals engagement ring, ruins proposal surprise. NTA for demanding replacement
Outrageous! You’re definitely NTA in this crazy situation!
Expose the jerk brother to save future sister-in-law’s happiness!
NTA. Brother steals engagement ring. Theft is not borrowing
NTA. Brother stole ring, demand new one. Fair and justified.
“NTA…. And everyone would know. Starting with my GF and then his GF. This can’t be true. Please, please tell me this is clickbait. How can someone be so selfish. Your brother is a liar, a thief, and a master manipulator. Your mom is an enabler. This is crazy. Right is right and wrong is wrong.” – Reddit user seeks validation
NTA – Brother stole your ring. Let’s end it here.
NTA, buying a placeholder ring is more reasonable than stealing
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/588992f8-0feb-418c-80a4-97547de227ad.png)
NTA demands new ring, chaos awaits when truth is revealed
Brother steals engagement ring. Commenter defends victim, calls out brother.
Brother steals engagement ring, commenter feels sorry for fiancée.
NTA: Stealing a placeholder ring? That’s a low blow
