Imagine this: You and your partner have been saving for years to buy a small, cozy house. Suddenly, your future in-laws offer a generous wedding gift – a beautiful, spacious house in their neighborhood. You’re over the moon… until they reveal the catch. They want you to share this dream home with your fiancé’s sister, indefinitely. What would you do?
The House Hunting Journey Begins
A Generous Offer Appears!
The Dream Home, Almost Too Good to Be True ✨
The Compromise: A House for a Loan
The Unexpected Condition: A New Roommate?
Claire’s Story: A Sister in Need ♀️
The Dilemma: A House or Personal Space?
The Fallout: A Family Feud Erupts!
The Final Stand: A House Refused
A House Divided: The Aftermath of a Generous Offer Gone Wrong
In the aftermath of the heated argument, the couple is left questioning their decision. They’ve been branded as selfish for refusing the ‘free’ house and causing inconvenience to their in-laws’ friend. To add to the emotional turmoil, Claire, the sister, is upset too, as she was looking forward to moving in with them. It’s a sticky situation, with emotions running high and relationships on the line. What’s your take on this? Let’s see what the internet has to say about this intriguing family drama…
NTA – A gift shouldn’t come with strings attached!
NTA: In-laws offered a ‘free’ house with unexpected conditions. Declined wisely.
In-laws trying to force lifelong caretaking under the guise of a gift
A disaster! City’s insane housing market, unexpected strings attached. NTA!
NTA: Declining offer to care for sister with mental illness.
Dodging bullets and enjoying the fallout!
NTA Wow oh wow, they s**k. They thought you’d be forced to say yes
NTA. Reject the ‘free’ house with unwanted strings attached!
Dodging a mess with unexpected strings attached!
Claim your independence! Say no to sharing and find your own home!
Parents’ sneaky plan to make you responsible for sister’s care
NTA! Unfair condition for a new married couple
Obvious bait and switch! They’re trying to control you!
NTA. Don’t sacrifice your freedom for their unreasonable request.
NTA, but beware of in-laws’ hidden expectations.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/826fb5d3-186f-48a9-b656-e4e5f08fbc6c.png)
NTA declined a shady gift with unexpected strings attached.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/a6431871-c3d3-4892-93d0-5cd392457472.png)
Congrats on the new stage of life! NTA for declining!
Parents trying to pass responsibility of SIL. Not cool!
Setting boundaries for gifts to avoid future complications.
Dishonest in-laws and a manipulative scheme. NTA for refusing!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/624c7aba-802c-4d9d-adb1-509fa8b599f3.png)
Nightmare in-laws and a house with hidden horrors!
Unwanted houseguests and hidden responsibilities. Not cool!
Manipulative in-laws trying to trap you? Don’t take the bait!
Newlyweds don’t need unwanted gifts with strings attached
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/488d35be-aa0d-4277-8e78-b5ff08131cc3.png)
Sneaky gift with strings attached! Stay strong and buy your own.
NTA: They’re not offering a free home, but a caretaker role.
Manipulative ‘gift’ exposes true intentions. NTA for seeing through it.
Living arrangements: Sharing spaces or separate dwelling? Pros and cons.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/5c1481e8-953d-4c9c-93d9-95c23729f498.png)
Living with another adult indefinitely? No thanks!
NTA. ‘Cloak and dagger’ setup, shame on them for treating you all like pawns.
Choosing independence over indebtedness
Refusing in-laws’ offer: Are they desperate to give away house?
Deceitful in-laws? NTA for calling out their conditional ‘free’ gift!
Generous gift with strings attached? NTA, they’re the a**holes!
In-laws trying to dump autistic sister-in-law on you? NTA!
NTA. Beware of the ‘free’ house with hidden responsibilities!
NTA. Stick to your original plan and avoid this Faustian deal.
Parents’ ‘free’ house gift turns into a permanent houseguest nightmare!
Beware of ‘free’ gifts with strings attached! It’s bribery!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/9680a8b3-dd35-4446-a136-604a72c30a2b.png)
NTA, setting up a lifetime caretaker role is unfair and unreasonable
Manipulative parents try to control you with a ‘gift’
NTA calls out guilt-tripping parents and their ‘strings attached’ gift
Expensive ‘free’ house? Not the a**hole for pointing that out!
“Free” money with strings attached? Walk away and be happy!
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/0fd9b13b-9d80-444b-9d17-23875a654be4.png)
NTA for not wanting to take on caretaker responsibilities.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3375e96a-aa9f-4b67-93be-9ca87095ebbc.png)
In-laws trying to dump SIL on you? NTA! ♀️
Privacy concerns arise when a couple rejects unwanted houseguests.
A cruel bait-and-switch! NTA for calling out their deception!
NTA: Unfair surprise ‘gift’ jeopardizes major commitment. Seek own housing.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e19207af-404d-48df-9a03-aca71cd852f4.png)
Navigating a disingenuous proposal with entitled in-laws. NTA!
Heartbreaking situation: Parents trying to offload disabled child.
Unexpected offer: Can I be your sister-in-law’s caretaker instead? ♀️
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/a62eb77c-201a-49c0-b214-a6d47015349b.png)
“NTA. Just say ‘no’! Don’t let your in-laws manipulate you. “
NTA: Why not buy sister the house? Selfishness at play.
NTA. Parents’ ‘nice’ gift: a house with a lifetime sister package?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/8dd1a7cc-fe51-482e-88ae-4cecad310ad3.png)
Parents paying to get rid of daughter?
Newlyweds outraged as someone else moves into their dream home!
NTA. Avoid the drama and enjoy your own tiny house!
A ‘free’ gift should come without any strings attached!
Refusing a bribe? Not much moral wrong. You’re NTA!
Last Updated on January 2, 2024 by Diply Social Team
