Imagine being a goldsmith, knowing exactly what you want for your engagement ring, and even offering to make it yourself to save money. Sounds like a dream come true, right? Well, not for our Ring Queen (36f) who found herself in a tricky situation when her fiancé (38m) decided to ignore their agreement and buy her a ring she didn’t want. Let’s dive into this sparkling conflict and see what went wrong…
A Goldsmith’s Dream ✨
Marriage Conversations
The Perfect Ring Plan
A Cheaper, Better Option
The Unexpected Proposal
The Wrong Ring
The Confrontation
The Costly Mistake
The Accusations
The Resolution… Sort Of
Ring Queen’s Dilemma: Ungrateful or Justified?
Our Ring Queen found herself in a sparkling conflict when her fiancé ignored their agreement and bought her an engagement ring she didn’t want. Despite her goldsmith expertise and the fact that she could make her dream ring for a fraction of the cost, her fiancé chose to buy a ring that was everything she didn’t want. When confronted, he called her ungrateful and said she should just be glad he got her a ring. While he’s agreed to return the unwanted ring, he’s not happy about it. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation.
RELATED STORIES
Clear communication and respect are key in engagement ring decisions
Fiancé disregarded agreement, defended actions. Red flag for future?
Creating a custom ring is fun and sentimental! ❤️
Fiancé agrees to return ring but calls her ungrateful
Expert fiancée advises on deferring to partner’s tastes in jewelry
Traditional ring purchase causes concern for future decisions
Fiancé ignores preferences, gives hated ring in name of ‘tradition’
Goldsmith saves money on rings, convinces husband to do the same.
Clear communication ignored for outdated gender roles. NTA.
Fiancé breaks agreement, justifies it with tradition, manipulates and gaslights.
Fiancé buys dream ring that looks nothing like it
Fiancée wants dream ring, but NTA suggests making own.
Red flag alert! Take time to reflect on encounter.
Fiancée unhappy with ring choice, NTA for wanting something different
Fiancé ignores partner’s ring preferences, expects gratitude for money spent
Fiancé disregards ring preferences, insults and scares bride-to-be. NTA
Woman designs dream ring, gets replica of father-in-law’s ring
Partner ignores dream ring request, NTA for being upset
Partner agreed on ring, did opposite. NTA.
NTA. Forcing a ring style on someone is narcissistic and yikes
Fiancé ignores ring preferences, calls partner ungrateful. NTA.
Fiancé ignores ring preferences, red flag for wedding planning
Marriage warning: NTA, but don’t marry someone who doesn’t appreciate you
Fiancé calls her ungrateful for not liking the ring
Jeweler commenter supports using family discount and working with partner
Respect matters more than the ring ✨
Fiancé ignores agreement for traditional ring, red flag?
Questioning peer pressure and red flags in engagement ring debacle
Don’t settle for less Stand up for your dream ring
Goldsmith fiancé receives nightmare ring, called ungrateful by partner. NTA.
Sarcastic comment about gender roles and a serious talk.
Fiancé disregards agreement on dream ring. NTA reconsiders proposal
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/8b56ba88-81e2-4878-86a2-664b885d5cea.png)
Ex’s flashy ring made me sick, current partner listened to me ❤️
Fiancé ignores partner’s wishes, spends too much on engagement ring
Fiancé ignores her input on dream ring, calls her ungrateful
Sibling-made rings make it special. NTA for wanting that.
Fiancée’s ethical beliefs and past trauma ignored in dream ring.
Partner ignored input, sulking now. Kudos for speaking up!
NTA! Placeholder ring proposal, fun to pick out rings together
Fiancé ignores ring preference, NTA stands up for herself
Fiancé ignores wishes for engagement ring, calls partner ungrateful.
Fiancé ignored dream ring request despite OP’s job expertise
Empowering response to a fiancée’s nightmare ring experience
Breaking tradition: NTA for not getting a proposal ring
Fiancé disregards partner’s profession and preferences for traditional gender roles
Wearing a ring you don’t like can impact your professional image
Think twice before marrying someone who doesn’t respect your wishes
Red flag alert! Partner’s lack of respect for career
Expert butcher wants specific beef, partner ignores and mocks preference. NTA.
Reflect on your future with someone who ignores your feelings.
Think twice before marrying someone who disregards your feelings
Expertise and communication win! NTA
Tradition-loving man saves himself for marriage, lucky fiancee or not?
Supportive comment encourages communication and respect in relationship ❤
Money and resentment are bigger problems than the ring. NTA
Engagement ring dilemma, NTA comment suggests rocky relationship ahead
Partner’s disregard for fiancée’s ring preferences raises red flags
Fiancé ignores her, fulfills ‘male duties’, and gets wrong ring
Designing the ring together would have been romantic. NTA
Normalize ringless proposals and going to jeweler together.
Red flags raised after manipulative proposal
Partner disregards OP’s ring preferences, red flag for future decisions.
Partner disregarded her opinions on engagement ring. NTA.
Silversmith defends remaking engagement ring, promotes own work
Partner’s unilateral decision on engagement ring raises red flags
Partner’s sudden change of heart about ring choice raises concerns.
Agreed on terms, he broke them, tradition is obsolete. NTA
Fiancé’s proposal fail: NTA commenter doubts his good faith
Is ‘man tradition’ worth marrying someone who disregards your feelings?
Red flag alert! Partner’s attitude towards ring raises concerns
Engaged woman stands up for herself in dream ring dispute
Proposing without a ring or with a placeholder ring is better
Partnering with someone who disregards your feelings? Yikes!
Fiancé ignores ring preferences, calls her ungrateful. NTA.
Communicating preferences is key to a perfect engagement ring
Setting boundaries in relationships is important. NTA for enforcing them.
Reconsider the marriage: financial values and respect are important
Fiancé ignores desires and calls her ungrateful.
Fiancée’s nightmare ring reveals fundamental lack of respect. NTA.
NTA, but rethink marriage. ‘Learn to like it’? Unacceptable.
Clear communication ignored by fiancé, NTA for standing firm
