Family Torn Apart Over Twin’s Ashes: Who Gets to Keep Them?

Imagine having to decide who gets to keep the ashes of a loved one. That’s the heart-wrenching dilemma faced by a family with three kids: Jane, the eldest, and Castor and Pollux, twins. Castor passed away unexpectedly five years ago, and his urn has been a fixture in the family home ever since. But when Pollux moved out, he asked to take his twin’s ashes with him, setting off an emotional and bitter feud between the siblings.

The Family’s Tragic Loss

The Urn’s Place in the Home

Pollux’s Heartfelt Request

The Inseparable Twins

A Childhood Promise

Jane’s Shocking Discovery

The Truth Comes Out ️

Jane’s Explosive Reaction

The Aftermath ️

Family’s Opinion

What Castor Would Have Wanted?

A Family Divided: Who Deserves the Ashes?

This tragic story has left a family divided, as Jane and Pollux argue over who should keep Castor’s ashes. While Pollux was granted his wish to take his twin’s ashes when he moved out, Jane feels it’s unfair and symbolic of her being left out. The family is torn, with some suggesting the urn should return home to restore peace. But what would Castor have wanted? Even Jane agrees he’d likely want to be with his brother, but coldly claims, “he’s too dead to care.” As emotions run high, the family must navigate this painful conflict. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…

NTA but Jane needs counseling to deal with unresolved trauma.

Commenter suggests therapy for daughter struggling with twin’s ashes. ‍ ‍

Daughter left out of twin’s ashes decision. NTA but insensitive.

NTA but Jane’s hurt is understandable. Lack of communication worsened it.

Splitting the ashes could be a good solution. NAH.

Grief causes people to lash out and act in ways they normally wouldn’t

Symbolic ashes causing family divide. NTA, find real issue.

Suggesting a fair solution to keep the family together

NAH feels excluded from family decision about deceased brother’s ashes

Suggestion for family discussion and splitting ashes.

Commenter questions family’s strange behavior and shares suspicions.

OP’s dismissive attitude towards daughter’s feelings is concerning

Suggests splitting ashes or turning them into a necklace

ESH. Jane’s outburst was wrong, but OP should have consulted the whole family before moving the ashes. A compromise could have been achieved.

A reminder to validate all forms of grief. YTA, but therapy helps.

Suggests sharing ashes through jewelry to ease daughter’s grief

A compassionate suggestion for keeping a memory alive

Suggesting a thoughtful solution for unresolved grief

Sibling’s ashes cause family feud. YTA for not compromising.

Sibling’s ashes cause family feud. ESH, but Jane’s right.

Siblings’ different ways of grieving can lead to misunderstandings

Suggests splitting ashes, empathizes with grief, NAH.

Compassionate suggestion for sharing ashes with grieving daughter

Sibling’s perspective on moving ashes causes family dispute

Commenter points out symbolic names chosen for aliases, recommends therapy.

Splitting ashes could bring peace to a grieving family

NTA vs NAH: Jane’s behavior understandable but unacceptable

ESH family torn apart over twin’s ashes, daughter’s grief dismissed

Suggestion to split ashes or give token amount, but proceed with level-headed discussion due to Jane’s reaction. NAH.

Dividing ashes into thirds could keep Castor’s memory alive

Protecting your son from emotionally violent daughter during grief

NAH. Son keeps twin’s ashes, but daughter deserves empathy too.

Daughter excluded from deceased twin’s ashes, YTA and hypocritical.

Sibling shares perspective on dividing ashes, emphasizes need for communication.

Heartbreaking dilemma over twin’s ashes brings family together.

Heartbreaking situation with no clear solution

Parent criticized for not getting help for daughter’s mental health.

Empathetic comment suggests family communication and consideration for all siblings.

Suggesting an urn necklace for the sister’s grief

Suggests dividing ashes as a solution, acknowledges it may not work

Divide the ashes equally. YTA for prioritizing one child’s feelings.

Suggesting a compromise for ashes dispute

Both siblings need closure and a compromise.

Suggesting a compromise for a grieving mother’s behavior

Daughter’s inappropriate behavior causes family conflict over twin’s ashes

Commenter jokes about cursed name choice, no replies.

Heartbreaking comment on the pain of losing a twin.

Compromise suggested for sharing twin’s ashes between siblings.

Peaceful resolution in the ashes dispute

Heartbreaking situation as family struggles over twin’s ashes

Parental favoritism causes family rift over twin’s ashes

Suggests compromise for twin’s ashes, empathizes with difficult situation.

Heartwarming suggestion for keeping a loved one close

Unique perspective on twin’s ashes sparks thoughtful solution

Understanding grief and change: NTA for keeping the urn.