In a world where science and family planning have become intertwined, a woman finds herself in a unique predicament. Her gay brother and his husband are planning to have a child through surrogacy and have asked her to donate one of her frozen eggs to ensure a biological connection to the baby. However, she’s not so keen on the idea. While she’s donated eggs before, this request hits a little too close to home. Let’s dive into her story and see what’s stirring up this family feud. ️
The Family Plan

The Biological Connection Request

The Egg Donor’s Past

The Biological Offsprings

Frozen Assets ❄️

The Dilemma

The Family Tree Conundrum

The Brothers’ Reaction

The Emotional Struggle

The Final Decision

The Emotional Standoff

The Egg-citing Dilemma: A Family’s Battle Over Biology and Boundaries
In an unexpected twist of modern family planning, a woman finds herself at odds with her brother and his husband. They’ve requested one of her frozen eggs for their future child, hoping to maintain a biological connection. However, she’s not comfortable with the idea of her brother raising her biological child while she plays the role of ‘just the aunt.’ Despite accusations of selfishness, she stands her ground, citing emotional discomfort over financial considerations. It’s a complex issue that has stirred up quite the debate. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this egg-ceptional situation…
NAH– Sister’s choice to not give eggs to brother’s family

Sibling feud over egg donation: boundaries crossed, emotions run high

NTA. Valid concerns, your body, your call.

NAH. Emotional struggle over biological connection. Consider family therapy for resolution.

NTA: Family feud over frozen eggs sparks rightful outrage

NTA. Genetics matter, but family isn’t entitled to reproductive services

NTA for saying no, but their anger is unjustified.

NTA. Family feud over frozen eggs. Can brother find them?

Sister declines brother’s request for eggs. NTA, sitcom vibes

Men’s reproductive rights? It’s a whole *thing*! NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/fa091ffa-d2b2-4ec0-996d-213827c22e5c.png)
NTA. Brother and spouse out of line. You aren’t selfish.

NTA. Brother’s unrealistic expectations make him an a**hole. Unusual birth arrangement.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/d2595c1c-9b68-46c6-88d0-45deeeac5d7b.png)
Stand your ground! Your body, your choice.

Donated eggs, but not to family. They’re the a**holes.

Sibling dilemma: To donate or not to donate?

NTA – Declining brother’s request for biological connection. Adoption is alternative

Commenter jokes about having three hands, sparking a funny thread

Kinship adoption creates unique family dynamics and strong bonds

NTA, but I don’t get it. No need for sister-cousin jokes

NAH. Emotional dilemma: family vs. personal autonomy. Seek therapist’s guidance

Declining request for biological connection to future child to avoid pain
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/92b5c1f5-18d0-47ff-be0a-06e7ff9dbf7c.png)
NTA: Emotional stability in donor, narcissistic to want biological child.

Donating eggs vs raising biological children: Awkward truths and boundaries.
