Imagine having a cherished, secret recipe, a bond between you and a loved one, now passed away. Now, imagine your sibling demanding that recipe, despite knowing it’s a special secret. What would you do? Meet our friend, who found himself in this exact situation. His stepmother, Abby, had shared a unique recipe with him, a secret between just the two of them. But when his half-brother, Greg, demanded the recipe for Thanksgiving, our friend found himself in a sticky situation.
A Second Mom and a Shared Secret ❤️
A Sibling Rivalry and a Special Recipe
A Promise Kept Secret
A Thanksgiving Demand
A Recipe Ruse
A Thanksgiving Gone Awry
A Revelation and a Fallout ️
A Promise Remembered
A Recipe for Disaster or a Promise Kept?
In a tale filled with family drama, secret recipes, and a Thanksgiving that no one will forget, our friend finds himself in a moral quandary. He had a special bond with his stepmother, Abby, encapsulated in a secret recipe. But when his half-brother, Greg, demanded the recipe for his wife to cook at Thanksgiving, he was torn. He ended up giving a similar, but not the same, recipe. The outcome? A Thanksgiving dinner filled with confusion, accusations, and hurt feelings. But was he wrong to protect a promise, or should he have shared the secret? Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…
RELATED STORIES
NTA. “No” means no, and he kept badgering you about it after you told him just that.
NTA. Giving in to your brother’s demand was a mistake
NTA. Recipe refusal sparks family feud. Power play by Greg?
“ESH” for family feud over secret recipe, with a backfired peace offering.
NTA…it’s your memory of Abby, not his. Secret recipe drama.
NTA. Brother’s a bully. You tried to defend your stepmother’s memory.
ESH for not giving the recipe, but providing a fake one
A hilarious NTA comment and some baking inquiries
NTA. Secret recipes are like treasure chests!
NTA! Keep the secret recipe a**hole! They owe you!
“YTA. You misled everyone with a secret recipe. “
Greg is a real piece of work, but you’re better off without him. ♀️
Family feud over secret recipe: boundaries crossed, resentment builds. ♂️
NTA for not giving up special recipe, but giving similar was a dick move. Greg should have respected your shared bond.
Curiosity piqued: What secret recipe are they all after?
Family secrets and misunderstandings cause recipe feud. ♂️
Sharing the secret recipe: NTA, but was it worth it?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/87b901a3-ca2b-4351-85c1-1a9bd428a20a.png)
ESH with a Soft Y to you. You shouldn’t have lied and by doing so you hurt an innocent party (Jen) but this also lies on your brother and father. The only truly innocent party here (from your post, unless she was badgering you too) is Jen.
Curious commenter wants to know the secret egg dish recipe!
NTA. Bullies got what they deserved.
A fiery feud over a secret recipe: NTA!
Missing info sparks speculation and confusion in recipe feud
Recipe feud turns messy: ESH slips wrong recipe, then confesses
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/1a3a7597-8e50-4d83-ab87-4e8aec51818f.png)
Family recipe feud: NTA, but tough situation with personal meaning.
Family recipe drama: Sacred secrets and a soft YTA
Setting boundaries with a secret recipe
Family feud over secret recipe turns into recipe for disaster.
NTA, but brother’s assholery hurt innocent wife. Blame not on you.
Sharing recipes can be rewarding, but some are meant to be kept secret ♂️
YTA didn’t see it coming? Family feud over secret recipe
Being nice to pushy people? You’re definitely not the a**hole!
Not the a**hole: The recipe feud unravels family secrets.
Debate over who’s at fault: NTA or ESH?
NTA: They wanted credit for a recipe they didn’t create
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/94aa0d7e-de7a-40ea-8696-c34b747c000e.png)
Sibling rivalry and betrayal: Who’s the real culprit?
A sitcom-worthy family feud over a secret recipe!
Giving a fake recipe ruined Thanksgiving for everyone. ESH.
ESH: Family feud over secret recipe leads to Christmas alone
Family feud over secret recipe: ESH for demanding special bond.
NTA, your half brother is an a**hole
Family feud over secret recipe: ESH deviated from agreement.
Family feud over secret recipe: Who’s the real a**hole?
NTA: Entitled family feud over co-created secret recipe. Drama unfolds.
A family feud over a secret recipe? Who’s to blame?
Setting Jen up for failure? That’s not nice! ESH
Family feud over secret recipe: ESH, but Greg’s the worst.
Sibling rivalry turns recipe dispute into a chaotic family feud
ESH: Recipe secrets, broken promises, and family feuds
Family feud over secret recipe: Who’s the real culprit? ️♂️
Recipe lies lead to betrayal and rejection. ESH in feud.
Sharing recipes: a generous act or a narrow perspective?
Family feud over secret recipe turns into a blame game
NTA: Family feud over secret recipe reveals favoritism and cruelty.
A promise broken and feelings hurt. Who’s to blame?
“Heartless” family feud over secret recipe! Who’s the culprit?
Don’t let peer pressure sway your decision!
Grammar lesson: Using ‘I’ vs ‘me’ in compound subjects/objects
ESH except for your SIL. Apologize and cook together next time!
Different taste, same recipe. Honesty is the best policy.
Recipe feud turns sour. ESH for false ingredients.
NTA: Stand your ground and keep your secret recipe safe!
Emotional boundaries matter. Let’s talk about f**k Greg.
NTA, Greg tried to steal your recipe and bully you.
