Egg-cellent Dilemma: Sister Demands Her Sibling’s Frozen Eggs

Imagine this: You’ve frozen your eggs in your mid-twenties, preparing for the future. You’re blessed with a baby naturally, but you still have those eggs stored for future children. Suddenly, your sister, who’s had a difficult pregnancy history, asks for your eggs. What would you do? This is the real-life predicament of one woman who’s now caught in a family feud over her frozen eggs. Let’s delve into her controversial story.

The Egg-storing Journey

A Natural Miracle!

Sister’s Struggles and New Hope

The Unexpected Request

An Instant Refusal, and a Counteroffer

The Price of an Egg

Family Fallout

The Bloodline Argument

The Blame Game Begins

Parents’ Plea and Guilt Tripping

The Egg-shaming Saga

The Egg Ownership Standoff

An Egg-ceptional Family Feud: Who’s Right, Who’s Wrong? ‍♀️

Caught in an egg-ceptionally tricky situation, a woman faces backlash for refusing to give her frozen eggs to her sister. After a difficult pregnancy history, her sister hoped to have a baby that’s related by blood. But our egg-owner stood her ground, even suggesting a hefty $5,000 price tag to dissuade her sister. With family members blaming her for her sister’s potential childlessness, the pressure is mounting. But she maintains, ‘These are my eggs. Even if they are not used, they are mine.’ Let’s see what the internet thinks of this egg-citing situation…

NTA, but expected a breakfast dispute instead of a serious issue

NTA, but adding a price tag made it more complicated

“NTA, be firm and honest. Don’t give in to pressure! “

NTA – Family pressures sister for frozen eggs, neglecting her existing family

ESH for putting a price on eggs and demanding reimbursement

Egg-cellent Dilemma: A yolk about expensive eggs and common sense

“NTA Why do people think that being blood related means being entitled to other people’s biological matter? It’s sickening, she’s not entitled to your eggs and she doesn’t *need* a blood related baby.”

NTA. Sister’s entitlement to OP’s eggs is staggering

Don’t give in! Stand your ground and protect your eggs!

Sibling demands frozen eggs. Uncomfortable boundary crossed. Complex emotions

NTA: Your eggs, your choice. She can explore other options

ESH. Uncomfortable with price, but sister should’ve respected boundaries.

ESH: Sister demands OP’s frozen eggs, blames her for not having a family. OP not obligated to give her body. Sister badmouths OP. Holy shitballs, the audacity!

Sibling demands frozen eggs, OP avoids honesty with price tag

Set boundaries. Just say no and end the conversation.

Offering to sell frozen eggs to entitled sister is messed up

Frozen eggs don’t guarantee a baby. NTA, educate your family!

NTA. Your eggs your choice. Family donor eggs or adoption?

User expresses frustration with Reddit and its CEO.

ESH: Family guilt, heartless sibling, and high price create tension

Engaging comment and replies about sister’s demand for frozen eggs

NTA. Personal decision. Your eggs, your choice.

A costly request: Would you give her the eggs then?

NTA: Immature sister won’t raise a mature child

NAH: Sibling demands frozen eggs, but price tag was a**holish.

Sibling dilemma: NAH for refusing, YTA for setting a price

NTA. Your eggs, your choice. Don’t let her dictate your future

Your eggs, your choice! Don’t do it unless you’re comfortable!

Don’t let her guilt trip you! Your eggs, your choice!

NTA: Your eggs, your choice. Be honest and set boundaries.

NTA. Adoption could be a loving alternative

Sister’s infertility dilemma: Why does she need sibling’s eggs?

Sibling rivalry and infertility: a messy situation for everyone

Sister demands sibling’s frozen eggs, but can’t produce her own

NTA: IVF process explained and egg-wanting lady’s cluelessness highlighted

NTA

You made a reasonable offer, she can’t guilt trip you

Confused about the situation and asking for more information

Egg-cellent Dilemma: Sister demands sibling’s frozen eggs

NTA. Your eggs, your choice. Don’t let her guilt trip you.

Engaging comment and reply: NTA. Having a niece-daughter and sharing a biological child?

NTA, but maybe research secondary infertility and pregnancy complications instead?

NTA. Your eggs, your decision. No freebies for entitled sister!

Engaging response to sibling’s demand for frozen eggs

NTA: Complicated situation, fair to ask for reimbursement, sibling overstepped.

NTA. The odds of success with so few eggs are miniscule

Infertile person shares concerns about giving away frozen eggs

NTA, confusing story. Hard time carrying, high cost, weird situation.

NTA, but freezing 10 eggs won’t guarantee successful pregnancies. ‍♀️