We’ve all had our fair share of awkward moments, but this one takes the cake! Imagine having friends over for dinner and trying to sell them something you got for free. That’s exactly what happened to one person, who now wonders if they were in the wrong. Let’s dive into this cringe-worthy story and see if we can help them out.
Dinner Party Gone Wrong
The Accidental Gift
Misunderstanding Strikes
Awkwardness Ensues
Disappointment and Goodbyes
Feeling Stupid and Rude
A Matter of Principle
Seeking Answers
The Verdict: Was it Wrong to Sell a Free Item?
So, our conflicted friend tried to sell an item they got for free to their friends, leading to an awkward dinner party moment. They feel rude and wonder if they should have just kept quiet. Their fiance doesn’t think they’re in the wrong, but that might be a biased opinion. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation and if our friend was out of line or not…
RELATED STORIES
Selling free item to friends? YTA and it’s a ripoff
Asserting the value of a free item: NTA wins.
User defends OP and calls out YTAs, declares NTA
Friend offers unwanted ‘deal’, deemed tactless and YTA
Choosing to sell instead of gifting to a friend? NTA!
Friend’s attempt to sell free item for $120 deemed a**hole move
Apology accepted? Fiance wanted to sell, but still awkward
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/043e052d-3f5f-440f-8d23-50f96f417cab.png)
Navigating the ethics of selling free items – YTA vs NTA
Friend is the a**hole for not being transparent about situation
Miscommunication leads to no a-hole here situation
Friend tries to sell free item, gets called out for it
Friend tries to sell free item, gets called out YTA
Friend tries to sell free item at dinner party
Friend tries to sell free item, gets called out as cheap
Generosity should not be taken advantage of.
Friend calls out OP for trying to profit off good friends
OP justified for wanting to sell item at a discount
Luck or loophole? Amazon lets customer keep $160 item
Friend tries to sell free item, commenter suggests alternative approach. NAH.
Awkward dinner party sales pitch, cultural differences at play
Friend offered free item for sale, not forcing friends to buy. NTA.
Friend tries to sell free item to friends, labeled YTA.
Tactless move at dinner party leads to light YTA judgment
Return the item for full refund, OP not the sharpest
Friend’s behavior exposed true colors, fiancé controlling. Awkward dinner ahead.
Friend tries to sell free item to friend, YTA verdict
Friend accused of being greedy landlord. YTA verdict given.
Split the deal, not the friendship. NTA
Friendship vs. Profit: Etiquette of Sharing Deals
OP is a small YTA for trying to sell unwanted item.
Friend reselling free item to friend, not steep enough discount.
Friend wants to sell free item to friend. YTA according to commenter.
Friend tries to sell free item, gets called out for it
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/36888f87-725f-4b6e-bdf9-513a3035c9cc.png)
Friend wants free item, NTA if sell for $75-85
Being considerate of wording can avoid misunderstandings and hurt feelings
Generosity over profit: commenter gives away appliances to friends.
Soliciting sale of free item to friends unprompted is rude AF
Polite suggestion on how to handle selling free item
Selling a free item? NTA, make some money back
Friend calls out freeloading behavior in blunt comment.
Politely declining free item shouldn’t cause drama
Selling to friends is okay, but not at dinner parties
Friend tries to sell free item, YTA for profiting off it
Honesty isn’t always the best policy, even with friends
Friend tries to sell free item, commenter says NTA with shock
Compromise suggested for selling free item dilemma
Grateful for a discount, not entitled to a freebie
You have the right to sell it, NTA
Generous friend offers discount, NTA for giving first dibs
Don’t let friends guilt you into giving away freebies
Friendship or money? YTA gets called out for selling item.
Friend’s constant hustling led to a cut-off. YTA.
NTA, it’s yours. Maybe a white lie would’ve been better ♂️
Friend tries to sell free item: NTA or YTA? Debate.
Winning a raffle and wanting to sell the prize. NTA.
Don’t mix family, friends, and money. Keep prices private.
Is it an A H move to sell a free item to a friend?
True friends don’t charge each other, split the cost instead
Selling a free item to a friend is tacky, ESH.
Friend tries to sell free item, asks for too much
Returning for refund and charging 50% seems fair. ESH.
Selling a free item to a friend? NAH, but split the cost.
Friend tries to sell free item, YTA for profiting.
Friend tries to sell free item, but gifting to friend feels great
Don’t be the a**hole, honesty is the best policy
Trying to profit off friends? YTA according to commenters
Be honest about intentions to avoid being labeled YTA ♂️
Friend tries to sell free item, commenter calls out mooch
Friend feels undervalued after OP tries to profit. YTA
Disclosing a free item and trying to sell it? YTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/f389b461-f36b-482a-9507-012e054e4a6a.png)
Selling free item to a friend? YTA, but at least self-aware
Friend tries to sell free item. Commenter says YTA.
Friend tries to profit off free item, deemed YTA by commenters
Friendship faux pas, YTA. Give the item away next time.
Friend tries to sell free item to friends, YTA confirmed
Friend tries to sell free item and gets called out YTA
Friend tries to sell free item to friends, YTA verdict.
