Dad’s Dilemma: To Reveal or Not to Reveal the Secret of Their Daughter’s Birth

In a world where love and family are paramount, a father’s love is put to the test. This dad is facing a moral dilemma that could potentially shake the very foundation of his family. He’s torn between keeping a pact with his wife and protecting his daughter’s feelings. His wife, unable to conceive, had agreed to use an egg donor to start their family. But when she expresses dissatisfaction with the outcome and wants a ‘better’ donor for the next child, the dad is left with a tough choice. Should he break their agreement and tell their daughter about her origins? Dive into this emotionally charged rollercoaster of a story.

A Dream Shattered, A New Path Chosen

The Quest for the Perfect Egg

A Miracle Unfolds

A Dream Realized, But a Storm Brews ️ ️

A Mother’s Unexpected Revelation

A Desire for a ‘Better’ Donor ‍♀️

A Father’s Defiance

An Emotional Standoff

A Lingering Doubt

A Family’s Secret, A Father’s Dilemma: The Heartrending Story of Love and Choices

In a tale that tugs at the heartstrings, a father is torn between keeping a pact with his wife and protecting his daughter’s feelings. After discovering his wife’s infertility, they opted for an egg donor. But when his wife expresses dissatisfaction with their daughter and desires a ‘better’ donor for the next child, the father is left questioning. Should he break their agreement and reveal their daughter’s origins? As the tension escalates, the family finds itself on the precipice of a life-altering decision. Let’s delve into the internet’s take on this emotionally charged situation.

NTA – Wife’s unrealistic expectations for child’s personality.

Daughter’s need for medical info vs. parents’ secret dilemma.

NTA. Prioritize her mental health before considering having more children.

“Her idea of children is warped.” Therapy needed for wife.

ESH – Daughter deserves to know. Genetic test will expose lie.

Insightful comment on egg donation insecurities. Therapy recommendation appreciated.

ESH: The truth hurts, but she deserves to know.

Medical reasons aside, when should parents reveal donor conception?

“NTA, favoritism and therapy before having another child “

NTA: Wife’s shallow attitude towards daughter’s genetics is concerning

Therapy first! YWBTA if you get another child.

NTA, wife needs therapy not more kids. ‍♂️

Supportive advice: Help your wife through therapy and understanding ❤️

ESH: Wife doesn’t love child, you lied to daughter for life

ESH. Revealing the truth is important for their well-being.

NTA for not revealing donor secret; wife needs to process infertility.

Curious about the consequences of revealing a secret?

NTA. Wife needs therapy before considering another child.

NTA. Wife needs to learn child is their own individual

ESH: Breach of trust, therapy concerns, and dysfunctional parenting.

Tough decision. Seek therapy, explain medical issues, NTA. Educate yourself!

ESH: Hiding birth secret, unrealistic expectations, and unequal treatment.

Wrong sub, try r/relationshipadvice for better advice!

ESH. Using an ideal to judge actual children never ends well

NTA, prioritize therapy and hold off on having more kids.

NTA, supportive dad for a kid with a secret birth

NTA. Wife’s unrealistic expectations about kids’ resemblance. Kids should know.

NTA: Narcissistic parent’s attitude raises questions about their parenting skills.

“ESH – Daughter deserves to know the truth for medical reasons “

NTA. Encourage her to seek therapy for unresolved issues and PPD.

NTA: Wife’s disappointment in designer baby could lead to divorce

Hiding the truth? Your daughter will find out eventually

Reddit isn’t ready for this mind-blowing secret revelation!

Engaging caption for the comment and its replies.

“Your wife’s obsession with appearances is concerning. Seek therapy. NTA!”

NTA. Daughter deserves to know. Secrets can’t be hidden forever.

Worried about wife’s desire for new egg donor, but be gentle with sensitive subjects. NTA for getting upset, but threatening won’t solve anything.

ESH: Time to come clean and seek therapy for wife.

Discovering the truth: A DNA test reveals a shocking secret.

YTA for hiding your children’s biological origins. ESH for agreeing.

Parents struggling to bond with child; seek professional help. ‍ ‍

Planning on lying to your kids forever? DNA test? ESH

Revealing the truth about biological parentage: a mind-blowing revelation!

Don’t keep the secret, therapy needed. NTA.

‍ ‍ NTA: Wife’s behavior is outrageous! Therapy needed, not another child.

No more kids! Your wife isn’t fit to be a mom. NTA

Lucky wife! Dad’s dilemma: to reveal or not reveal secret.

NTA. Wife’s awful behavior puts daughter at risk. Babies aren’t customizable.

Unpredictable children: NTA, even biological kids surprise us!

Therapy needed! Wife’s delusion affecting child. NTA for seeking help.

NTA: Wife’s warped view on children and lack of empathy.

ESH. Wife lied, husband agreed. Trauma for child. Seek therapy. No more kids.

Revealing the truth: medical history, therapy, and unrealistic expectations.

Wait for the right time to reveal the truth. ‍ ‍

NTA. Wife’s reaction to daughter’s appearance is unreasonable and harmful.

NTA: Wife’s narcissism threatens marriage & daughter’s well-being. Seek therapy.

NTA. Therapy needed before more kids. No Build-A-Bears here!

Revealing the truth about conception: a necessary responsibility.

NTA for going back on agreement, but TA for lying.

Therapy: The key to unravel the secrets and heal relationships.