Picture this: your daughter moves back home from college and asks if her high-school boyfriend can move in too. You agree, but weeks later, they break up and your daughter wants him out. What would you do? One dad found himself in this exact situation and now he’s torn between his daughter’s feelings and his own sense of responsibility. Let’s dive into the story and see how it all unfolds.
The Sticky Situation Begins ️
The Ex-Boyfriend’s Background
Ex-Boyfriend’s Good Behavior
A Helpful House Guest ✂️
The Big Breakup
Too Much Time Together? ⏰
Daughter’s Heartfelt Plea
Ex-Boyfriend’s Desperate Request
The Compromise: Pool House ♂️
Wife’s Fury Unleashed
Dad’s Responsibility
Wife’s Argument
Dad’s Viewpoint
The Ex-Boyfriend’s Father
Feeling Responsible ♂️
Dad Torn Between Daughter and Ex-Boyfriend
This dad is caught in a whirlwind of emotions as his daughter demands her ex-boyfriend be kicked out of the house, while the ex pleads for a place to stay. The dad tries to find a middle ground by allowing the ex to stay in the pool house, but his wife is furious, claiming he’s taking the ex’s side over their daughter’s. With his daughter heartbroken and his sense of responsibility pulling him in the opposite direction, this dad is left wondering if he’s made the right choice. Let’s see what people think of this complicated situation…
RELATED STORIES
NTA. A heartwarming story of compassion and responsibility
Insightful advice for dad dealing with daughter’s ex-boyfriend staying
Fair compromise reached in tough situation with daughter’s ex-boyfriend
Asking daughter the reason for fight is crucial
Responsible dad chooses safety over daughter’s comfort
Admirable decision to prioritize well-being of daughter’s ex-boyfriend. NTA.
NTA. The daughter and wife begged for him to stay. ♂️
Curious about the reason for the breakup?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/b9e6d153-3fec-4c9d-8a1a-9c38fa8372e1.png)
Prioritizing daughter’s safety in breakups
Teaching daughter a lesson in love and commitment
Curious about the ex-boyfriend’s misdeeds? Let’s find out!
Compassionate NTA struggles with homeless friend, offers pool house solution
NTA for helping him, but daughter’s safety is top priority
Curious about the reason behind the fight?
Teenager doesn’t want to live with ex, responsible dad saves day
Curious about the breakup? OP asks for more INFO
The reason for the breakup is crucial
NAH, daughter’s ex staying in pool house, family needs to talk
Heartbreak is tough, but daughter’s ex staying is reasonable. NAH
Why they broke up matters. Share your thoughts!
Being the mature one pays off in the long run
Compromise and understanding: NTA for giving ex-boyfriend a place
User questions decision to let daughter’s ex-boyfriend stay. Replies clarify.
Compassionate dad gets praise for helping daughter’s ex-boyfriend ❤
NTA: Know why daughter doesn’t want to see ex
Pool house as a solution during breakups. NTA.
NTA. Good job finding a solution to a tough situation.
Trying to be a good person, but living with someone has consequences
Supportive comment tells dad to stand his ground with daughter’s ex.
Curious about the cause of their breakup
Curious about ex-boyfriend’s treatment of daughter?
NAH suggests talking to ex-boyfriend to minimize presence
Communication breakdown? Commenter questions decision-making process in family dilemma.
Compassionate dad shelters daughter’s ex. NTA.
Daughter’s selfishness leads to ex-boyfriend staying. NTA.
Supportive comment, don’t budge, NTA.
Compliment received! Positive vibes in the comment section ✨
Supportive comment receives no replies, but deserves an upvote
Compassionate dad lets daughter’s ex stay during pandemic
Prioritizing safety over daughter’s discomfort makes OP NTA
NAH verdict, but communication is key for ex-boyfriend living situation
Daughter’s ex-boyfriend has tenant rights, NTA for not kicking out
Plan for his departure and don’t assume relationship will recover
NTA handled it well, kudos for taking him in
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/66cab72b-4310-4b00-a64a-0ac26f51c654.png)
Internet commenter sarcastically suggests joining Boy Scouts for a son.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://diplycom5cc47.zapwp.com/q:i/r:0/wp:1/w:1/u:https://static.diply.com/9a6140b7-4e39-4f78-8f99-c8d5f6a676fd.png)
Daughter’s ex-boyfriend overstaying: NTA, she needs to understand ♂️
Supportive comment defends dad’s decision to let ex-boyfriend stay
Support for dad taking in daughter’s ex-boyfriend
Compassionate commenter defends daughter’s ex-boyfriend.
Not the a**hole, but what’s the backstory?
Legality of eviction discussed; tricky laws in Michigan explained
Supportive comment defends dad’s decision, throws shade at wife
Compassionate dad receives support for not kicking out daughter’s ex-boyfriend
Being honorable pays off!
