Dad Buys Son a Car, But Not Daughter: Fair Game or Foul Play?

Picture this: a dad, two kids, and a brand new Hyundai. Sounds like a happy family portrait, right? Well, not quite. ‍♂️ Our tale stars a well-off father, his football star son, and his academically inclined daughter. The twist? Dad buys a car for the son, but the daughter… well, she gets a different kind of deal.

Meet the Family ‍ ‍

The Golden Boy’s Perks

The Daughter’s Dilemma

The Dad’s Decision ‍♂️

The Reasoning Behind the Ruling

The Daughter’s Defense ‍♀️

A Potential Compromise?

The Dad’s Defense ️

A New Deal on the Table

A Family Feud Fuelled by Four Wheels

In the end, it’s a tale of two siblings, a father’s controversial decision, and a Hyundai. The son, a football star, gets a car and extra cash. The daughter, an academic, gets her education funded but no car or extra spending money. The father’s reasoning? The son’s grueling football schedule leaves no time for a job, while the daughter, he believes, could work part-time if she wants more. The daughter cries foul, accusing dad of favoritism. The dad, however, offers a compromise: a car and extra cash if she hits a 3.5 GPA in her freshman year. So, is this dad playing fair or playing favorites? Let’s see what the internet has to say…

YTA for favoring son over daughter in car purchase.

“YTA. You favor your son because he’s an athlete. Give your daughter her own metrics for support.”

Daughter undervalued, siblings’ achievements compared. Unfair treatment.

NTA, but be careful how you talk about your daughter.

Inquiring about daughter’s extracurriculars and questioning football’s importance

“YTA. Did you set clear goals for your daughter? “

YTA for favoring son over un-athletic daughter. Possible depression?

YTA – Stereotypical American football dad berates daughter. Therapy needed

YTA for favoring son over daughter.

“YTA! Present your reasonings better – give her a benchmark.”

Playing favorites: YTA for not buying daughter a car.

Dad’s favoritism sparks backlash: YTA for playing favorites!

Neglected daughter’s interests questioned. Is dad playing favorites?

YTA for favoring your son over your daughter.

Commenter feels YTA for treating daughter differently, lacking respect.

Mixed opinions on favoritism towards son in car purchase.

Dad’s unequal treatment sparks fiery debate. Who’s the real a**hole?

OP’s daughter’s clubs are not irrelevant. ️‍♀️ Share all the info!

Are you favoring your son over your daughter? Be honest.

Curious about dad’s offer: car vs college, what was her response?

“You clearly hero worship your son while branding your daughter a spoilt brat.”

NTA: Paying tuition is equivalent to buying a new car.

“YTA. Unfair treatment. Each kid should be treated equally. “

“YTA for showing favoritism. Your son lucked out, daughter didn’t. “

Heartbreaking loss for daughter, how does she cope?

Equal spending, different priorities. Daughter wants a car, dad disagrees.

“YTA. Favouritism hurts. Don’t devalue your children’s achievements. “

Unfair car treatment: YTA. Connect with your daughter more.

YTA for favoring son’s football over daughter’s interests.

NTA- Open communication about expectations and responsibilities can prevent misunderstandings.

YTA in the most horrific way. Your children deserve equal treatment financially.

Dad buys son a car, not daughter. NTA, but probably an a**hole.

NTA: Unfair comparison, but logical reasoning behind not getting daughter car.

NTA – Fair to pay equally for college expenses, not car.

Daughter’s talent: Love her same as son? Grades unchanged.

YTA for favoring son over daughter. Not everyone excels in sports.

Merit-based aid is tough. Scholarships often require financial need. YTA.

Dad buys son a car, but not daughter: YTA, unfair!

Engaging comment: NTA. Show your daughter the numbers and dispel favoritism.

Parent’s favoritism sparks resentment: YTA for punishing daughter’s intelligence

YTA – Unfair treatment of children sparks heated debate.

Son saves dad money with scholarship. Fair to buy him car?

INFO: How does your spouse feel? Their mother is dead.

YTA for favoring son with a brand new car.

Parenting strategy criticized for favoring one child over the other

YTA: Unequal treatment of kids with car purchase sparks controversy.

Fairness in expenses: football equipment, gas, and high school costs.

Unpopular opinion: NTA. Son works, daughter costs money. Fair?

NTA. Full ride to uni? That’s awesome!

Son gets car, daughter doesn’t: is it fair or foul?

NTA. Completely reasonable.

Unfair favoritism? Dad buys son a car, not daughter. YTA.

YTA for favoring son over daughter. Toxic situation and unfair.

YTA for undervaluing your daughter and favoring your son.

Equal treatment or favoritism?

NTA: Daughter’s lack of effort, no car entitlement.

Hard work deserves equal rewards! NTA

Daughter’s laziness or hidden disability? Dad’s favoritism questioned.

Rewarding son for hard work, daughter shouldn’t expect equal treatment.

Sibling rivalry over unequal financial support for education.

Commenter calls out parent for favoritism, predicts negative impact on daughter’s self-esteem.

NTA whatsoever! Kudos to you for teaching work ethic.

“YTA. Treat each kid fairly by paying equal amounts for college.”

Sibling rivalry settled with equal financial support for different needs

“YTA how is she spoiled if you’re not treating her the same and just paying the same amount for her college as your son? Shit don’t make no sense. I think you’re downplaying her achievements bc clearly she did well enough that she got into your sons school without a football scholarship. Also what are you doing for her? Basically nothing except paying for her college” – A fiery debate over unequal treatment

“YTA. If you can’t afford both, teach them negotiation skills! “

NTA. Daughter’s illogical argument sparks relatable sibling rivalry.

NTA: Son’s scholarships, daughter’s upset. Fair game or foul play?