A small business owner shares their experience with an employee who has been with the company for three years. Throughout this time, the employee’s personal life has been in constant turmoil, leading to frequent requests for time off and apologies for not showing up to work. The business owner has tried to be understanding, but the employee’s continuous threats to quit have pushed them to their limit. Finally, after another emotional outburst, the owner decides to fire the employee. Did they make the right decision?
New Employee’s Personal Upheaval ️

Frequent Leave Requests

Emotional Confrontations

Threats to Quit

Maternity Leave and More Issues

Work Blamed for Personal Problems

Final Straw

Firing the Employee

Aware of Mental Health Issues

Feeling Like a Mother

Summary: A Tough Decision for a Business Owner
The small business owner has been dealing with an employee whose personal life has been in constant turmoil, leading to frequent leave requests and threats to quit. After three years, the owner has had enough and decides to fire the employee after another emotional outburst. They wonder if they made the right decision, considering the employee’s mental health issues. What do you think? Share your thoughts and reactions below.
Employee’s constant absences and snapping at boss led to termination.

Employer not at fault for firing employee with emotional manipulation

Firing employee who threatened to quit and funded her for 7 months. NTA

Boss fires employee after constant threats to quit. NTA.

Gendered language sparks cringe-worthy replies

Firing a toxic employee: NTA morally, legal implications unclear

Employee fired after constant threats to quit. NTA wins.

Firing a bad employee with personal issues, but letting them take advantage of you, makes you ESH. Other employees suffer and it’s poor leadership.

Using ‘female’ to refer to a person can be cringeworthy

Commenter jokes about employee’s work ethic, gets agreement.

Maturity at work vs personal life, NTA wins.

Employee’s absence leads to justified criticism and self-awareness.

Enthusiastic job seeker praises employer’s decision, lands job offer

Employee’s behavior justified boss’s decision

Employee receiving pay in lieu of notice

Productivity over toxicity, NTA for firing unproductive employee
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/2fef3a7e-34c8-4e5f-a457-d4bf28000432.png)
Fired employee took advantage of employer’s generosity. Hopeful lesson learned.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/5385dbc0-e7da-4efa-bd49-a8f926c70e4c.png)
NTA. Firing an employee who constantly threatens to quit can improve morale

Employee taking advantage of employer, NTA for firing.

Commiserating over difficult coworkers – NTA prevails
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/fc444750-d185-41b8-995e-277a05ba077b.png)
Employee gets fired after threatening to quit, NTA.

Small business owner faces potential unemployment insurance claims due to lack of written documentation.

Employee threatened to quit, boss granted wish. NTA

Setting boundaries early on can prevent future issues.

Generous severance package earns NTA judgement

Legal consequences for firing employee due to pregnancy complications

Sometimes relationships don’t work, even in the workplace. NTA

Be prepared for unemployment claim, keep detailed records

Job opening: Boss fires employee, gets complimented by applicant.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/8559e05d-1e17-4327-bb25-bdbd85ac3ada.png)
Managing emotions at work: NTA fires overly emotional employee

Frustration with unproductive coworker causing business harm. NTA

Commenter agrees with decision to fire employee.

Commenter criticizes employer’s decision-making and offers blunt advice.

Small business owner shares experience of letting go toxic employee

NTA. Boss values business over employee’s mental health

Frequent absenteeism can be a huge drain on morale and finances

Asserting ownership rights, commenter supports firing bad employee. NTA

Employer praised for standing up to entitled employee.

Lesson learned: Set clear policies and stick to them

Supportive boss deals with ungrateful employee

NTA for firing manipulative employee. Advice: seek therapy for yourself.

Documenting everything can save you from lawsuits.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/2c5db87e-5c6f-4a80-8e6f-d94fd9699dbb.png)
Commenter shares NTA opinion, gets called out for word choice

Employee demands more after 7 months paid leave? NTA

Commenter calls out favoritism and deems OP the a**hole

Employee’s behavior finally addressed, fair treatment for all

Boss fires employee after 7 months off with pay. NTA.

Employee constantly threatening to quit? NTA for firing her

Employee’s constant absence causes resentment among coworkers. NTA.

Firing an employee for health reasons – NTA but handle with care

NTA boss goes above and beyond for employee, but enough is enough.

Don’t let your kindness be mistaken for weakness . Stand up for yourself and know your rights .

Firing an employee after constant threats to quit – NTA

Employee deserved to be fired. NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/a1dce74c-397f-48f4-bd2b-8e2e947f4e7c.png)
No charity here, NTA. First tantrum should have been the last

Employee’s unprofessional behavior leads to justified termination

Putting yourself first is hard, but necessary for a business

Empathetic firing decision made for the benefit of the business

Generous employer receives praise for firing entitled employee.

Employee takes advantage of leave, NTA for firing.

Protect yourself! Document everything in case of wrongful termination claim

Maternity leave envy

Employee’s behavior caused unfairness to others. NTA for firing.

Balancing empathy and business is tough, but NTA here

Tough love or bad management? Engage in the debate
