We all know that one person who loves to pull pranks, but sometimes they can take it too far. Meet Rob, the self-proclaimed prankster who loves to mess with everyone, including his own family. His pranks have caused a rift between him and his brother, who’s had enough of the antics. When Rob’s 30th birthday rolls around, he asks his sister-in-law, Halle, to make him a fancy cake. Little did they know, this would lead to a birthday cake disaster and a family feud.
Meet Rob, the Prankster

Not-So-Funny Pranks

Family of Jokesters

Targeting Halle

The Cake Request

Hesitant to Go

The Party Begins

A Warning from Rob ⚠️

The Prank Goes Wrong

Rob’s Anger

Standing up for Halle

Leaving the Party ♂️

Rob’s Angry Texts

Halle’s Suggestion ️

A Birthday Cake Fiasco and a Family Feud
So, what do you think? Was Rob’s prank just a harmless joke, or did he cross the line? Should Halle have been more careful with the cake, or was Rob’s prank completely out of line? And should the brother apologize for taking the cupcakes, or was he right to stand up for his wife? It’s a messy situation, and we want to know what you think! Let’s check out some top responses from the internet.
Brother’s ‘prank’ goes too far, family supports bullying. NTA.

Cutting off toxic family members for baby’s safety

Brother’s ‘pranks’ go too far, wife is a saint, NTA.

Brother’s ‘prank’ goes too far, wife deserves apology. NTA.

Cut ties with toxic prankster family for your wife and child. NTA

Commenter calls out bully brother’s dangerous prank.

Brother’s prank goes too far, OP takes cupcakes. NTA.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/1a6948b7-1592-4ccc-a4b8-b8ac52e74ef8.png)
Brother gets what he deserves for ruining cupcakes

Family prank goes too far, wife assaulted. NTA.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/4d154d4c-53e7-4977-b277-1afae6fcd91f.png)
Cutting toxic people out of your life is necessary

Commenters agree: Brother’s prank went too far, no refund necessary

Protecting your child from toxic family members

Defending disrespectful behavior only enables it. NTA.

Standing up to a bully brother – NTA

Standing up for his wife’s honor, NTA brother gets revenge
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/7f5ab063-e169-49f2-b4a9-c5577baaa81b.png)
Commenter condemns brother’s behavior in birthday cake prank.

Cut ties with prankster brother for dangerous birthday cake prank. NTA

Cutting off toxic family members is sometimes necessary

Standing up for your wife, NTA. Family needs to change

Brother’s prank backfires, cupcakes remain off-limits.

Concerned commenter questions prankster brother’s behavior

Setting boundaries with family after humiliating prank

Sibling rivalry taken too far? Revenge ideas welcome
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/635597f8-6b5c-43f7-8d16-cc225bf38a78.png)
Stand up for your spouse! You’re NTA

Setting boundaries with family to protect your child.

Brother assaults wife, commenters suggest cutting him off completely.

Brother ruins cake, sister goes no contact.

Cutting off toxic family members? NTA, do what’s best.

Stand up against abuse. Don’t let bullies win. NTA

Sibling rivalry taken too far
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3301ff36-092b-4026-a205-73de15c3e273.png)
Prankster brother ruins birthday cake, gets cupcakes taken away. NTA.

Heartbreaking cake destruction by bully brother, cut contact immediately.

Dealing with family drama: NTA but no-win situation

Rewarding bad behavior sets a bad example for your child
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/9af2e549-536f-4aab-b63c-482d232e755d.png)
Cake prank backfires, brother learns costly lesson.

Supportive spouse stands up against prankster brother

Sibling rivalry gone wrong, NTA stands up for self

Setting boundaries in relationships is important for mutual respect

Prankster brother ruins birthday cake, gets his comeuppance

Commenter raises valid concern about safety of prank gone wrong.

Sibling rivalry gets out of hand. NTA calls out immaturity.

Wife vs Brother: Cake prank gone wrong

Brother’s birthday prank goes wrong. Commenters side with victim.

Setting boundaries for a safe and supportive family environment.

Standing up to family for the safety of your child NTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e4044199-6f7a-401e-ab8c-e53455442722.png)
Sibling prank goes wrong, but OP saves the cupcakes!

Standing up against bullying: Don’t apologize for his behavior
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/27f2d905-16ba-4803-afd6-6e1957d10296.png)
Protect your family. Cut ties with the cruel prankster brother
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/ae76cb00-35dd-4e98-8fb4-eca6388c49c4.png)
Brotherly love gone wrong. NTA stands their ground

Prankster brother goes too far, earns NTA judgement.

Delicious cupcakes save the day for not-the-a**hole commenter

Protecting your family comes first. Cut ties with dangerous brother.

Sibling rivalry turns violent on birthday, justice served with payment.

Cutting off toxic family members

Prankster brother ruins birthday cake, gets called out for bullying

Brother’s ‘joke’ not funny, NTA for being upset

Sibling prank goes too far, commenter advises cutting contact. NTA

Brother paid for cake, but assaulted wife. NTA for retaliation.

Sibling prank gone wrong. Would you have reacted violently?

Brother ruins birthday cake, commenters sympathize with wife.


Brother’s prank goes too far, commenters side with wife.

Brother pulls prank, wife suggests apology, commenter defends OP.

New mom gets support after family’s visit goes wrong

Commenter expresses shock and outrage at dangerous prank

Commenter advises cutting off family until pranks stop

Brother’s pranks are actually illegal. NTA for holding him accountable.

Last Updated on May 19, 2023 by Diply Social Team