✨ Pregnant Woman Refuses to Thank Sister-in-Law’s ‘Fertility Spell’ – Who’s in the Wrong?

Picture this: you’ve been trying to get pregnant for almost a year, and finally, the good news arrives! But there’s a twist: your sister-in-law, a self-proclaimed lifetime Wiccan, claims her ‘master-level fertility spell’ is the sole reason for your pregnancy. Now she’s demanding a thank you and validation for her magical efforts. What would you do? ‍♀️

The Struggle to Conceive

Enter the Wiccan Sister-in-Law

Unsolicited Magic

The Pregnancy Announcement

Sister-in-Law’s Passive-Aggressive Behavior

Behind-the-Back Gossip

To Thank or Not to Thank?

Husband’s Opinion

Edit: General Thank You

A Magical Dilemma: Does She Owe Her Wiccan Sister-in-Law a Thank You?

Our protagonist is overjoyed to be pregnant after months of trying, but her sister-in-law’s insistence that her ‘fertility spell’ is the sole reason for the pregnancy is causing tension. The Wiccan SIL is demanding a thank you and validation for her magical efforts, but our protagonist doesn’t even believe in witchcraft. To make matters worse, she’s been gossiping behind her back, calling her ungrateful and rude. The husband thinks his wife owes his sister nothing, but she can’t help feeling guilty. Let’s dive into the internet’s thoughts on this enchanting predicament… ✨

Experienced Wiccan calls out sister-in-law’s pretentious ‘fertility spell’. NTA.

Sarcastic comment shuts down sister-in-law’s passive-aggressive behavior. NTA.

Pregnant woman’s SIL takes credit for her pregnancy with ‘fertility spell’

Questioning the logic of the ‘fertility spell’

NTA and SIL’s antics make for great stories

Respectful refusal of fertility spell leads to validation conflict. NTA.

Pagan ex-believer calls out SIL’s fertility spell as a con.

NTA for not thanking sister-in-law’s unasked fertility spell. Watch out for her charging for spells though

Sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’ refusal sparks agreement and boundaries.

Pregnant woman refuses to thank sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’ – NTA

Respect boundaries: NTA for not thanking for unwanted ‘fertility spell’

NTA calls out sister-in-law’s ‘working spell’ as total BS

Pagan/witch explains why SIL’s fertility spell is problematic ✨

NTA: Unasked help does not deserve thanks.

Fertility spells don’t work, NTA for not thanking SIL’s spell

Pagan commenter explains why casting a spell without consent is wrong

Agreeing with NTA comment and calling out ‘fertility spell’ as nonsense.

NTA stands up to sister-in-law’s fertility spell BS

Casting a fertility spell on someone who doesn’t want it? NTA

Unwanted fertility spell? NTA for not thanking sister-in-law ‍♀️

Selfish sister-in-law wants credit for pregnancy, commenter says NTA.

Defending Wiccans, commenter deems thanking for spell unnecessary.

Pagan commenter finds ‘Master-Level spell’ hilarious

SIL casts unasked-for ‘fertility spell’, demands credit. NTA claps back.

Wiccan commenter calls out pregnant woman’s rude behavior ‍♀️

Did the sister-in-law’s fertility spell actually work?

NTA: Calling out the absurdity of fertility spells.

Pregnant woman not obliged to thank sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’

Witchcraft practitioner explains why SIL’s fertility spell was invasive. NTA.

Respectful comment defends Wicca as a religion and supports OP’s stance.

Pagan commenter explains why sister-in-law’s fertility spell is inappropriate

Sarcastic comment calls for more updates on meddling sister-in-law

NTA or N A H? Commenter suggests considering SIL’s beliefs.

Wiccan commenter supports OP’s decision to refuse fertility spell ‍♀️

Pregnant woman politely declines sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’ offer. NTA.

Don’t validate superstitions. NTA for refusing fertility spell thanks.

Sister-in-law expects gratitude for ‘fertility spell’ – YTA?

Respectful refusal of unsolicited fertility spell, NTA ‍♀️✨

Sassy reply shuts down sister-in-law’s ego. NTA wins.

Pregnant woman credits Reverse Cowgirl, not sister-in-law’s spell. NTA.

Congrats on pregnancy! Expecting thanks for fertility spell is narcissistic

Respectful NTA response to sister-in-law’s unwanted fertility spell

Thanking someone for their support is enough. NTA

NTA. Commenter humorously suggests thanking sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’ may prevent being turned into a toad.

Sassy response shuts down sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’. NTA

Setting boundaries with religious in-laws. NTA wins this one.

Respectful response to religious beliefs and gratitude.

Sassy NTA comment shuts down attention-seeking sister-in-law

A neutral thank you could have avoided the trouble. NTA

NTA for not thanking SIL’s ‘fertility spell’, nicely explained.

Spell-casting sister-in-law gets mad when not thanked.

Redditor calls out OP for not being gracious towards SIL’s beliefs

NTA. Refusing to thank mentally ill SIL for fertility spell.

NTA for not thanking sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’, but consider private thanks to maintain relationship

Sassy NTA response shuts down sister-in-law’s fake magic spell.

NTA. Unsolicited ‘help’ and name-calling is invasive and weird

Being polite won’t hurt, but it’s not mandatory. ‍♀️

No clear proof it was her spell. NTA for refusing.

Compromise suggested for NTA’s refusal to thank sister-in-law’s spell.

NTA claims fertility spell is ridiculous in hilarious comment.

NTA stands up to sister-in-law’s fertility spell with clever comeback

Sarcastic NTA comment suggests thanking husband’s testes for pregnancy ‍♀️

NTA. Congrats on the pregnancy and standing up for yourself!

Gratefulness shouldn’t be forced.

Politely declining sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’ – NTA wins.

A clever suggestion to thank everyone, including SIL, with humor

A sarcastic reply to a fertility spell suggestion.

NTA shuts down sister-in-law’s inappropriate behavior and beliefs ‍♀️

Pagan commenter questions sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’, supports OP (NTA)

Friend’s Wiccan spell worked, but spells require consent. NTA.

Supportive comment wishes pregnant woman well, calls out husband’s role

Christian commenter denounces taking credit for others’ achievements.

Demanding gratitude for a fertility spell is bizarre

Former Pagan explains spellwork and why SIL is in the wrong ✨

Pregnant woman hilariously shuts down sister-in-law’s fertility spell ‍♀️

Small thank you for fertility spell, why not?

Ignoring sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’ drama is the better option

A sarcastic comment about a fertility spell gone wrong.

Sassy comment shuts down need for fertility spell gratitude ‍♀️

NTA, but sister-in-law may still claim success to her coven

NTA stands up to sister-in-law’s ‘fertility spell’ and possible revenge