Meet our conflicted mom, who’s caught in the crossfire between her children’s academic futures and emotional wellbeing. Her daughter, Emma, is a prodigy, reading at 4 and winning national competitions. The school wants to skip her a grade, but there’s a catch. Her brother Jonah, who had to repeat a year, is in the same grade Emma is supposed to skip to. Fearing the impact on Jonah’s self-esteem, our mom declines the school’s offer, causing a family rift. Let’s delve into this emotional rollercoaster.
Meet the Family

Emma’s Brilliance

The School’s Proposal

Jonah’s Struggles

A Mother’s Decision

Emma’s Reaction

A Mother’s Defense ️

Dad’s Support

A Plea for Fairness ⚖️

A Mother’s Heartache: Balancing Brilliance and Brotherhood
Our mom is caught in a whirlwind of emotions. Her daughter, Emma, a gifted child, is offered the chance to skip a grade. But her son Jonah, who had to repeat a year, is in the same grade. Fearing the impact on Jonah’s self-esteem, she declines the offer, causing a family rift. Emma is upset, feeling her brother’s situation shouldn’t affect her. Dad sides with mom, but Emma remains hurt. The mother is left questioning her decision, wondering if she did right by both her children. Let’s see what the internet has to say about this delicate situation…
OP is holding daughter back to save son’s embarrassment. YTA

YTA OP. Hindering daughter’s growth for son’s ego?

Skipping grades: a rare choice with potential long-term consequences.

“YTA. Favoritism and unfair treatment. Kids notice. “

Crushing a daughter’s ambition? YTA. Consider a better school.

“YTA for holding back your daughter. Unfair to her intelligence.”

Skipping grades: Is it fair to sacrifice opportunities for siblings?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/7751781e-ac9d-45aa-b39a-f504bf931341.png)
Did you ask the school? Consider Emma’s negatives too.

Preventing a bright girl from reaching her potential. YTA.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/eb05d858-cd4c-46df-8736-6fefc3083cc1.png)
Mother prioritized Jonah and assumed his feelings without consulting Emma. YTA

Protecting egos over self-image: the lasting impact on a child.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/273e2450-6b09-4b5e-92c2-cef42313e23a.png)
Skipping grades: YTA comment expresses frustration with sibling rivalry.

YTA for holding back gifted child, hindering sibling’s growth.

More info needed on Jonah’s situation. Gentle YTA for Emma.

Parent’s tough decision: Skipping grades or sibling rivalry?

Mom’s favoritism alienates daughter, risking her academic motivation.

“YTA. Not being fair to Emma. How do you think?”

Parental decision without child’s input? YTA

“YTA. Punishing your daughter for your son’s lack of effort? “

Parent criticized for holding back daughter’s academic progress.

Lying to daughter about skipping grades? YTA, according to comment.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/c29356b0-e538-46be-ae4e-b9f4114d7bb7.png)
YTA for holding back Emma and coddling your son.

Sibling rivalry escalates as mom makes a controversial decision.

Unfair to Emma. Consider other options for her future.
