Man Wants Fiancée to Pay His Debt: Fair or Foul?

Picture this: you’re in a relationship, and one person is drowning in debt while the other is financially stable. The couple is planning to get married, but the debt-ridden partner has a proposal: the financially stable partner should pay off their debt, and they’ll pay them back in a year and a half. Sounds fair, right? Well, not everyone thinks so. In this story, a man (31) is struggling with $67k in debt, while his fiancée (29) is almost debt-free and has a considerable amount in savings. He wants her to pay off his debt, and he’ll pay her back later. But is this really a fair deal? Let’s dive into the details.

The Debt Dilemma

Fiancée’s Financial Success

Credit Card Crisis Averted ️

Impressive Savings

Moving In and Wedding Plans

A Three-Year Plan

The Spreadsheet Solution

Her Generous Offer

The Counter Offer

Her Reaction

Friends Weigh In

The Savings Sacrifice

So, Is He the A**hole?

In this tale of love and money, we’ve got a man with $67k in debt and a fiancée who’s managed to become almost debt-free with a solid savings account. She offers to cover all their expenses while he aggressively pays off his debt before their wedding, but he counters with a proposal for her to pay his debt and he’ll pay her back later. His friends think he’s being an a**hole, but what do you think? Is it fair for her to bail him out, or should he take her generous two-year offer and work on his debt himself? Let’s see what the internet has to say about this sticky situation…

Fiancé expects handout, rejects generous offer, and is called out. YTA.

OP is the a**hole for asking his fiancée to pay his debt.

Man wants fiancée to pay debt, commenters call him sketchy

Fiancé should not be responsible for partner’s debt.

Commenter and replies agree: OP is the a**hole.

Fiancé wants her to pay his debt despite her generous offer. YTA.

OP’s plan to have fiancée pay debt is a scam. YTA

Commenter calls OP the a**hole and questions his trustworthiness. Replies suggest the fiancée may be testing him before marriage.

YTA wants fiancée to pay his debt. Gracious partner deserves better

Fiancée’s plan is generous and protects her. YTA for asking more.

Commenter warns against agreeing to fiancé’s debt proposal.

YTA for expecting fiancée to pay off your debt

Fiancé wants debt paid off without commitment. YTA.

YTA. Her plan was thoughtful, solid, and kept your unmarried debt separate, and your counter seems to only benefit you.

Man wants fiancée to pay his debt, but commenters say YTA.

User calls out OP for being selfish and unsupportive.

Beware of marrying someone with debt? Discussion on pre-marital finances.

Fiancé wants debt paid, called YTA. Is marriage doomed?

YTA wants fiancée to pay his debt and won’t take her plan ‍♂️

Man wants fiancée to pay his debt and argues with her. YTA

User sarcastically asks for fiancée’s number to pay off debt. Commenter calls out OP and labels them as YTA.

Don’t be a YTA. Graciously accept the rent-free offer

YTA expecting her to pay off your debt with no guarantee.

Fiancé wants her to pay his debt without any security

Commenter calls out OP for being a double a**hole

User calls out man for wanting fiancée to pay his debt

Commenter calls out OP for unfair debt proposal.

Fiancée covering bills, YTA wants debt paid off too

Fiancé wants debt-free partner to pay his debts? YTA, dude.

Man wants fiancée to pay his debt, but YTA comment shuts him down.

Commenter thinks OP is the a**hole. Uh-oh

Don’t be a greedy a**hole, take her generous offer.

Commenter thinks OP is an a**hole and a red flag

Plan your finances and show her real numbers

Fiancé proposes debt plan, but OP wants more. YTA.

Fiancée’s plan to not pay man’s debt is fair. YTA.

Fiancée says HELL NO to entitled debt counteroffer. YTA

Fiancée suspicious of YTA wanting debt paid off.

Fiancée’s offer is already generous. YTA for asking more.

Commenter calls out fiancé for trying to make partner pay debt

Man wants fiancée to pay his debt, but commenters say YTA.

Debt-shifting fiancé gets called out for unfairness.

Fiancé refuses to pay his debt, commenters call him YTA.

Commenter calls out man for wanting fiancée to pay debt. YTA!

Commenter calls out OP for wanting fiancée to pay debt

Fiancée should run ‍♀️ and leave him with his debt

Fiancé wants her to pay his debt, commenters say YTA and fiscally uneducated

Bride offers to pay debt, groom refuses. YTA or NTA?

YTA gets called out for proposing a scam

Commenter thinks someone is the a**hole.

Debt-free couple calls YTA disrespectful and a huge AH

Counter-offering to make fiancée pay debt: YTA. Don’t be greedy.

Commenter thinks man’s request is unfair and unwise

Commenter questions man’s contribution to relationship, deems him YTA.

Man tries to make fiancée pay his debt, gets called out.

Fiancée offers to help pay off debt, but OP wants more YTA

Generous fiancée offers to pay off debt, confusion over math explained ‍

Man wants fiancée to pay his debt, but YTA. Work harder.

Donut financial acumen? Fiancée should end engagement.

A blunt YTA verdict buried in a sea of BS