Picture this: three brothers, a mother with early onset dementia, and some tough decisions to make. When the time came for their mother to choose who would make medical decisions on her behalf, she picked the youngest brother. But there’s a catch – she asked him to keep it a secret from the other brothers. Fast forward three years, and the secret is finally out. Now, the youngest brother is left wondering if he’s the bad guy for revealing the truth.
The Three Brothers
Mom’s Tough Decision
Choosing a Decision-Maker
Mom’s Wishes
Financial Support
Agreeing to Mom’s Wishes ✅
Balancing Life
Mom’s Other Wishes
Keeping It a Secret
Three Years Later ⏳
The Argument Heats Up
The Big Reveal
Matt’s Reaction
Frank’s Opinion ♂️
Secrets, Lies, and Family Ties
After their father’s passing, the brothers’ mother was diagnosed with early onset dementia. Knowing her time was limited, she made the tough decision to assign her youngest son as the one to make medical choices for her. She had specific wishes, like staying in her own home and not being kept alive by machines, but asked her son to keep his role a secret from his brothers. As her condition worsened, the eldest brother, Matt, insisted on putting her in an assisted living facility, leading to heated arguments with the youngest brother. Eventually, the secret came out, leaving Matt hurt and their mother upset. Now, the youngest brother is left questioning if he did the right thing by revealing the truth, while the middle brother, Frank, thinks he should’ve kept it to himself. ♂️ Let’s see what the internet has to say about this family drama…
RELATED STORIES
NTA, brother is manipulative and abusive towards mom
Keeping power secret was impossible. NTA for being honest.
Sibling rivalry over mom’s medical decisions and finances. NTA.
Sibling drama over mom’s medical decisions. NTA, but Matt’s an AH
Protecting mom from a sneaky sibling with legal power
Sibling conflict over dementia patient’s medical decisions. ⚕️
Sibling conflict over POA for mother with Alzheimer’s
Being named medical decision maker causes family feud. NTA wins.
Protecting Mom’s wishes and money from greedy brother
Delaying conversation about medical decisions led to family conflict ⏰
You did the right thing for your mom ✔️
Former in-home aide advises NTA to consider safety and future challenges ❤️
Brother’s greed exposed, NTA stands up for mother’s wishes
Mom’s medical decision causes family drama. NTA comment wins.
Sibling rivalry over medical decisions. NTA has prevailed.
Discussing end-of-life wishes with loved ones is crucial
Mom made the right choice, he’s not respecting her wishes. NTA
Brother seeks validation from sick mother, proves her right. NTA
Supportive comment to OP dealing with brother and dementia.
Sibling drama over medical POA and brother’s incompetence. NTA
Consider discussing assisted living with mom’s doctor for her care ✨
Matt’s greed is obvious. OP, you’re NTA and a great son ❤️
Navigating family conflict over caregiving and finances ✌
Sibling conflict over mom’s medical decisions resolved with NTA verdict.
Caring for a loved one with dementia can be challenging. NTA
Sibling greed jeopardizes mother’s care
Stand your ground and honor your mother’s wishes
Plan ahead to avoid family conflicts over end-of-life care ✍️
Mother’s medical decisions: NTA doesn’t want daughter making choices
Consider memory-care facilities, 3 home aides/day is expensive
Sibling conflict over mom’s medical decision. Support for OP.
Brother’s greed exposed, commenter calls him ‘disgusting’.
NTA, but it’s important to research and plan for future care ❤️
Sibling feud over mom’s medical decisions resolved with love ❤
You’re doing what’s right for your mom. Your brother’s behavior is unacceptable.
Following mom’s wishes despite greedy brother’s objections
Tips for navigating difficult family decisions during medical crises
Being a DPOA is tough, but NTA for making decisions alone
Supportive comment on home care and family communication ❤
Stand your ground and follow your mother’s wishes.
Honesty is the best policy, especially in tough family situations
Brother disregards mother’s wishes, proves her right. NTA.
Sibling rivalry over medical power of attorney. You’re NTA ♂️
Making tough decisions for loved ones is never easy.
Protecting mom’s medical decisions from manipulative brother. Stay strong ❤️
Standing up for mom: NTA brother seeks family support
Matt’s manipulative behavior towards mom. NTA. Set boundaries.
Planning legal documents is essential to avoid family conflicts
Sibling rivalry escalates over mom’s medical decisions
Sibling rivalry over mom’s healthcare proxy and inheritance
Mother slightly TA, brother HUGE AH for crying to her
Sibling drama over mom’s medical decisions and inheritance
Caring for a loved one with dementia is tough.
POA prevents narcissistic brother from taking advantage of elderly parents.
Navigating family dynamics in medical decisions ⚕️
A selfish comment about putting mom in a home
Plan for mom’s future care while she’s still lucid.
Brother is more concerned about inheritance than mother’s well-being
Sibling drama over mom’s medical decisions. You’re NTA
Tips on securing legal documents and navigating end-of-life decisions
A helpful recommendation for those with loved ones with dementia ❤️
Caring for a loved one with dementia can be challenging
Navigating the difficult decisions of elder care.
Navigating family opinions during difficult medical decisions. NTA
Compassionate support for a difficult family situation
Brother prioritizes inheritance over mom’s in-home care
Honoring mom’s wishes ✌ over inheritance
Sibling rivalry over mom’s medical decisions. NTA takes charge.
Keeping secrets is pointless. NTA
Respect your mother’s decision. Why is your brother interfering?
A heartwarming story of a daughter’s love for her mother ❤
Sibling drama over mom’s medical decisions and inheritance
Navigating the difficult decisions of dementia care.
Sole caretaker of mom’s wishes, NTA amidst family drama ❤
NTA calls out a family member for being a leech
NTA. You did the right thing protecting your mother.
Stand firm and keep advocating for your mom! NTA
Following a loved one’s wishes is key. NTA
Sibling rivalry over mom’s medical decisions and inheritance
Stand strong in advocating for your mother’s legal wishes!
A heartfelt reply from someone who’s been through it ❤️
Encouraging comment to put mother’s wishes in writing for legal protection ⚖️
Sibling rivalry at its finest ♂️
Brother ignored mom’s wishes, complains about not being chosen?
Taking charge of mom’s medical decisions – NTA comment.
Follow mom’s wishes, let Matt cry to his therapist
Sibling rivalry over medical decisions
Respectful NTA stands up for mom’s wishes
Sibling conflict over elderly care responsibilities, NTA handled well
Navigating tough medical decisions for loved ones with dementia
