Meet the ‘Tough Love’ Uncle, a 45-year-old man who has stepped up to care for his 15-year-old niece, Shelly, amidst a family crisis. With his sister temporarily out of the picture due to tax issues, he’s taken on the responsibility of feeding Shelly and the rest of his family. But when Shelly, who weighs 320lbs, asked for extra servings at dinner, he found himself in a moral conundrum. Is he right to refuse her request in the name of health, or is he being too harsh during a tough time? Let’s dive into the drama. ️
An Unexpected Responsibility
Meet Shelly, the Niece in Question ♀️
The ‘Tough Love’ Uncle’s Meal Plan ️
The Dinner Dilemma
Shelly’s Request for More Food ️
The Uncle’s Refusal
Social Media Backlash
Uncle’s Stand on the Issue
The Guilt and Dilemma
The Moral Conundrum
The ‘Tough Love’ Uncle’s Dilemma: Health vs. Hunger
Caught in a whirlwind of family drama, the ‘Tough Love’ Uncle is grappling with a difficult decision. He’s trying to balance his niece Shelly’s emotional wellbeing with her physical health. While he’s committed to providing nutritious meals for his family, Shelly’s request for extra servings has put him in a tough spot. He’s refusing to enable overeating, but at the same time, he’s aware that Shelly is going through a tough time. Is he doing the right thing, or is he being too harsh? Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…
RELATED STORIES
NTA. Stand strong against her bullying. Consider therapy for her.
NTA. Adding extra veggies as a side is a great idea!
NTA – Tough love: You do enough cooking already! ♂️
Holding the line on food, but is it a healthy coping mechanism?
NTA. Setting a good example and dealing with social media backlash
NTA at all. 320 lb is not “big.” It’s morbidly obese.
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/a8bc5618-89ad-4d7e-9e3f-4e6662e565fa.png)
NTA: Inspiring story of overcoming childhood starvation and establishing healthy habits
Helping her battle her demons with food and counseling
NTA, niece needs therapy to cope with mom’s absence
“NTA. Set boundaries and teach her about consequences. “
Shelly’s entitled demands backfire!
Encourage her to cook healthy meals and snacks for herself!
A military-like food system, but is it worth the effort?
NTA. ♂️ Have you explained your concerns about her weight?
NTA: Tough love or health-conscious? Chicken and veggies vs pizza/burger
Encouragement and support for doing the right thing!
NTA. Feed her and share delicious meals on social media!
Using food to cope can lead to dangerous eating disorders.
NTA, but prioritize her health! Take her to the doctor ⚕️
Tough love for an obese niece? NTA, you’re doing great!
Empathy and encouragement for a struggling parent, keep going! ✊
NTA. Tough love for entitled niece. Find somewhere else
Using food as a coping mechanism? Therapy can help! NTA
NTA. Tough love: No seconds for her, same as everyone else.
A disabled person wants to move in, but there’s competition!
“I used to be 435 lbs… I understand your niece.”
Independent teen with food access, NTA.
NTA. Seek professional help for her eating disorder. Document everything.
Suggest therapy for her emotional struggles; find a nearby location
“NTA… she can make her own food!”
NTA, but teach her basic cooking skills and consider therapy.
NTA. Power through the abuse for a delicious reward!
Engaging suggestion: Cook with her and consider a nutritionist
NTA: Tough love for niece’s health, but is it enough?
NTA for providing healthy meals, but could improve communication and support
NTA: Tough love and potential false accusations causing family turmoil
Traumatized teenager fat-shamed by uncle, causing outrage and heartbreak.
NTA for not making extra meals, but shaming her is wrong
NTA: Tough love vs. social media drama
Not the a**hole for prioritizing health over hunger
NTA. Treat her eating disorder like any other addiction
NTA, but she needs real medical help ⚕️
“NTA she needs professional help to deal with her hunger.”
Meal planning level:
Don’t give in! Niece needs help, not personal chef. ♂️
Controversial comment sparks debate on child’s weight and well-being
Commenter calls for therapy and support for struggling teenager.
Concerned commenter discusses child’s weight with empathy
Heart attack waiting to happen! 320 lbs at 15?
NTA. Providing her with what she needs, and sharing personal experience.
Let her cook! No need for OP to do extra prep
NTA, tough love can be a blessing in disguise
From excessive activity to massive calorie intake, a true foodie!
15-year-old too lazy to make own food. NTA.
NTA, but Shelly needs therapy. Let’s prioritize her mental health!
YTA for fat shaming, but focus on loving her as she is ❤️
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/d3bd32e8-f2c1-4d16-86de-a8061c129128.png)
Empathy for a struggling teenager adjusting to a new lifestyle
Shelly’s weight is a concern, but counseling is essential.
Emotional plea for therapy and counseling for eating disorder
Uncle’s tough love: Setting boundaries with entitled niece ♂️
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/613173f2-5b80-42d3-b103-d215b2565abe.png)
Setting boundaries with ungrateful family member. Stay strong!
Shelly needs therapy, not food. Find a child psychologist!
Tough love for a loved one’s health, but worth it!
Compassionate tough love: Help her overcome cravings for a happier life
Share your meals to prove you’re not starving your family!
Supportive comment acknowledges the need for more comprehensive help.
NTA. Encourage therapy for Shelly and consider family therapy too
One plate is enough! Not the a**hole. ️
Supportive advice for helping someone with an eating disorder
Isolation, hunger, and trauma: A cry for help
Supportive advice to help her on her weight loss journey
