A Heartrending Adoption Request Ignites Family Feud: Who's in the Wrong?

Diply Social Team
Diply | Diply

Imagine being unable to have children after years of trying, then finding hope in the possibility of adopting your sister's children, only to be met with a wall of resentment. This is the heartbreaking situation a 31-year-old woman and her husband find themselves in. Their well-intentioned proposal to keep their niece and nephew within the family has ignited a family feud that no one saw coming. 😢💥

A Couple's Heartbreaking Journey to Parenthood 🌈👶

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

A Ray of Hope: Adoption 🏠💕

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

The Family Crisis Unfolds 🌀👨‍👩‍👧‍👦

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

A Tragic Turn of Events 😢💔

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

An Unexpected Proposal 💍👨‍👩‍👧‍👦

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

A Shocking Reaction 😮🔥

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

The Aftermath: Blocked and Banned 🚫👨‍👩‍👧‍👦

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

A Possible Explanation? 🤔💭

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

A Sister's Love Amidst the Chaos ❤️👭

aitaadoptingsiskids | aitaadoptingsiskids

A Family Torn Apart: Love, Loss, and an Adoption Proposal 💔👨‍👩‍👧‍👦

When a couple's dream of having children was dashed, they found a glimmer of hope in adopting their sister's kids. Little did they know, their well-meaning proposal would ignite a family feud, leaving them blocked and banned from seeing their beloved niece and nephew. Amidst the chaos, the couple wonders if they crossed a line or if their sister's negative reaction is a cry for help, possibly due to untreated postnatal depression and grief. The situation leaves us pondering: were they wrong for proposing adoption, or is the sister being unreasonable? Let's see what the internet thinks of this emotional rollercoaster. 🎢💭

NTA: Sister wants control but not responsibility. Adoption offers stability. 👍

CakeisaDie | CakeisaDie

Heartbreaking situation for the 9-year-old, but NTA for fighting.

semerien | semerien

NTA. Offering to adopt niece and nephew, criticizing sister's issues.

[deleted] | [deleted]

NTA! Engaging comment about adoption and family dynamics. 🤔

Ennah_Schemer | Ennah_Schemer

NTA. Helping sister, kids get loving home. Win-win situation. ❤️👪

johnmduggan | johnmduggan

NTA. Your sister needs professional help. 🤷‍♂️

moongirl12 | moongirl12

NTA. Research adoption laws for best interest of all involved.

ferocious_llama | ferocious_llama

Compassion and conflict: Navigating family dynamics in a delicate situation.

GothPenguin | GothPenguin

NTA! Your sister's behavior is outrageous. Protect those children! 💜

lulubelle09 | lulubelle09

NAH. Get a lawyer and fight for custody through courts 💪

[deleted] | [deleted]

You're a good person! Adopt them without her! 💛

HowToFixOurDemocracy | HowToFixOurDemocracy

Compassionate suggestion for adoption sparks family tension. NTA, but tread carefully.

abcwva | abcwva

Engaging suggestion to let parents care for kids while sister calms down 😊

Weenaru | Weenaru

NTA. Encourage her to seek help for postnatal depression 🙏

[deleted] | [deleted]

NTA. It's cruel of her, keep the kids away for now.

kemiass | kemiass

NTA: Standing up for the well-being of your sister's children 👏

Fafalle | Fafalle

Heartbreaking situation with an awful sister. NTA, save those kids! 💔

PlantaSorusRex | PlantaSorusRex

Heartbreaking plea for adoption amidst family turmoil. 💔

Medievalmoomin | Medievalmoomin

Navigating the foster care system: Can she bypass family adoption?

Unnecessary-Space814 | Unnecessary-Space814

Heartbreaking custody battle: NTA offers refuge for troubled kids ❤️

Apprehensive_Ad_2237 | Apprehensive_Ad_2237

👏 Taking in foster kids shows compassion and responsibility! NTA!

sunshine_lover47 | sunshine_lover47

NTA seeks legal advice to circumvent sister's foster care plan.

kellydofc | kellydofc

NTA, sister's mental illness affects her parenting decisions. Adopt the kids ❤️

Extreme-Waltz7138 | Extreme-Waltz7138

NTA advises on formal custody arrangement to protect children's safety.

Mama_Mush | Mama_Mush

Heartbreaking plea for therapy to protect traumatized child 💔

soliloquieer | soliloquieer

Heartbreaking family feud: NTA in a sad situation 😢

Arefue | Arefue

Not the a**hole. Sparks fly in heartbreaking adoption dispute. 💔

Aggressive-Sample612 | Aggressive-Sample612

Is there more to your sister's behavior? A mental breakdown?

PM_UR_FELINES | PM_UR_FELINES

Passionate comment defends kids' right to a loving home ❤️

MarinaraSaucey12 | MarinaraSaucey12

Cutting ties with a toxic mother for the sake of kids 😬

PennyyPickle | PennyyPickle

Heartbreaking adoption request sparks family feud. Sister labeled a monster.

blueivysfutureintern | blueivysfutureintern

👏 NTA saves kids from system, sister takes anger on them

SoManyWhippets | SoManyWhippets

Not the a**hole. Let's hear their side of the story!

RestaurantNo7749 | RestaurantNo7749

Opportunity to adopt if she surrenders the children. 🏠❤️

d1scworld | d1scworld

NTA, taking in foster kids would be a Christmas miracle 🎄

HWGA_Exandria | HWGA_Exandria

🏆 NTA: Step up and give those kids the love they deserve!

Claire_Bee | Claire_Bee

NTA: Choosing family over sister may lead to permanent estrangement 😢

Sensitive_Ad_1063 | Sensitive_Ad_1063

Urgent intervention needed for sister's mental health. Protect the children! 🚑

[deleted] | [deleted]

Fight for custody through child services and show your commitment ❤️

fromhelley | fromhelley

Document everything and consult a lawyer for future reference! ✍️📝

Danmont88 | Danmont88

Choose the kids over your sister. NTA. 🙌

StainlessHinge | StainlessHinge

Heartbreaking adoption request sparks hope for a happy resolution. ❤️

Khanover7 | Khanover7

Former CPS caseworker explains why NTA and offers reassurance 👍

dogsandbooks9 | dogsandbooks9

Heart of gold shines through in selfless adoption request ❤️

[deleted] | [deleted]

Family feud erupts over sister's demand for isolation. NTA.

unknown_928121 | unknown_928121

Heartwarming plea for adoption sparks family feud. Who's at fault?

[deleted] | [deleted]

Offer to foster, get therapy, and keep family unit intact. 🙏

dramatic-pancake | dramatic-pancake

Government preference for family over foster care in adoption cases

znhamz | znhamz

👍 Take legal action to secure adoption rights. Get a lawyer!

ChrissyKittyCat | ChrissyKittyCat

Not the a**hole - sparks a family feud 🔥

sheezuss_ | sheezuss_

Creative adoption solution sparks debate among commenters. 🤔

FizziKat | FizziKat

Supportive comment: Autistic person advocates for stability and familiarity ❤️

AutisticTheatreKid | AutisticTheatreKid

NTA: Adopt the kids, ditch the sister. 🚫👀 Nurture resentment!

ohdearitsrichardiii | ohdearitsrichardiii

NTA, but sister needs help. Kids shouldn't be with her 😔

Kristinegombos | Kristinegombos

NTA: Support your sister and her children during this difficult time ❤️

frntztk | frntztk

👍 NTA. Explore alternatives to adoption, like guardianship or temporary custody.

woolfchick75 | woolfchick75

NTA! Get legal help ASAP for your abandoned niece and nephew! 🚨

[deleted] | [deleted]

NTA. Fight for custody to protect the children from their unstable mother. 💪

KitKat4816 | KitKat4816

NTA: Heartbreaking adoption request sparks family feud. Is she wrong?

Illustrious-Stick458 | Illustrious-Stick458

Supportive commenter hopes for stable future for the kids! 🙏

[deleted] | [deleted]

🔥🔒 Get the state involved to protect the kids! 🔒🔥

Consolegamergirl | Consolegamergirl

NTA. Adoption may be best for kids and sister's recovery. 💛

explodingwhale17 | explodingwhale17

NTA. Contact the adoption agency for help with your sister.

CarpeCyprinidae | CarpeCyprinidae

NTA. Kids deserve a good home. Sister's unfit. Family support needed. 💜

Special-Parsnip9057 | Special-Parsnip9057

Heartbroken for the family. Concerns about sister's proximity and treatment.

master0fcats | master0fcats

Take custody, give kids normalcy, keep distance from sister. NTA! 🏠

unicorndontcare69 | unicorndontcare69

NTA: OP is a SAINT! Best outcome for OP and niece/nephew.

dwegol | dwegol

🔥Sue for custody! Is she really an unfit parent?🔥

AllyKalamity | AllyKalamity

NTA: Adopting kids for a safe home. Sister's selfishness exposed.

lorelai_gilmore_20 | lorelai_gilmore_20

Parent giving up rights loses say in kids' living situation.

gorton2499 | gorton2499

Seeking custody through children's services, hoping for a happy ending. 🤞

bramira13 | bramira13

🤞 Hoping for a positive update on the custody battle!

EveOfTheTardis | EveOfTheTardis

Supportive comment, hoping for successful adoption despite family feud ❤️

Dammit_Janet5 | Dammit_Janet5

Heartbreaking plea for children's well-being, urging mother to reconsider.

InkyPaws | InkyPaws

NTA. Protecting the kids is never a bad thing. 💜

Vazlira | Vazlira

Engaging comment suggests potential challenges in adoption process. 🤔

SpicyHispanicWoman | SpicyHispanicWoman

Concerned about sister's mental health? 🤔 Reach out to her doctor!

plumbus_hun | plumbus_hun

Adopting abandoned children: a noble act with potential consequences ❤️

nomadzebra | nomadzebra

Heartbreaking tragedy fuels determination to protect children. Adopt and block.

Sensitive-Grass-892 | Sensitive-Grass-892

Engaging dilemma: adopt children and lose sister or lose children?

boodlenev | boodlenev

Not the a**hole - Let the family feud begin! 🔥

Yanu | Yanu

Supportive comment, wishing for sister's recovery ❤️

JennaLS | JennaLS

NTA! The children's mother doesn't understand foster care. Sucks to be her! 😏

okileggs1992 | okileggs1992

NTA. Fight for custody with evidence. Get a family lawyer! 👊

Mission-Cloud360 | Mission-Cloud360

NTA: Sister's questionable motives for foster care spark family conflict.

Kay_Elle | Kay_Elle

Filed Under: