Picture this: It’s Christmas, and you’ve decided to surprise your girlfriend with an $800 Coach bag. You think it’s the perfect gift to lift her spirits after a tough year, but instead, it triggers a whirlwind of emotions, an explosive argument, and a trip to the hospital. Let’s dive into this rollercoaster of a holiday story, where good intentions meet unexpected reactions.
A Tough Year for the Vet Nurse Girlfriend
The Boyfriend’s Supportive Gesture
The Christmas Surprise: An $800 Coach Bag
The Unexpected Reaction
Accusations and Arguments ️
The Dramatic Exit
A Lonely Christmas
The Snarky Text Message
The Hospital Call
Blame Game Begins
A Christmas to Remember
A Christmas Gift That Ended in Tears, Arguments, and a Hospital Visit
In a surprising turn of events, a man’s attempt to cheer up his girlfriend with a lavish Christmas gift backfires spectacularly. The $800 Coach bag, meant to bring joy, instead triggers a heated argument, accusations of being a ‘sugar baby,’ and a dramatic exit. The girlfriend, already dealing with epilepsy, has a seizure and ends up in the hospital. Now, the boyfriend is left questioning his actions, feeling blamed, and grappling with a Christmas that’s anything but merry. Let’s see what the internet thinks of this situation…
RELATED STORIES
ESH: Girlfriend’s stress, OP’s defensive response, and lack of empathy.
“YTA, you agreed not to do gifts, you didn’t pick up something small because she was important to you (that could be reciprocated by a good gesture in return), you did something she could not reciprocate and then tried to write it off. She was already stressed about it and felt worse for your gift.”
“YTA. Return the expensive gift and grovel.” – Commenter
“Is it common to agree on gifting?” – Reply
Soft YTA for extravagant gift, but not responsible for seizure.
“YTA for getting an $800 gift when you agreed no gifts “
YTA for giving an unwanted gift, sister is also an AH
OP’s insensitive gift and text caused emotional turmoil, YTA
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/110464cc-690a-400a-b6ed-d79d5187a6e3.png)
YTA broke gift agreement, harassed her, caused stress, and ignored boundaries
“YTA. You agreed to no gifts and then gave her something insanely out of touch for what she was expecting. If you knew for MONTHS that you had something for her, you could’ve at least prepped it by saying, look I did get you a little something, but don’t expect anything back. Or because I think you deserve it for the tough year we had. That PLUS the shitty texts to her because she went and got space from you is AH behavior. You can be the AH even though I agree with others that you didn’t cause a seizure (or at least aren’t directly to blame). You need to work on communicating and learning your girlfriend’s love languages better, especially if stress is one of her triggers. Find presents that de-escalates as others have mentioned (breakfast in bed, a day trip away from life stress).”
“YTA. Dismissing her feelings and arguing instead of acknowledging them.”
NTA: Communicate your love and understanding to resolve the situation
Opinions clash on gift-giving expectations, causing tension and misunderstanding.
NTA. Girlfriend’s reaction was unfair, but there’s more to it
“YTA for overspending on a gift. Holidays can be stressful.”
“YTA. You broke the agreement and bought an expensive gift. “
ESH: Miscommunication and meltdown leads to a Christmas disaster
“NTA. You wanted to make her feel loved, not bad “
“YTA. Expensive gift after agreement. Materialistic vs non-materialistic clash.”
Debate over the price and quality of *Coach* bags sparks discussion
YTA for disregarding her needs and causing unnecessary stress
Thoughtful gift misunderstood, causing unnecessary conflict. NTA for sure!
Love gone wrong: Good intentions, poor understanding, and blame game.
NTA: She projected her feelings onto you, ruining Christmas
NTA: A well-intentioned gift gone wrong, don’t blame yourself!
“NTA – Her sister is an AH trying to gaslight you “
ESH: $800 gift, no gift agreement, and accusations of causing seizure
Defending against unfair blame, hoping for a peaceful resolution. ✊
Flashing reminder of financial inequality sparks regret and resentment
NTA – Trying to make her happy backfired, seek therapy
YTA, but with good intentions. Time to have a heartfelt conversation. ❤️
Understanding her seizures is worth more than an $800 gift
Expensive gift caused hurt feelings and extreme reaction. ESH.
Thoughtful gestures over expensive gifts can make lasting memories
Expensive gift, broken promise, and a possible seizure? ESH indeed!
YTA for breaking agreement, causing stress, and triggering a seizure
Veterinary nurse explains the struggles of caring for an epileptic
YTA: Ignoring boundaries and power dynamics, causing discomfort
“YTA for disregarding her wishes and making her feel dependent.”
A heartwarming gesture turned into a hospital visit. Not the a**hole.
“YTA. You agreed not to get presents and then you gift her an $800 bag. How is she supposed to feel? You try to hide the fact that you’re starting competition when there’s no competition to be had. A nice quiet dinner would have worked much better than a materialistic display of dominance.”
“YTA for not supporting your gf’s Christmas. Be her partner “
OP’s well-intentioned gift backfires, causing unintended stress. ESH
YTA for breaking a promise and lacking empathy, causing conflict
YTA for ignoring her feelings and making the situation worse
NTA. Outrageous comments! Unappreciative partner blames you for seizure? Leave!
Ignoring her wishes hurt her. YTA for not respecting.
YTA for a misguided gift: unequal, dramatic, and controlling.
A personal story of epilepsy and understanding, with a soft YTA.
“YTA. You ignored her wishes and made it all about you.”
Independent partner, health issues, no blame, scary shit, not the a**hole
NTA. Well-intentioned gift turns into a rude and ungrateful disaster
“YTA. You broke your deal and bought an expensive gift.”
ESH for not respecting wishes, AH gf, and blaming sister
