Family Feud Over a Ghost Sibling: A Tale of Unseen Bonds and Unresolved Grief

Diply Social Team
Diply | Diply

Imagine this: you're part of a family that has a unique tradition, a tradition that involves honoring a sibling you've never met. This sibling passed away before you were born, yet his memory has been kept alive in your family through photos and annual visits to his grave. You've always felt uneasy about this, believing that if he had survived, your younger sister wouldn't exist. One day, your mother proposes a new family photo - one that includes a picture of this unseen sibling. Would you agree to participate? This is the dilemma our protagonist, who we'll call 'New Year Playboy', found himself in. Let's delve into his story.

The Unseen Sibling: A Heartbreaking Beginning

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

A Mother's Choice and a Short-lived Life

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

Keeping His Memory Alive

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

A Grave Visit I Always Decline

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

The Unseen Sibling's Impact on Family Dynamics

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

A Family Photo with a Ghost Sibling

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

A Mother's Wish and a Son's Refusal

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

The Unseen Sibling: A Brother I Never Knew

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

A Mother's Heartbreak

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

The Question of the Hour

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

A Change of Heart?

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

Understanding a Mother's Grief

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

A Step Towards Empathy

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

A New Perspective

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

The Unseen Sibling's Impact on Family Planning

itsanewyearplayboy | itsanewyearplayboy

Ghost Sibling, Unresolved Grief, and a Family Photo: A Tale of Unseen Bonds

Caught in a web of unseen bonds and unresolved grief, 'New Year Playboy' finds himself in a unique family situation. His mother wants to include a picture of their deceased sibling in a family photo, a sibling he never knew and doesn't consider his brother. This proposition sparks a family feud, with 'New Year Playboy' and his brother standing on one side, and their mother on the other. Despite the disagreement, this story leads to a journey of understanding and empathy, as 'New Year Playboy' begins to comprehend the depth of his mother's grief. Let's see what the internet thinks of this situation...

NTA, your mom needs professional help 😕

RatioNo1114 | RatioNo1114

NTA: Grief counseling can help your mother heal and cope.

lexisplays | lexisplays

Compassionate advice on unresolved grief and the power of communication. ✨

ICanDieRightNowPlz | ICanDieRightNowPlz

Mom's grief is present, but not out of control IMO. 🙏

Knittingfairy09113 | Knittingfairy09113

Engaging comment and insightful reply about sibling bonds and grief.

DinaFelice | DinaFelice

NTA. Mom's unresolved grief causing unhealthy expectations. Therapy needed. 💔

AdmirableWorth5325 | AdmirableWorth5325

YTA. Lack of empathy and denial of comfort to grieving mother. ❤

BrilliantFact7293 | BrilliantFact7293

Heartbreaking loss and differing perspectives on sibling relationships. 💔

crazyhairedjess2 | crazyhairedjess2

Grieving lost sibling while appreciating existing family: a complex balance

UnApprovedActivities | UnApprovedActivities

NTA. A tale of unseen bonds and resolved grief. 👏

Initial-Frosting4063 | Initial-Frosting4063

NTA, time to put the dead to rest. Mom needs therapy.

RedSealWitch | RedSealWitch

NAH. Remembering a lost sibling: love and understanding go far ❤️

bring_coffee_now | bring_coffee_now

Heartfelt remembrance: Mum's grief and family's understanding and choice.

sweetpeaz357 | sweetpeaz357

Heartbreaking choice or selfish act? A divisive debate unfolds. 😢

WetMonkeyTalk | WetMonkeyTalk

Heartfelt comment about honoring lost siblings and understanding parental grief ❤️

klasorbet | klasorbet

Heartbreaking loss, conflicting emotions, and the unseen bond of grief.

meganhbn | meganhbn

Including the unseen sibling in a family portrait matters ❤️

AndSoItGoes24 | AndSoItGoes24

NTA, mom needs grief counseling. Annual grave visit is normal.

DarkCheezus | DarkCheezus

Empathy and understanding are crucial in dealing with grief. 💔

LocalBrilliant5564 | LocalBrilliant5564

NTA: Encourage your mother to seek professional help for closure

geman11 | geman11

🤔 Confused about the connection between his death and your sister?

hunnypie777 | hunnypie777

Sharing deceased child's photos on Facebook: Is it appropriate? NTA.

JustbyLlama | JustbyLlama

NTA. Confront her about her grief counseling expectations. 🤔

JCBashBash | JCBashBash

Prolonged grief disorder: A personal journey of unseen bonds and solitude 😢

countrybumpkin1969 | countrybumpkin1969

Heartbreaking choice, but no regrets. Not the a**hole. ❤️

Otherwise_Beyond_572 | Otherwise_Beyond_572

Heartfelt comment about the bond between mothers and lost children ❤️

shortstack7070 | shortstack7070

Lack of empathy vs. burdening siblings with unseen memories 😒

46Vixen | 46Vixen

YTA for denying siblinghood. Show compassion for your grieving mother. 😡

Tigerboop | Tigerboop

Mother's grief shouldn't dictate how you grieve. Seek therapy. 💔

Ancient-Transition-4 | Ancient-Transition-4

"YTA. Your mom's grief is valid. You need therapy. 😢"

Individual_Baby_2418 | Individual_Baby_2418

Heartbreaking revelation sparks empathy and support for NTA

Careful-Victory-8138 | Careful-Victory-8138

Mom's grief manipulation: NTA for setting boundaries and moving on.

Anxious_Badger | Anxious_Badger

Mother's unresolved grief causing her to seek validation from others.

M0rg0th1 | M0rg0th1

Engaging caption: NTA, but mom's grief over ghost sibling is complex 😱

ElimGarakOfCardassia | ElimGarakOfCardassia

Understanding the pain and conflict on both sides. 🙏

YeedilyDeet | YeedilyDeet

Parents forcing kids to grieve? Not cool! Therapy needed 😓

FairyFartDaydreams | FairyFartDaydreams

NTA. This is weird. 🤔

Miss_Bobbiedoll | Miss_Bobbiedoll

Unseen bonds and unresolved grief: NAH, mom's grief is separate ❤️

3kidsnomoney--- | 3kidsnomoney---

The lasting impact of a lost sibling and judgmental attitudes 😢

Purple_Joke_1118 | Purple_Joke_1118

Unseen bonds and cherished memories of a lost sibling. 💞

Susie0701 | Susie0701

Heartbreaking tale of unresolved grief and its impact on family ❤️

SarHoLo | SarHoLo

Sibling photo drama: Denying mom's wish for a complete family

MARVEL-ous84 | MARVEL-ous84

Mom needs therapy. Grief counseling is necessary. 💔

gia_sesshoumaru | gia_sesshoumaru

A heartfelt perspective on grief and family dynamics. 💔

tszarathstra | tszarathstra

NTA. OP's siblings have no reason to take a picture with a ghost sibling 👻

AborigenalOrange | AborigenalOrange

Mom needs therapy! You're NTA for pointing it out 👍

SnooSongs7226 | SnooSongs7226

NTA. Unresolved grief: when mourning becomes manipulation. 💔

Lilac-Roses-Sunsets | Lilac-Roses-Sunsets

Unseen grief from a lost sibling affects family dynamics. 😢

purpleprose78 | purpleprose78

30 years later, unresolved grief and a mother's mental illness.

TheCallousBitch | TheCallousBitch

Empathy for both sides, unresolved grief, and the power of counseling.

[deleted] | [deleted]

Heartbreaking NTA story about a ghost sibling and unresolved grief 😢

almaclark | almaclark

Heartbreaking story of a mother's cruel actions and unresolved grief. 💔

Sinvisigoth | Sinvisigoth

Sibling rivalry and unresolved grief: NTA for setting boundaries 👍

Fluffy-lotus606 | Fluffy-lotus606

Bittersweet blessings: From loss to love, NTA's beautiful journey ❤️🙏

TheReinsofFullnight | TheReinsofFullnight

Engagingly empathetic comment and understanding of differing perspectives. 💜

recrucio | recrucio

NTA. Mother needs help. 🙏

[deleted] | [deleted]

Validating a mother's unusual request and exploring underlying guilt and grief.


Making mom happy is a simple yet rewarding act ❤️

lookingforassist | lookingforassist

Unseen bonds and unresolved grief: Understanding the love for ghost siblings ❤️

Sugarnspice44 | Sugarnspice44

A mother's enduring love for her lost child, with empathy.

Electrical_Age_6542 | Electrical_Age_6542

NAH. Mom needs counseling to heal from unseen sibling's loss.

Suchafatfatcat | Suchafatfatcat

Unseen bonds and unresolved grief shape a complex family dynamic. 💔

Acrobatic_End6355 | Acrobatic_End6355

Grief is personal, but you have the right to say no 😌

stuckNTX_plzsendHelp | stuckNTX_plzsendHelp

Understanding a mother's grief and finding common ground. 💜

makeshiftmarty | makeshiftmarty

Compassion vs Boundaries: Family Feud Over Unseen Bonds 💔

PercivalGrimm | PercivalGrimm

Sibling rivalry and unresolved grief: a delicate family dynamic 💔

Investment-Striking | Investment-Striking

Mom's insistence on grieving a non-viable baby divides opinions 🤔

deedoodledum | deedoodledum

Healing through grief: NTA's perspective on a lost twin 💔

BoysenberryNo4959 | BoysenberryNo4959

Filed Under: