We’ve all been there – caught in the middle of a heated debate between friends with opposing views. One man found himself in this exact situation when his friend Paul (34M) dragged him into an argument with Allie (30sF), a staunch believer in naturopathy. As a pharmaceutical industry professional, he was supposed to be Paul’s secret weapon against Allie’s anti-modern medicine stance. But was his response too condescending? Let’s dive into the story.
The Great Debate
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/383c9795-b244-46f1-affe-57cc95a3e738.png)
Paul’s Frustration
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3f017888-63be-49d5-8385-72f4d343f589.png)
Impressive Credentials
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/9438ccf4-2718-48fc-bd78-55fb5b9f926f.png)
The Secret Weapon Plan
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/1ea5397d-8137-407b-a714-e6a023b08cf6.png)
An Unwilling Participant ♂️
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/f95d1bb2-f6a3-41da-a574-014093a8bc4d.png)
The Surprise Encounter
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3ef79c93-3961-4e99-bb04-99aa9428cd82.png)
Avoiding the Topic
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/f832d7f4-a65a-4572-b0f4-70222aa57a7d.png)
The Confrontation Begins
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3c80910c-44e7-420d-909f-11f43bbd0ac0.png)
Shutting It Down
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/0f79e5fe-72b5-4809-8a44-649d0c75e807.png)
Accusations Fly ️
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/e59d6f4d-fbb0-4c37-a1aa-f637913e0e81.png)
An Awkward Exit
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/53e9baff-64f4-4f1e-9370-0f73f0482a37.png)
Paul’s Role ♂️
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/3c79e96e-33ae-4d02-b09c-3ea019cd3de9.png)
The Verdict: Condescending or Justified?
So, our pharma expert found himself in a tricky situation, unwillingly brought into a debate by his friend Paul. When confronted by Allie, he chose to shut down the conversation with a blunt response. Was he being condescending, or was he simply protecting himself from a potentially heated and unproductive argument? Let’s see what the internet thinks about this dramatic encounter.
NTA for shutting down naturopathy believer with hilarious cytokine storm comment

NTA shuts down naturopathy believer and friend’s argumentative behavior

NTA. Using “layperson” isn’t condescending, poor vocabulary isn’t faux pas.

Politely declining a debate at a party is NTA

NTA shuts down naturopathy believer, defends use of ‘lay person’.

Standing up to pseudoscience: NTA shuts down believer

NTA shuts down antivaxxer, receives appreciation

NTA shuts down naturopathy believer at party

Handling naturopathy believer with maturity. NTA wins!

Synonyms save the day in a debate about terminology.

Polite shutdown of a naturopathy believer, with a TA instigator

“I’m not having debates with people who are committed to misunderstanding me.”

Commenter questions use of ‘layperson’ and suggests nicer approach.

Woman gets shut down for pushing naturopathy beliefs

Polite ways to shut down anti-vaxxers, with a dog trainer’s twist

NTA shuts down essential oil believer with no regrets.

Naturopathy debunked: commenter shuts down believer with no mercy

NTA for avoiding conflict over naturopathy with AHs.

Naturopathy believer calls out ‘big pharma’, gets mad when shut down. NTA

Savage yet factual takedown of naturopathy believer.

Informing on the edge of truth, not changing minds. NTA

Pharmaceutical R&D worker shares frustrations with anti-pharma attacks.

NTA shuts down naturopathy believer with condescension

NTA commenter sympathizes with Paul’s frustration with Naturopathy believer

Expert opinion dismissed, commenter defends shutting down naturopathy believer.

Directness wins. Layperson offended? Their problem. NTA

User shares personal experience with naturopathy and supports OP’s response.

Commenter suggests better phrasing for conversation with naturopathy believer.

NTA shuts down naturopathy believer and praises Big Pharma

NTA shuts down naturopathy believer, sparks debate

Starting with ‘layperson’ was harsh, idiots have feelings too

NTA shuts down naturopathy believer politely

A comment on word choice sparks debate.

Agreeing with NTA: Pharma marketing is exhausting and futile

NTA shuts down naturopathy believer with baseball bat comment

Commenter praises someone for shutting down naturopathy believer.

Engaging in good faith conversations about medicine is important.

Directness vs Tact: Shutting Down Naturopathy Believers

Debate over inviting unvaccinated guests to events

Polite shutdown of naturopathy believer earns classy approval

Expertly shutting down a debate with a pharmaceutical burn. NTA

Support for naturopathy but pro-vaccine, pro-doctor, and pro-mask. NTA.

NTA shuts down anti-vaxxer, no changing minds

NTA shuts down anti-vaxxer and shares personal experience

Debate over the term ‘lay-person’ turns condescending.

Refusing a debate with a Naturopathy believer. NTA wins.

Polite response shuts down naturopathy believer

Lawyer defends man’s harsh response to naturopathy believer. NTA

Commenter suggests a more aggressive response to naturopathy believer.

NTA commenter suggests revenge and questions expertise of naturopathy believer.

Unqualified people giving medical advice can have deadly consequences. ⚠️

Sassy response to naturopathy believer’s rude attitude. NTA

Debate on naturopathy vs modern medicine gets heated

NTA shuts down combative naturopathy believer with honesty

Insulting a ‘Karen’ for being anti-vax: NAH or ESH?
![Image credit: [deleted] | [deleted]](https://static.diply.com/5d3bb089-2e72-453c-8a09-c1b9a973b5f2.png)
Public health worker shuts down naturopathy believer: NTA

Pharmacologist calls naturopathy believers idiots, but acknowledges need for public education.
