Dinner Party Dilemma: 500+ Pound Brother-In-Law Left Off Guest List 🍽️😱

Diply Social Team
Diply | Diply

Imagine spending months creating the perfect dining room for your spouse's dream dinner party, only to have it turn into a family feud. One couple found themselves in this exact predicament when they decided not to invite the wife's 500+ pound brother-in-law to their fancy dinner party. The reasons for the exclusion range from concerns about the brother-in-law's ability to sit in their new dining chairs to past incidents of him harassing the wife over her cooking. But was this decision justified or just plain cruel? Let's dive into the story. 🕵️‍♀️🍽️

Dream Dining Room Project 🏠✨

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

The Dinner Party Plan 🍽️🥂

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

One Family Member Left Out 👀

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

The Weighty Issue 🏋️‍♂️

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Alternative Seating Options ❌

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Not Just About the Weight ⚖️

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

The Uninvited Call 📞

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Accusations of Bigotry 😡

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Standing Firm on the Decision 💪

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Family Fallout 🌪️

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Mixed Reactions 😶

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Clarifications and Limitations 📝

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Medical Chair Not an Option 🚫

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Sister's Involvement 👩

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

Avoiding Personal Attacks 🛡️

fair_ad5874 | fair_ad5874

A Dream Dinner Party Turns Sour 😞🍽️

So, what started as a dream dinner party to celebrate the completion of a beautiful dining room project quickly turned into a family feud. The couple's decision to exclude the wife's 500+ pound brother-in-law from the guest list sparked outrage among some family members. With accusations of fat-phobia and elitism flying, the husband stands firm, stating that the night is about his wife's dream, not accommodating the brother-in-law's weight and food issues. Let's see what the internet thinks of this sticky situation... 🌐🔥

Excluding BIL due to his weight and rudeness: NTA.

sapphirecupcake8 | sapphirecupcake8

Excluding 500+ lb brother-in-law from dinner party: justified or cruel? 🤔

captainkaiju | captainkaiju

Excluding 500+ pound brother-in-law from dinner party: NTA

TinyRascalSaurus | TinyRascalSaurus

Logistical realities of not being able to attend dinner parties 🤷🏼‍♂️

Key-Bit1208 | Key-Bit1208

Balancing health concern and fatphobia in guest list decisions 🤔

Tiseye | Tiseye

Excluding 500+ lb brother-in-law from dinner party: NTA

RideTheWindForever | RideTheWindForever

Navigating family dynamics during events can be tricky 👮🏻‍♂️, but prioritizing inclusivity can lead to hurt feelings 😢.

LexifurTheCat | LexifurTheCat

Excluding him is justified, he's a bad guest. 🙄

BeeYehWoo | BeeYehWoo

Tough love is necessary. NTA 👏

Wombatseal | Wombatseal

Difficult situation. If he can't stand, can't move party. NTA.

Msmediator | Msmediator

NTA for excluding 500+ pound brother-in-law from dinner party.

ThistleFaun | ThistleFaun

Setting boundaries with aggressive brother-in-law, NTA 👍

rainbowtwilightshy | rainbowtwilightshy

Inviting sister but not BIL to dinner party causes drama 🤷🏻‍♂️

AimMick | AimMick

Hosting a dinner party, but leaving out 500+ pound brother-in-law?

MiskatonicUAlum | MiskatonicUAlum

Commenter sympathizes with host, others share seat struggles 😕

Bird_Brain4101112 | Bird_Brain4101112

Excluding 500+ pound BIL from dinner party: NTA

mouldydoritos | mouldydoritos

Excluding 500+ pound brother-in-law from dinner party: NTA

shadow-foxe | shadow-foxe

Stand your ground and keep your dinner party drama-free. NTA 👍

Zoeyoe | Zoeyoe

Commenter stands up for host and calls out entitled behavior.

teijinator2000 | teijinator2000

Excluding drama-causing, food-hogging brother-in-law from dinner party. NTA.

steph-highfill77 | steph-highfill77

NTA - Enabling has led to entitlement and a 500+ pound brother-in-law.

binarysolo_0000001 | binarysolo_0000001

Commenter calls out AITA culture on social media.

doggirlie | doggirlie

Focus on behavior, not weight. Address disrespect towards sister politely.

Physical-Energy-6982 | Physical-Energy-6982

Sibling loyalty or party etiquette? Navigating family gatherings 🤔

PenguKitter-ta7 | PenguKitter-ta7

Excluding 500+ lb brother-in-law from dinner party: NTA.

Blahtyblah91 | Blahtyblah91

Compassionate response to difficult family situation 😊

[deleted] | [deleted]

Encouraging weight loss or body shaming? NTA comment sparks debate.

[deleted] | [deleted]

Don't let others' insecurities weigh you down 💪

stoneyselly | stoneyselly

Excluding him for being an AH? NTA, but tread carefully.

edgarallanpotatoe | edgarallanpotatoe

Don't blame OP for not inviting 500+ pound BIL 🙄

BlaqueDaliah | BlaqueDaliah

Excluding 500+ pound brother-in-law from dinner party for safety reasons. NTA.

CrystalQueen3000 | CrystalQueen3000

Setting boundaries for a healthier relationship with food and family 👍

rhorn2005 | rhorn2005

Avoiding drama at family gatherings, NTA suggests excluding brother-in-law.

Steemboatwilly | Steemboatwilly

Hospital dilemma: refusing surgery due to weight. NTA.

tanybl_01 | tanybl_01

Inviting only his wife was rude and opened a can of worms 😕

Brainjacker | Brainjacker

No dinner for the food hogging, rude brother-in-law 🙄

ConcentrateRegular79 | ConcentrateRegular79

Calling out the enabler and defending the decision. NTA 👍

SilverQueenBee | SilverQueenBee

Excluding abusive 500+lb brother-in-law from dinner party: NTA 👏

Celestial-Salamander | Celestial-Salamander

Commenter calls out 500+ pound brother-in-law, sparks agreement.

[deleted] | [deleted]

Excluding disabled family member was rude, but safety concerns valid ⚠️

AltDogBarkBarkBark | AltDogBarkBarkBark

Horse not invited to dinner party, known to bite host. NTA.

blablamcbla | blablamcbla

Prioritizing feelings and finding creative solutions for dinner party drama 🤔

RosieRustyRiley | RosieRustyRiley

Inclusive hosting: accommodating guests with medical needs 👨‍🏫

freddyfazzballs | freddyfazzballs

500+ pound brother-in-law left off guest list for valid reasons 🙌

potatobugblue | potatobugblue

Commenter thinks host is not the a**hole for excluding brother-in-law

[deleted] | [deleted]

Handling a weight-sensitive situation with grace and empathy 🙏

Quicksilver1964 | Quicksilver1964

Clear judgement, no a**holes here! 👍

plastigbagbitch | plastigbagbitch

Size and rudeness are not invited to dinner parties 🥴

cynical_old_mare | cynical_old_mare

Commenter believes host is not the a**hole. 👍

MrsEllaneously | MrsEllaneously

No drama here, commenter approves of guest list decision 👍

13miyoun | 13miyoun

Inviting only one half of a married couple, ESH.

Jewish-Mom-123 | Jewish-Mom-123

Excluding 500+ pound brother-in-law from dinner party: NTA

kschin1 | kschin1

dontbelievethefife | dontbelievethefife

Addressing rudeness over disability is key. NTA.

MidniteProph | MidniteProph

Logical and reasonable decision, NTA. Considered his past behavior towards wife.

No_Communication9556 | No_Communication9556

Excluding 500+ lb BIL from party: How to do it respectfully 🙏

yavanna12 | yavanna12

Excluding 500+ lb brother-in-law from dinner party: NTA

FloatingPencil | FloatingPencil

Excluding the 500+ pound BIL from dinner party: NTA.

PadLakeEagle847 | PadLakeEagle847

Stand your ground! You have the right to choose guests 🙌

YeouPink | YeouPink

Your home, your rules. NTA 👍

RobertBDwyer | RobertBDwyer

Excluding BIL from dinner party understandable but excluding spouse not wise 😕

[deleted] | [deleted]

Excluding 500+ lb brother-in-law from dinner party: NTA 👍

[deleted] | [deleted]

Filed Under: