Daughter Refuses Guardianship of Dad's Baby: Was She Too Harsh? 😲

Diply Social Team
Diply | Diply

Imagine being a 37-year-old woman with four kids of your own, and your 65-year-old dad decides to have another baby with his third wife. Now, he wants you to be the guardian of the baby in case the worst happens. Sounds like a tough situation, right? Well, that's exactly what happened to one woman, and she's now questioning her dad's decision to have a child at his age. Let's dive into the story and see if you think she's being too harsh or just being honest. 🤷‍♀️

A Family of Many Ages

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Dad's New Baby

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Guardianship Dilemma

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Baby-Free Future

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Dad's Will Update

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Daughter's Refusal

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Dad's Disappointment

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Daughter's Explanation

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Dad's Assurance

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Daughter's Response

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Dad's Reaction

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Daughter's Stance

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

Questioning Dad's Choices

honest_scallion_2768 | honest_scallion_2768

A Guardianship Quandary: Who's in the Wrong? 🧐

So, here's the dilemma: a 37-year-old woman with four kids of her own is asked by her 65-year-old dad to be the guardian of his new baby. She refuses, citing her own family's needs and her dad's age as reasons. Dad gets upset, accusing her of favoritism and not caring about the baby's future. The daughter stands her ground, questioning her dad's decision to have a child at his age. Was she too harsh, or just being honest? Let's see what the internet has to say about this family drama... 💬

NTA for not wanting to take on more responsibility at mid-30s

erikarew | erikarew

Guardianship debate: Daughter refuses baby, is she in the wrong? 😕

Fragrant_Style_2629 | Fragrant_Style_2629

NTA for refusing guardianship of dad's baby at 65 😍

Prestigious_Detail_9 | Prestigious_Detail_9

Daughter refuses guardianship of half-sibling, calls out father's irresponsibility. 😍

[deleted] | [deleted]

NTA for refusing guardianship of dad's baby at 65 😊

La_Murano | La_Murano

Responsible daughter refuses guardianship of father's baby. NTA 👏

GingerMinx6 | GingerMinx6

NTA refuses guardianship of dad's baby due to unfair will 😍

Elfich47 | Elfich47

Daughter refuses guardianship of dad's baby, NTA. 👏

starredandfeathered | starredandfeathered

Clear and concise: Daughter not responsible for dad's baby 👍

Ok_Garden5983 | Ok_Garden5983

Daughter declines guardianship of dad's baby, NTA. Teens are easier.

MarlyCat118 | MarlyCat118

Daughter rightfully refuses guardianship of father's baby 😍

Ok_Smell_8260 | Ok_Smell_8260

Daughter refuses to raise dad's baby, suggests he asks others 😍

ColdstreamCapple | ColdstreamCapple

Daughter stands up for herself and earns NTA judgement 👏

Red_Cathy | Red_Cathy

Planned baby or not, dad's still TA for expecting commitment.

DaydreamerFly | DaydreamerFly

Sibling refuses guardianship of new baby, NTA 👏

del901 | del901

Daughter refuses guardianship, was dad wrong? 😕

Jubatus2point0 | Jubatus2point0

Dad's irresponsibility leads to daughter's NTA response 😕

Pretend-Panda | Pretend-Panda

Responsibility of guardianship explained. NTA for refusing.

cranbeery | cranbeery

Daughter calls out dad's selfishness and 25-year age gap 🤪

SubRedditLurker08 | SubRedditLurker08

Saying no to guardianship is justified. Age matters 😲

[deleted] | [deleted]

Daughter makes responsible decision to not take on guardianship. 👍

SeminolesFan1 | SeminolesFan1

Daughter refuses to raise dad's 3rd family, sparks debate 🤔

mekareami | mekareami

Daughter stands her ground, refusing guardianship for dad's baby. 🙌

Educational-Truth479 | Educational-Truth479

NTA suggests wife should take care of baby if husband passes. 😍

Logical_Childhood733 | Logical_Childhood733

Daughter not responsible for dad's baby. NTA 👍

[deleted] | [deleted]

Respectful boundaries: Daughter not obligated to care for father's baby. 🙏

kylecs7637 | kylecs7637

Not the a**hole. But what led to this decision?

Loll1gag | Loll1gag

Guardianship request unfair to daughter, NTA. 🙅‍♀️

RideTheWindForever | RideTheWindForever

Planning for the worst or unnecessary precaution? 🤔

SnooCats6410 | SnooCats6410

Guardianship not required for dad's bad choices. NTA 👍

EntrepreneurAmazing3 | EntrepreneurAmazing3

Age is just a number, but having a baby at 65?

chubbywhiteboy420 | chubbywhiteboy420

Sibling refused guardianship of younger siblings, no regrets. 🙌

Copper__Phoenix | Copper__Phoenix

Child of older parent defends OP's decision to refuse guardianship.

Pristine-Vehicle-955 | Pristine-Vehicle-955

Respect your boundaries, you're not obligated to take on baby. 👍

asphodel2020 | asphodel2020

NTA. Prioritizing own family and retirement plans over father's baby.

Wonderful_Ad968 | Wonderful_Ad968

Age of the mother sparks unnecessary conflict 😒

mindbird | mindbird

Not the a**hole, but why? Tell us more! 🤔

TheLavenderAuthor | TheLavenderAuthor

Commenter defends daughter's decision to refuse guardianship of baby 😊

RyzenTide | RyzenTide

Controversial opinion on procreation sparks debate. 🤔

NancyNuggets | NancyNuggets

Choosing a reluctant guardian can harm the child's future 😔

dancingpianofairy | dancingpianofairy

Guardianship should come with fiscal support. NTA for refusing.

VaginaNarritives | VaginaNarritives

Daughter stands her ground on refusing guardianship. 💪

Jensooverstupid | Jensooverstupid

Choosing not to take responsibility. 🤷‍♀️

DifferentPen6715 | DifferentPen6715

Legal explanation of guardianship and trust arrangements for minor children.

No-Idea-Y-Im-here | No-Idea-Y-Im-here

Daughter refuses guardianship of dad's baby due to his irresponsibility. NTA 👍

Initial_Number_4747 | Initial_Number_4747

Consider the consequences of refusing guardianship. 💭💰

FatLouie_84 | FatLouie_84

Daughter refuses guardianship of dad's baby and gets support.

Altruistic_Bench_473 | Altruistic_Bench_473

Setting boundaries with family: NTA daughter refuses guardianship.

[deleted] | [deleted]

Daughter stands her ground on dad's poor family planning 😏

ThunderandFury | ThunderandFury

Setting boundaries and speaking the truth is not being harsh 👍

bringmethemashup | bringmethemashup

User questions father's decision to have kids late in life.

Weird_Biscuits9668 | Weird_Biscuits9668

Mother's input ignored in dad's unilateral decision for guardianship. NTA.

JCWa50 | JCWa50

A man's friend has a 4-year-old daughter at 68. NTA for refusing guardianship.

nattybird | nattybird

Stepmom to the rescue? A comment suggests a solution 🤔

erayer | erayer

Age is just a number, but NTA for refusing guardianship 😊

CanUFeelItMrKrabs | CanUFeelItMrKrabs

Commenter believes state decides guardianship, not daughter. 😍

junglequeen88 | junglequeen88

Daughter makes tough call on guardianship, stands her ground. 💪

UnderstandingAway302 | UnderstandingAway302

User defends daughter's decision to not take guardianship of baby.

bjrharding | bjrharding

Daughter refuses guardianship of dad's baby, and she's not wrong 🙏

tiny222 | tiny222

Legal and ethical implications of willing a child discussed 🤔

StAlvis | StAlvis

Mother's child, not the father's to will. NTA.

Lawlesseyes | Lawlesseyes

Setting boundaries with family - NTA 👍

lordarcanite | lordarcanite

Curious why the mother wasn't considered for guardianship? 🤔

ef9357 | ef9357

NTA commenter shares experience with older father's desire for kids.

Separate_Ingenuity35 | Separate_Ingenuity35

Legal guardianship doesn't require living with the child. NTA.

farsical111 | farsical111

Daughter stands up for herself and sets boundaries with dad. 👏

EdwardAlphonse31011 | EdwardAlphonse31011

Daughter refuses guardianship of dad's baby due to lack of planning 😲

RevKyriel | RevKyriel

Daughter refuses guardianship of dad's baby: harsh or justified? 🤔

Tehloneranger44 | Tehloneranger44

Daughter refuses guardianship of dad's baby and calls him dumb. 😬

Heckate666 | Heckate666

Legal expert explains guardianship confusion. No need to worry 😊

Tollhousearebest | Tollhousearebest

Standing up for yourself and setting boundaries. 💪

nightcana | nightcana

Standing up to a self-involved parent. NTA 💯

FullFeeling | FullFeeling

Daughter refuses guardianship of dad's baby, commenters support her.

all-that-is-given | all-that-is-given

NTA for refusing guardianship. Raising a child is a huge responsibility. 🙏

FrederickChase | FrederickChase

Daughter rightfully refuses guardianship, commenters agree. 👏

Audneth | Audneth

User thinks dad is a repeat offender. 🤔

[deleted] | [deleted]

40-year-old wife missing in guardianship debate 🤔

I_might_be_weasel | I_might_be_weasel

Filed Under: